By Cliff Rold
An undefeated former Olympian as champion; an aging Hall of Famer with some quality rounds left in him; a solid set of tested veterans; two dangerous heirs apparent chomping at the bit. In an excellent 2007 for the sport of professional boxing, that description of any weight division sounds like explosive par for the course.
Unless that weight division is Light Heavyweight.
The description of the players is correct. It’s the explosion that has been lacking. 2007 got off to a promising start for the 175 lb. realm, but a series of cancellations, ducks, and seeming disregard from the two men who hold the strongest claim to the label of ‘champion’ have brought us to the ultimate example of a division gone wrong:
Antonio Tarver (25-4, 18 KO, Ring Magazine #3) v. Danny Santiago (29-3-1, 19 KO, unrated)
This would be a bad matchup on ESPN. It’s an awful one in the main event of the final “Championship Boxing” show of the year on Showtime. The fact that it bookends with an earlier Light Heavyweight entry on the same network, Chad Dawson’s rousing February 3rd victory for the WBC belt over Tomasz Adamek, says a lot about what didn’t happen this year.
It starts at the top.
More importantly, it starts with the mess at the top. The lineal champion of the division, 33-year old 2000 Olympic Gold Medalist Zsolt Erdei (28-0, 17 KO, WBO titlist) of Hungary notched the ninth defense of the title he won against Julio Gonzalez in 2004. Number nine came last Saturday against Tito Mendoza (36-8, 28 KO), a challenge consistent with the level of opponent Erdei seems content lately to mark his reign with, stretching out his line of safe paydays without stretching him to find out how good he just might be.
Most Americans have never heard of Erdei. Those that have are given no reason to demand the rectification of a historical split in the title that has been in place since the days of Dariusz Michalzewski and Roy Jones given his recent opposition. It’s a shame. Erdei has talent, and has defeated some quality opponents as champion (Hugo Garay, Mehdi Sahnoune, Thomas Ulrich), but Mendoza completed a 2007 trifecta of mediocre and less that also included easy stoppages of a woeful George Blades and the aforementioned Santiago, a fight as lacking in competitiveness as the challengers credentials suggested it would.
In short, Erdei remains the strongest argument for those who feel that the concept of titles needing to move from ‘the man who beat the man’ is, if not outdated, in need of caveats.
Of course, I note the split because many in the U.S. press, even those that know better, will often refer to Ring Magazine titlist Bernard Hopkins as THE light-heavyweight champion of the world. On face, there shouldn’t be much problem with that. Hopkins defeated Tarver after a superlative round-robin that roped in Tarver, Jones, Glenn Johnson and Eric Harding from 2002-2005. It doesn’t hurt that Hopkins had just finished the best run at Middleweight since Marvin Hagler.
Of course, though, there is one small problem: while he loves to point at his title belt, Hopkins seems less than interested in being the Light Heavyweight champion in the ring. His win over Tarver was marked by a retirement announcement that never developed into a retirement; a year-long layoff; and then a single bout in 2007 against leading Middleweight contender Winky Wright last July. That has been followed not only by another layoff but months without so much as the hint of a fight negotiation until the days following World Super Middleweight champion Joe Calzaghe’s decisive victory over Mikkel Kessler three weeks ago. That fight may happen in the spring and, if it does, it could be great for boxing.
But make no mistake: if Hopkins were to beat Calzaghe, he would hit the two-year mark as the popularly recognized champion without facing a top-ten light heavyweight contender, something even Erdei has done a couple of times. That might be good for Hopkins financially, and with a win over Wright and potential victory versus Calzaghe it’s good for him in terms of elevating his all-time standing, but it’s not good for the state of the division.
The only upside to Hopkins relaxed schedule is that, turning 43 in January, he may retire before stretching that run to three years.
Below Erdei’s un-champion like 2007 schedule and the Hopkins cameo appearance, one fighter does seem to want to do the work to deserve the mantle of king. It appears he has the tools to do so as well which is why it’s not so shocking that his desires have been hard to accommodate. The 25-year old Dawson (25-0, 17 KO, #5, WBC titlist) of New Haven, Connecticut has not only talked and walked it, he’s even signed for it.
As noted, his win over the rugged Adamek, one that followed a dominant victory over a then-top ten rated Harding in June 2006, seemed the precursor of a great run the division in general but especially for “Bad” Chad. A stay bust fight with journeyman Jesus Ruiz in June was anticipated to be a set-up for a showdown with Tarver but, when negotiations for that fight stalemated, Dawson turned to a mandatory assignment ripe with risk and less financial reward. That assignment was to be a September showdown with 29-year old Canadian-based Romanian Adrian Diaconu (24-0, 15 KO, #8).
It wouldn’t have grabbed mainstream headlines, but the announcement of the bout generated legitimate buzz amongst the hardcore faithful and would have forced a lot of channel flipping as it was scheduled to go head-to-head with the Middleweight showdown between Jermain Taylor and Kelly Pavlik. As was only fitting in a year gone wrong, Diaconu was forced to pull out of the fight for medical reasons, pushing that tantalizing match-up back to 2008. Dawson versus Epifanio Mendoza didn’t leave many fingerprints on remotes.
Through no fault of his own, Dawson finds himself ending 2007 pretty much where he started, waiting to take the big step from probably to is. That makes him a symbol for the division itself.
So with champions who aren’t living up to their crowns and two young tigers just missing each other, one would hope that the rest of the division could at least make some compelling matches to pick up the slack. That hasn’t happened either. Brit Clinton Woods (41-3-1, 24 KO, #2, IBF title): one easy win in 2007 against a Julio Gonzalez he’d already defeated in lopsided fashion. Exciting #6 contender Paul Briggs (26-3, 18 KO) of Australia: one win so far against Willie Standup last February. To Briggs credit, he is lined up for a December 16th showdown with Stipe Drews (32-1, 13 KO, #10, WBA titlist) in a fight that could bail out the rest of a lackluster year with some needed fireworks.
Then, of course, there’s Glenn Johnson.
Johnson (46-11-2, 31 KO, #4), a former Ring titlist and conqueror of both Tarver and Jones, can’t seem to buy a big fight. Even the eager Dawson’s camp hasn’t seemed the least bit interested. Johnson bounced back this year from a highly debatable hometown decision loss to Woods in their September 2006 rubber match with two knockout wins in 2007, one against a still-viable former titlist in Montell Griffin. Long a victim of shady judging, Johnson now stands as a victim of his own success at 38-years old. The late-peaking warrior remains perhaps the most entertaining fighter in his class, a come forward volume puncher willing to take some to land some, and he has a monster chin to go with it. The division-wide refusal to acknowledge that Johnson is still here is a pox on the whole house.
Tarver?
Well, Tarver is interesting. He’s been in full rhetorical war mode lately, insisting that he’s being disrespected. I can sort of understand his position. Tarver was often discounted during his best days, written off as an unworthy rival to Roy Jones. He was also, along with lightweight Diego Corrales, the model for what every fan and pundit should expect and demand of a championship-level fighter in the 2-3 fight a year era.
From his first loss in 1999 to Harding to his last against Hopkins in 2006, Tarver consistently fought nothing but top ten contenders, titlists and big names. The risks rewarded him and proved that a fighter could make money, face consistent top opposition and reach a high level of achievement.
That seems long ago with what’s on tap in a Santiago who is making his first start since his KO loss to Erdei. The only thing worse than fighting Erdei’s 2007 schedule is fighting Erdei’s leftovers and then playing the victim. No matter what you might hear from Mr. Mason Dixon himself, it was Tarver who lost almost every second of his fight with Hopkins and it’s Tarver who is responsible for making fans and pundits care about his career again. This fight, coupled with his June bout against Santiago stoppage victim Elvir Muriqui, isn’t cutting it.
The obligation to ‘make them care’ is one he shares with the rest of the field. With all this naysaying, it’s a relief that one can find some reasons to be optimistic. The division is only as disappointing as it is because there are quality matches to be made. It’s unlikely that next year will be as sparse as this one.
Beneath all the ego, greed and legacy securing of 2007, there are some fights on the horizon in 2008. Dawson-Diaconu is all but a guarantee to occur. Hopkins-Calzaghe would pit two Hall of Famers against each other. January’s Roy Jones-Felix Trinidad bout will at least garner attention that can be parlayed into another fight later in the year, perhaps even Roy Jones pursuing a WBO mandatory position against Erdei or a WBA mandatory versus the Drews-Briggs winner. Tarver could also fit nicely with one of those two, meaning that we could get a solid mix of old and new names in the new year.
And then there’s Glenn Johnson. The IBF currently has him slated as a mandatory so he’ll probably get Woods again and, judging in their previous bouts aside, those two just mix in entertaining fashion.
Let’s hope it all comes out along these lines. If enough of the woulds, coulds and shoulds come together, then 2008 won’t end with questions of what’s wrong at Light Heavyweight. Instead, we can just ask for more.
Cliff’s Notes…
Showtime: Just to be fair, have to give a little credit to a Showtime undercard this weekend which will feature exciting flyweight Nonito Donaire (18-1, 11 KO) in his first start since stopping Vic Darchinyan in what may have been the knockout of the year. He’ll be matched in a competitive bout with a Luis Maldonando (37-1-1, 28 KO) whose only loss was to the power-punching Darchinyan and who also has a draw with the excellent Cristian Mijares on his ledger. This fight is worth a look whether you stick around afterwards or not…
Forrest-Piccirillo: The other bout on the televised card matches Jr. Middleweights as former World Welterweight champion Vernon Forrest (39-2, 28 KO, #4 at 154 lbs., WBC titlist) faces Michele Piccirillo (48-3, 30 KO). Almost no one expects this bout to be the least bit fan friendly, but Forrest turned low expectations for bouts against Ike Quartey and Carlos Baldomir into watchable entertainment so who knows. Maybe this battle of Ricardo Mayorga victims surprises. After he wins, Forrest versus Roman Karmazin is a heck of a fight by the way…
Mayorga: Speaking of Mayorga, his win against Fernando Vargas last week won’t get him back in any serious title chases but, win or lose, he remains captivating in the ring…
Nearing a Superfight: Back next week with an enthusiastic look at Mayweather-Hatton. Call me a sucker but 24/7 just has me even more jazzed for this one, and I’ve always thought these two matched up well.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com