By Cliff Rold
From Groucho Marx’s mouth to God’s ear, “If you've heard this story before, don't stop me, because I'd like to hear it again.”
The most memorable fights are rarely just about the action in the ring. The days and minutes, the stories leading men to the ring matter. It’s why a bout built for years like Mike Tyson-Evander Holyfield rolls so easily through the collective conscious years later and Ike Ibeabuchi-David Tua, well, does not.
This weekend, there is no Tyson-Holyfield on tap, but that’s okay. There are still in four fights, on two networks, stories to be told. Each has some classic element of drama worth exploring every bit as much as the elements of pugilism that will determine how the chapters are written on the way to the turn of the final page.
Let’s go the report cards.
Ascension: Daniel Ponce De Leon-Juan Manuel Lopez (HBO)
Speed: Lopez B+; De Leon B
Power: De Leon A; Lopez A-
Defense: Lopez B+; De Leon B-
Intangibles: De Leon B; Lopez Incomplete
The metaphor of young lion toppling old to seize violent possession of the herd is a Boxing favorite. It is the culmination of the young lion’s story of ascension; the end of his rise from cub to king. While often such tales leave the strongest impression, they come second to the test that precedes them when the herd is momentarily thinned by the crossroads of ambitious, in this case southpaw, youth.
The 27-year old De Leon (34-1, 30 KO, WBO titlist) of Mexico is currently regarded as one of the best in the world at 122 lbs. The spot at the top of the ladder remains elusive, and any immediate hope of a shot at World champion Israel Vasquez (43-4, 31 KO) rests in this weekends challenges. And, oh yes, the 24-year old Lopez (21-0, 19 KO) of Puerto Rico will be a challenge. Although his quality of opposition has been less than De Leon’s, he shows better speed, more classic technique and tighter defense to go with so far prodigious power. Whether his power is of the same one-punch nastiness De Leon has exhibited remains to be seen, and what he’ll do when he gets hit remains to be determined. Lopez is in most respects an enigma, a fighter whose best foes have been of the worn veteran variety (i.e. Hugo Dianzo), leaving him with little in the way of tests or revelations. Conversely, De Leon has shown growth since a 2005 loss to Celestino Caballero by way of a willingness to take something off his shots in favor of volume and victory, as he did in edging out former World Jr. Bantamweight champ Gerry Penalosa in 2007.
Restoration: Vernon Forrest-Sergio Mora (Showtime)
Speed: Forrest B+; Mora B
Power: Forrest B; Mora D+
Defense: Forrest B; Mora B
Intangibles: Forrest B; Mora B
Of course, not all stories revolve around the pursuit of the positions of elders. There are also, perhaps before even the mythologies of Maat and Zoroast, the stories of personal restoration, of protagonists who fate dealt a losing hand only to allow them back to the table once more.
The 37-year old former World Welterweight champion and current WBC 154 lbs. titlist Forrest (40-2, 29 KO), of Atlanta, Georgia, can tell that story well. A pro career that began in 1992 winded through a decade before a shot at Shane Mosley validated his place in the sport. A year later, he was defeated twice by the unrefined Ricardo Mayorga and further set back by shoulder injuries. It took until last year, in wins against the durable Michelle Piccirillo and Carlos Baldomir, to find hints of his best form again.
Mora’s narrative was different. After winning the first season the Contender reality show on national U.S. TV, he looked like a fighter with the chance for stardom. Instead, the 27-year old Los Angelino Mora (20-0-1, 5 KO) has fought only five times since May 2005 and seen his star potential dim almost black. The winner of this bout will have the best chance for headlines since the big days that seem so far away. Unfortunately for Mora, the only place where he can really hope to compete is in speed. Forrest hits harder, has greater range, deeper experience and is more difficult to hit clean. If Mora is to find a glimmer of hope, it is that both Mayorga and Baldomir forced Forrest to struggle simply by getting inside the jab. Forrest isn’t comfortable up close. We know this much: each has shown a measure of character that is admirable. Mora came out of nowhere to beat the more naturally gifted Peter Manfredo and Ishe Smith to capture fame; Forrest persevered for years where others might have walked away in frustration.
Hubris: Kelly Pavlik-Gary Lockett (HBO)
Speed: Pavlik B; Lockett B
Power: Pavlik A; Lockett B-
Defense: Pavlik B; Lockett B
Intangibles: Pavlik A; Lockett Incomplete
The peaks of acclaim Forrest and Mora slipped from are the ones Youngstown, Ohio’s Pavlik (33-0, 29 KO) occupies now. He is, at 26, the World Middleweight champion with big money and fights on the horizon. This is not expected to be a compelling fight. Pavlik and the 31-year old Welshman Lockett (30-1, 21 KO) are fairly even in terms of speed and how often they’ve been hit, at least so far, by the power gap is massive and the things we know about Pavlik (Chin: so-so; Heart: proven; Experience: earned) just haven’t been tested in the soft rise of Lockett.
Still, they fight the fights for a reason. Many a young champion has been caught looking somewhere other than across the ring. If Pavlik comes in flush with the wrong type of confidence, anything can happen.
Revenge: Carlos Quintana-Paul Williams II (Showtime)
Speed: Williams B+; Quintana B
Power: Williams B; Quintana B
Defense: Quintana B+; Williams B
Intangibles: Quintana B+; Williams B+
The greatest plot device, the one that has sold the most books and received the most knowing nods of understanding, is thirst for vengeance. Whether it is found in the Arthur’s battles with Morgan Le Fay or Maximus finally wasting that weasel Commodus (You know stuff like “Death smiles at us all. All a man can do is smile back” is bad ass), revenge touches something at the base core of man.
26-year Paul Williams (33-1, 24 KO)of Augusta, Georgia, is a fighter in pursuit of revenge for a first loss that saw his ‘next big thing’ label frayed and his WBO Welterweight belt captured away this past February. 31-year old Carlos Quintana (25-1, 19 KO) of Puerto Rico is the man who turned the trick and he will arrive ready to prove his first victory no fluke, pushing Williams even further from the goals of riches and titles that mark any fighters journey through the ranks. As in the first fight, Williams possesses the edge on speed, but the lack of serious stopping power from both men almost guarantees another hard twelve rounds. The first fight was decided largely on Quintana’s ability to hit more and get hit less. His amateur years, superior timing, and Williams’s low held guard meant a steady diet of lefts hands fed to the presumed favorite. Each man has shown they can overcome adversity, Quintana in bouncing back from a destructive 2005 loss to Miguel Cotto and Williams in not folding against Quintana or the late rushes of rugged Antonio Margarito in the summer of 2007. Now we find out if Williams has the ability and maturity to adjust to a man that knows he can win where Williams does not.
Resolution.
On Sunday morning, Boxing fans everywhere will see how all of these elements played out in the ring. Always part of the fun in getting there, from the first trip through the woods with Red Riding Hood to the latest Grisham page-turner, is guessing how it all turns out. The guesswork today says:
Forrest TKO 10 Mora
Williams W12 Quintana
Lopez KO10 De Leon
Pavlik KO9 Lockett
Right or wrong, the one thing certainty is each result will build into the next story with new spins on each of the elements noted above and others, like redemption, justice and tragedy, not so evident this time around. After all, there aren’t as many types of stories as there are ways to tell them, which is why even those that feel familiar are told so many times. Boxing fans have heard them all before…
…and they always like to hear them again.
HBO World Championship Boxing begins Saturday at 10:05 PM EST/7:05 PM EST.
Showtime Championship Boxing begins Saturday at 9 PM EST/PST.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com