By Cliff Rold
Photo (c) Chris Cozzone/FightWireImages
The outcome of Showtime’s main event became obvious too soon after the opening bell. The outcome of HBO’s concluded on an anti-climactic cut. Yet, with fourteen rounds between the two bouts, it would be hard to find room to argue about the way the results came out. Saturday night ran with the story ingredients of redemption and validation, heavy leather displayed all the way.
Significantly, the results matter in framing the rest of 2008 and elements of 2009.
Let’s go to the report card.
Clottey-Judah
Speed
Pre-Fight Grades: Judah A; Clottey B
Post-Fight: Judah A-; Clottey B+
Power
Pre-Fight Grades: Judah A-; Clottey B
Post-Fight: Same
Defense
Pre-Fight Grades: Clottey B+; Judah B+
Post-Fight: Judah B/Clottey B+
Intangibles
Pre-Fight Grades: Clottey B; Judah B-
Post-Fight: Clottey B+; Judah B
We start up the scale at Welterweight where Ghana’s Joshua Clottey (35-2, 20 KO) picked up the vacant IBF belt with a ninth-round technical decision over a former World Welterweight champion Zab Judah (36-6, 25 KO). Two things were notable about the decision. The first is that replays showed it very likely should have been a stoppage win, an uppercut opening a wide cut over the right eye of Zab Judah only to be ruled caused by a head butt.
The second is that, even with a should-have been stoppage win, Clottey is even less of a puncher than his so-so knockout ratio describes. Judah, who grew to fame based on early observations about his power and defensive prowess, was hit repeatedly on Saturday night with Clottey’s right hand and dealt fine with it. Never known for a great chin, the work done against Judah left him upright and illustrated how hard Clottey has to work to compete at the highest levels of the sport.
Work hard was what both men did through all of their nine rounds. Regardless of how one feels about whether or not Judah could have continued with the cut (and the ring doctor stated he felt that Judah could have and couldn’t see for other undeterminable reasons), Judah certainly acquitted himself well throughout the fight, battling through adverse moments in a way he hasn’t been regularly noted for.
In the end, it was for naught. Even with advantages that played out as expected in speed and power, he just couldn’t outwill Clottey and after building an early lead on the cards was finding it a hellish task to keep the points piling up in the developing second half. Earning his sixth loss, the question of whether Judah will ever reach the potential many saw in him over a decade ago is about two losses past answered. The question on Saturday was how much longer he’d be a serious player near the top of the Welterweight division. The answer attained was that if he isn’t yet relegated to playing gatekeeper, he’s getting awfully close.
Clottey is in a different place, and unlike Judah he won’t be encumbered by what others think he should be. Clottey has developed, with class, professionalism and poise, into a legitimate spoiler figure that any Welterweight will have to dig in to defeat as a reportedly torn bicep is healed. Fans that have seen what are his two signature fights, with Antonio Margarito in 2006 and Judah now, could walk away both times impressed with quality action. Already 31, the African warrior will have to act fast to parlay that into the sort of check that can put the exclamation point on a subtle and now rewarded career.
Further down the scale…
Darchinyan-Kirilov
Speed
Pre-Fight Grades: Darchinyan B+; Kirilov B
Post-Fight: Same
Power
Pre-Fight Grades: Darchinyan A; Kirilov C
Post-Fight: Same
Defense
Pre-Fight Grades: Kirilov B+; Darchinyan B
Post-Fight: Kirilov C+/Same
Intangibles
Pre-Fight Grades: Darchinyan B+; Kirilov B+
Post-Fight: Darchinyan A/Kirilov B+
Look, there really isn’t much to say here. The new IBF Jr. Bantamweight titlist Vic Darchinyan (30-1-1, 24 KO) walked through the deposed Dimitri Kirilov (29-4-1, 9 KO) even faster and more violently than predicted in this space. Darchinyan was faster, more powerful, relentless and ultimately victorious. With all his amateur experience, it was a surprise to see Kirilov with no Plan B and no attempt to stay out of the pocket. He’s had a fine career, but considering the talent level currently at 115 lbs., one wonders what Kirilov can do now. He looked slower and worn in his previous fight against Cecilio Santos. He looked almost shot on Saturday and retirement can’t be beyond consideration.
As good as Darchinyan looked, his options going forward are rough as well. Holding a title in one of Boxing’s best current fields, a division where unification is in the air, might well put him in line to face WBC/WBA titlist Cristian Mijares. While it’s not the best fight in the division (that’s Mijares/Fernando Montiel), it would be an entertaining step in the right direction. Is it the best step for Darchinyan? Mijares showed against Katsushige Kawashima, Jorge Arce and Alexander Munoz that he has a way of diffusing the bombing efforts of power punchers with precision counter punching of his own.
That could be a bad sign. Darchinyan has never been impossible to hit and during the brave stand of Kirilov late in the third and into the fourth, he was tagged repeatedly with rights. Mijares is taller and has more wrinkles than Kirilov and Darchinyan would need more than reckless abandon with the left.
This chatter could all be irrelevant if Mijares-Darchinyan does not unfold and takes nothing from what Darchinyan got done. Many in Boxing expected him to have a tough night, to show some affects from the devastating knockout he suffered last year against Nonito Donaire. He has not to date and sure as hell didn’t Saturday. His ‘intangibles’ are proving to be as quality as his gift for gab and as long as he stays a factor in the nether regions, he’s a boon.
Overall, at least a solid B+ of a weekend after an A+ in Margarito-Cotto a week ago. Boxing has a bit of a halt in big fights for the next few weeks but when it picks back up, let’s hope the momentum remains.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com