By Ryan Songalia
Photo © Ed Mulholland/FightWireImages
Muhammad Ali once proclaimed "It isn't bragging if you can do it." When Paulie Malignaggi failed to live up to the lofty expectations set by his own mouth prior to his encounter with Miguel Cotto, a sense of schadenfreude, a German term used to denote enjoyment in another's misery, prevailed within public opinion.
Just as has been the case with other notorious self-promoters like Hector Camacho and Antonio Tarver, once they fell to the fists of an opponent, critic's and fans alike rejoiced at seeing a loud mouth get what they felt he had coming to him. Battered and bruised after a hard-fought twelve round contest, Malignaggi was forced to face the music for which his own mouth was the conductor of.
When I last spoke with the loquacious Malignaggi at the Manhattan Center in December, his appearance was the portrait of inner peace. Nowhere in his profile was there a hint of bitterness about the way things unfolded just across the street at Madison Square Garden last June. His cheerful demeanor and willingness to interact with the fans belied a realistic sense of self, a trait that is lost sometimes amidst the verbiage of a Malignaggi vocal assault.
Malignaggi, for all of the hype and perceptions, is not the cocky, self-proclaiming larger-than-life character that he has been projected as at times. Is he confident? Is he ever.
The eloquence that emits from Paulie's comments to the press underlie his intelligence; the kid is smart. While supremely confident in his abilities, there are some that have described him as shy, which is a term contradictory to his image.
"Malignaggi is a flashy dresser with a big mouth who's basically a good guy," asesses Thomas Hauser, noted author and literary laurete. "He's also a walking poster boy for hair gel and wears so many tassels on his boxing shoes that it's like fighting with five-pound weights on his feet."
"Outside of the ring he is on the coolest guys around," asserts fellow Brooklynite and friend Dmitriy "Star of David" Salita. "Paul is very ambitious and hungry to establish himself in the ring. Not too many people gave him a chance to be where he is at right now. He accomplished a lot and I think will accomplish even more."
Bottom line, his public image as a loud mouth braggart is more a publicity tactic than a realistic measurement of his character. What, you thought Cotto would carry the publicity for their fight?
Of course, there is the showboating. Often done to his own detriment, it does however liven up otherwise monotonous action.
"I'm always trying to entertain," states Malignaggi, the Brooklyn native. "Sometimes you have the part of me that wants to have some fun in there because the fight gets pretty repetitive at times with guys that I'm winning every round with. People think I choreograph the showboating like I go in there to clown. I don't go in there to clown, I go in there to win the fight."
"They see this crazy guy on camera and they don't understand that there are other sides to me. Yes, I dress flashy. It's about the things I never had when I was growing up. And I'm a showman. My thing is to show off and stand out."
In spite of the facial damage that Malignaggi suffered against Cotto, the fight was still a competitive bout. Even with the second round knockdown, the margins of 5 and 3 points on the judges cards depict the story of a fight that wasn't the washout his mug might've led you to think. Asserts Promoter Lou Dibella, "He earned great respect in an all out war."
Following a fighter's first loss, the big question remains: How will he react to losing the "0" on his record?
"It definitely tested me mentally," admits Malignaggi. "I was feeling out of it for awhile. After I thought about it and had some time to heal up and stuff, it just makes me hungrier."
Like a teen who has his heart broken for the first time, Malignaggi appears to have grown as a fighter and matured to the point where he has the veteran experience to handle adversity more capably than previously. That trait, which cannot be taught in any gym, will be a major factor as he makes his return February 17 on Boxing After Dark against tough banger Edner Cherry. Cherry, whose last three fights have been all-action wars, is the kind of mid-range opponent that seems tailor-made for Malignaggi's style. That doesn't necessarily translate into an easy fight.
Malignaggi analyzes, "He seems to like to box. He's a solid fighter but he hasn't fought anybody on Paulie Malignaggi's level. He's going to be fighting on a high world-class level and he's in for a rude awakening. When the bell rings he's going to be into a totally different world, like I was when I went into the Cotto fight. He's going to be fighting a very hungry fighter. I still have an aftertaste from my last fight. I didn't like losing and I'm preparing myself 100-percent never to lose again."
"I think Paulie wins the fight, he is the better boxer," states junior welterweight contender Dmitriy Salita. "Although Paulie is not a big puncher, he is a physically strong fighter."
Salita continues, "The key to victory in this fight is who will establish their style of boxing. Cherry is a shorter, smaller fighter. In order for him to be effective, he will have to put a lot of pressure on Paulie and make him fight."
Prompted by his corner's lack of support during the Cotto fight, Malignaggi felt a change was needed. "I was never told from my corner that I was still in the fight. That's why I went to a new trainer in Buddy McGirt. I didn’t have the right guy for the job, I needed to make the change."
What may be most beneficial is McGirt's tendency to ingrain a more disciplined style in his fighters, which can help the sometimes too combative Malignaggi. "I think boxing is more of one of my main strengths than brawling, obviously. I think with Buddy guiding the ship a little bit, I won't be sucked into a kind of fight like that anymore."
Malignaggi assures that this new partnership with the former two division champion McGirt has paid dividends. "I've definitely improved a lot working with Buddy," states Paulie. "We've worked on a lot of different things and I've become a more complete fighter. People will see a lot of it in this fight but even more in time. We're fine tuning things like balance, angles and timing. I had always relied on my natural ability. My style is what I am but we're working on sitting down on my punches and balance, offense and defense."
There is great pressure for Malignaggi to live up to the standard he has publicly set for himself, particularly given the spotlight of an HBO card. A tough loss followed by a lackluster performance on TV cannot be good for a love 'em or hate 'em fighter.
"Every fighter from the time he's an amateur thinks about fighting on HBO because that means you're well on your way to making it. They chose this fight and I plan to put on a great show so HBO will keep putting me on and we can develop a good relationship."
Referring to himself in the third person, "The Magic Man" states, "If Paulie Malignaggi struggles with Edner Cherry, then something is wrong. I know I'm going to be seeing the best Edner Cherry yet, because this is his big opportunity. Regardless of what Edner Chery comes to fight that night, Paulie Malignaggi should not have a tough time with him. And if he does, then I'm going to be disappointed because I'm looking to get to a much higher level than Edner Cherry."
However, a big win on HBO in front of his hometown crowd in New York City will cement him as a top attraction in the junior welterweight picture. With Hatton and Castillo preparing to shorten each other's careers this Summer, the division is wide open for the New Yorker with the "Growing up Gotti" looks and quick tongue to match it.
What's next is anyone's guess. Outside of Hatton and Castillo, Junior Witter, Ricardo Torres, and Soulemayne M'Baye hold the title belts that Malignaggi has openly sought to try his luck at. Not exactly the division of three years ago, but you have to start somewhere. If a big shakeup in the division is to occur, Malignaggi will have to do his own shaking.
Whatever the case, rest assured that Paulie Malignaggi will not go quietly.
Any questions or comments? Send them to me at mc_rson@yahoo.com