By Cliff Rold
When the BoxingScene ratings (https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=boxing-ratings) are updated later this week, 25-year WBO titlist Timothy Bradley (26-0, 12 KO) will be in the same number one spot he was in before Saturday night’s controversial defeat of Nate Campbell. 22-year old newly minted WBC titlist Devon Alexander (19-0, 12 KO) will certainly be a new addition, dropping a significant average.
Average age that is.
Including 30-year old lineal World Jr. Welterweight champion Manny Pacquiao, the average age of the Jr. Welterweight division rests at right around 26 years of age making it one of the youngest classes in the sport. It’s got its old hands for sure but when one considers the current top ten, undefeated talents like 25-year old Lamont Peterson (27-0, 13 KO) and 29-year old Mike Alvarado (26-0, 19 KO) who haven’t quite cracked the top ten yet, and a 22-year old Victor Ortiz who could return, Jr. Welterweight becomes a bigger window to the game’s future than almost any other division.
While perhaps not the immediate future in terms of super fights, this class is currently producing a crop which will be in the super fights of tomorrow and is producing quite a few superb fights right now.
Bradley and Alexander got past seasoned veterans Nate Campbell (33-6-1, 25 KO) and Junior Witter (37-3-2, 22 KO), respectively, on Saturday night and both look, so far, like the sort of talents who can be expected to be around for a while.
Let’s go to the post-weekend report card.
Grades
Pre-Fight: Speed - Bradley A; Campbell B/Post: A; B-
Pre-Fight: Power - Bradley C+; Campbell B+/Post: B; B
Pre-Fight: Defense - Bradley B; Campbell B/Post: B+; B-
Pre-Fight: Intangibles - Bradley A; Campbell B+/Post: A; Incomplete
Pre-Fight: Speed - Alexander A-; Witter B+/Post: A-; B
Pre-Fight: Power - Alexander B-; Witter B/Post: B; B
Pre-Fight: Defense - Alexander B; Witter B/Post: B+; B-
Pre-Fight: Intangibles - Alexander B; Witter B+/Post: A; D
We begin with the undercard bout. Alexander-Witter looked on paper like it could be a competitive affair but ultimately became a showcase for Alexander who impressed with concentrated orthodoxy against the most unorthodox of foes. Witter was the second former 140 lb. titlist Alexander has faced since turning professional in 2004 and against both Witter and, previously, DeMarcus Corley, it hasn’t been flash or style which meant victory.
It’s been fundamentals and maturity to go along with world class speed. Against Witter, with his first title opportunity at hand, Alexander never got outside of himself. He started with his southpaw right jab and increased its use. He kept with what was working, on Saturday lead right hooks and straight lefts, even as Witter varied his stance and multiplied rough house tactics. The few times he was tagged, he shrugged it off. Alexander also showed off calculated pop. He knows he’s not a nuclear power guy, but also fights with the confidence that if he lands flush it must be respected. He rocked Witter on more than one occasion but never jumped without thought, allowing the next hurting opportunity to develop organically. Against a fighter with as much more experience as Witter had, it was sound professionalism.
Witter on the other hand may have made certain what was hinted at in his loss to Bradley last year. With wild leaping hooks and fancy footwork, Witter at his best was a fighter whose game relied on speed to make bad form good. Schooled in much of the same tactical approach as former Featherweight champion Naseem Hamed, the 35-year old doesn’t appear able to do so anymore against better opposition.
The main event, like the undercard, ended up showcasing a young fighter on the rise but the full glow of the spotlight was aborted by a headbutt, a cut, and some controversy as the headbutt induced bleed was, it appeared, errantly ruled to be caused by a punch.
In the three completed rounds, there was a lot of what works for Bradley and signs of improvement. He’s got remarkably fast hands and when he lets them go in short bursts, he’s hard to defend against because he can pile on. In a way not seen in previous wins over Witter and Holt, Bradley used his jab to set traps, keeping Campbell at bay and not letting him inside until Bradley was set to defend and counter.
Part of that was a slide in snap from the veteran. In this bout, and in his last against Ali Funeka, Campbell is showing signs of age. His hands are still heavy and the technique is sound but he missed right hands on Saturday he was landing a year ago. To Bradley’s credit, when Campbell did get rights in, Bradley took them and defended well against the former Lightweight titlist sneaky inside uppercut.
And then of course there was the conclusion. Campbell scores an incomplete grade because there are questions about what happened. Viewing and reviewing the drama in Campbell’s corner, he clearly went to the stool complaining he couldn’t see and it’s hard to doubt him. Medical verification of blood inside the eye would confirm vision problems.
There is another angle though. Campbell is one of the most lucid fighters in the sport, smart and honest even amidst a storm of bravado. He knew he was in tough, he knew he was in the other man’s hometown, and he would know a no contest staves off a loss. If the fight stops before the fourth, he lives another day. If he continues and loses on the cards or by stoppage after the fourth, he’s a tough old guy coming off a loss. There’s no way to know if this is what he was thinking about, but he was smart enough to do so and there was a recent example of a fighter worked over by similar conditions.
In March, veteran Marco Antonio Barrera was cut early by a headbutt against Amir Khan and the fight lasted just long enough to get to the cards, Khan winning on his turf. Was any of this in the air? Who knows but for now Campbell stands with a TKO loss which could be overturned sooner than later.
Looking Ahead
The future looks bright for the winners and shorter for the defeated but Campbell has more remaining upside. If the verdict is made a no decision, he’ll have a good claim for another shot at Bradley. If not, he’s a heck of a name to tackle for anyone looking to separate from an increasingly crowded pack at Jr. Welterweight.
Witter probably has less to look forward to.
Unfortunately for Witter, on this side of the pond, the British fighter will be recalled for submitting to Alexander without doing much to try to change the result. He will also be recalled for losing to Bradley and for a horrifically bad outing with Zab Judah a decade ago which could explain many of the years away from U.S. eyes. In between, he really did make for good fights, and wins, against the likes of Corley and Vivian Harris and can hope to find at least some of that form again back home. Perhaps he’ll look just vulnerable enough to get the sort of pay day against someone like Khan he couldn’t get in a prime spent largely chasing, and arguably being ducked, by Ricky Hatton.
The victors, and youth, collect spoils and may someday be rewarded against each other. Alexander has a WBC belt taken from Bradley and there can always be an angle there. Each man likely has mandatories on tap and Alexander could use some time to build an economic base. A St. Louis native, Alexander can attempt to follow in the footsteps of stable mate Cory Spinks whose proven to be a big local draw in a strong U.S. sports market. He’s well positioned to be the latest, and maybe one of the last, stars built by the aging Don King.
Bradley, with wins over Witter, Holt and now Campbell is clearly the number one man in the division not named Manny Pacquiao. He is, in terms of merit, the number one contender to Pacquiao’s lineal world championship at 140. It’s not a fight for 2009 but if he keeps winning, and Pacquiao doesn’t make a permanent move to almost-Welterweight, Bradley can see his public mandate built along with his fistic one.
Boxing, almost always, is fought within divisions. If Pacquiao doesn’t fight again at Jr. Welterweight so be it. If he does, he is its rightful champion and fighting one’s most deserving contender should be part of the game. If Pacquiao does continue at 140, sooner or later Bradley will have to come into the crosshairs and it’s looking like a real fight.
For a complete recap of the in-ring action, check the post-fight report at https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=21309
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com