By Cliff Rold
Every division goes through its cycles. There are periods of dominant champions, periods of hot potato title changes, parity from depth or a lack thereof.
Light Heavyweight has had some of the wilder cycles throughout the history of the sport. Prior to the birth of the Cruiserweights, and a growth in the Heavyweight division, many of the cycles were about money. Billy Conn could probably have reigned for years at 175 lbs.
It was more profitable not to.
The 1970s and the first half of the 1980s saw the best of both worlds with a dominant champion for part of the decade in Bob Foster, an era of incredibly talented parity featuring men like Victor Galindez, Matthew Saad Muhammad, and Marvin Johnson, and then the consolidation of the division behind the great Michael Spinks.
After Spinks, the cycle was a bit down. Good but not great fighters like Virgil Hill, Charles Williams and Henry Maske all made their marks, but nothing ever really popped. The twin title reigns of Roy Jones and Dariusz Michalczewski in the late 1990s were more remarkable for the men’s ability to avoid each other than most of what happened in the ring.
The 2000s turned out to be one of the up periods for the division. While its strength in comparison to other eras is debatable, a crew featuring Eric Harding, Clinton Woods, Antonio Tarver, Jones, Bernard Hopkins, and Joe Calzaghe at various times was never dull.
41-year old former Ring and IBF Light Heavyweight titlist Glen Johnson (49-13-2, 33 KO) was a big part of the equation as well. This Friday night, he’ll be trying to stay in the equation as a new decade kicks off. 30-year old Yusaf Mack (28-2-2, 17 KO) won’t be interested in those aspirations. It’s a crossroads fight of sorts between two men who have serious questions to answer.
For Mack, the questions are about whether he can truly cross the bridge into elite levels of competition. Mack has a lot going for him. He’s got sneaky speed and can crack. He’s also had defensive and stamina deficiencies that have held him back. Both his losses, to Librado Andrade and Alejandro Berrio, came via knockout. His best win arguably came last year, an upset of the exciting but limited Chris Henry.
Johnson is a step above all of those men and Mack has to answer the question of whether he can truly compete with someone of Johnson’s experience and caliber.
Johnson has to answer the question of whether he’s still Johnson anymore.
Despite his many losses, Johnson has been one of those fighter who age very well. Even if it can be taken for granted that many of the losses on his ledger were of the headscratching scoring variety, many others were just the process of making him what he was for much of the 00’s.
Johnson was a tank.
Holding his hands high and dropping his jab like an axe-handle, Johnson pressured and hustled his way to decision wins over Tarver and Woods. He laid Jones out like an ironing board. Many thought he earned the nod over Chad Dawson in 2008.
The tank looked rusty in the Dawson rematch. Johnson was made ineffectual by the younger, faster man for most of twelve rounds last November in perhaps his worst outing since his lone stoppage loss, as a Middleweight in 1997, to Bernard Hopkins. With everything he brings in to the ring, all of the effort he exerts, it’s only logical that the wear and rounds will catch up.
Is that what began to happen in the Dawson rematch?
Is Mack good enough to find out?
The questions matter in the context of the fight alone but there is also a bigger picture. Johnson and Mack aren’t fighting just for a check. The winner in this, an IBF eliminator, moves to the front of the contention line for a crack at 28-year old Light Heavyweight beltholder Tavoris Cloud (20-0, 18 KO).
Beyond the question of whether fans will be treated later this year to Cloud-Johnson or Cloud-Mack, there are also things yet to be asked about the exciting young titlist. Heavy-handed and aggressive, Cloud looks the part of a Light Heavyweight to get excited about. However, with a schedule that has seen him fight only three times in the last two years, and career best wins to date over aged versions of Julio Gonzalez and Woods for his belt last year, Cloud has more proving to do.
A Johnson who can perform well enough against Mack to say, “I’m still fine; Dawson was just really good in the rematch,” can help in that proving.
A Mack who can show he’s ready to get over the hump, combining physical talent with consistent results, carries enough sock to test the chin of Cloud.
Those tests will matter because asking whether Johnson is finally getting past it is as much about him as it is his Light Heavyweight era. There is an interesting split at 175 lbs. right now with three young lions in Dawson (29-0, 17 KO), WBC titlist Jean Pascal (25-1, 16 KO) and Cloud contrasted against still lingering versions of Johnson, Jones, Hopkins, and Tarver. Tarver and Johnson have already lost two apiece to Johnson. Hopkins and Jones are fighting each other soon.
The younger men will increasingly be looking to each other to define their place.
The older men will still be around to ask them if they’re ready.
We’ll find out Friday if one of those old men still has enough answers to be a question again later this year.
Weekly Ledger
But wait, there’s more…
Brinkley-Stevens Coverage: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=25002
ShoBox Coverage: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=25005
Mayweather/Pacquiao: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=25028
Ratings Update: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=25044
Picks of the Week: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=25072
Cliff’s Notes…
It’s hard to get excited about a Lucian Bute-Edison Miranda fight but it also reflects the position Bute is in at Super Middleweight with no Super Six. If he keeps winning, there will be opportunities in the form of challenges from below and above on the scale…Only in the internet age can a guy taking a couple days to check off on a fight contract become fodder for apoplectic response…Based on the current Ring Ratings, the proposed Koki Kameda-Pongsaklek Wonjongkam fight would mean a new Ring Champion at Flyweight. Why is that funny? Because all it would do is further confirm the lineage of the title, a lineage traceable in their own back issue stacks. Be forewarned about any language that might suggest this would crown anything when the fight becomes official. There’s no credit for backing into a truth that’s been there all along…Comic nerd alert: Superman meets the Justice Society this Friday on Smallville…Who Dat say dey gon’ beat ‘dem Saints? Not the Colts.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com