By Cliff Rold
Two networks and four fights later, Boxing now has two tantalizing battles on the horizon. The roll the sport has been on since 2007 may have no end in sight and thank God for that. Hopefully loyal report card academics were paying attention last week. If they were, they saw Chad Dawson-Glen Johnson live up to its predicted spot as fight of the weekend and now the chatter can begin for…
Summer 2008.
Miguel Cotto-Antonio Margarito at Welterweight.
Antonio Tarver-Chad Dawson at Light Heavyweight.
Do we really have to wait?
Sadly we must. However, in the spirit of looking ahead, format is changing up. Rather than break each completed fight down individually, this edition will look at what each double header told us about its division.
Let’s go to the report card.
Showtime’s Light Heavyweight Post Fight Grades
Antonio Tarver: B+
Clinton Woods: D
Chad Dawson: B
Glen Johnson: B+
Rumors of now-IBF titlist Antonio Tarver’s demise were exaggerated. At 39, Tarver (27-4, 19 KO) fought like a man of at least 34 against an impotent Clinton Woods (41-4-1, 24 KO). Seriously, where was Woods? He’s never been a special fighter, but he’s always been an honest one. He’s always tried hard. Whether it was against Roy Jones or Glen Johnson or some Euro Willie Standup, Woods always brought pressure and let his hands go. Against Tarver, he walked forward aimlessly like a man ready to do something else with his life.
Some of the credit of course goes to Tarver. He looked sharp for long stretches, much more the fighter who cleaned out Light Heavyweight earlier this decade than the one who was befuddled by Bernard Hopkins in 2006. After a 2007 when he stooped to fighting Zsolt Erdei leftovers, Tarver may have made himself a realistic future option for the top of the class but was it really a performance that would make people want to pay to see him challenge? Before that question can be answered, he’ll probably have to find out if Chad Dawson (26-0, 17 KO) was exposed or just accelerated on the learning curve last weekend. All guesses are valid.
Tell me again which was the 39, and which the 25, year old man when Dawson faced Glen Johnson (47-12-2, 32 KO)? I scored the bout a draw but over the last six rounds, it was Johnson whose punches had snap, it was Johnson whose legs were fresh, and it was Johnson seizing the initiative. It looked like he deserved at least a draw and, if liberally scoring the fifth or tenth 10-8, could easily have won the fight. They both won rounds; the difference was that Dawson got thumped in the rounds he lost.
Johnson’s post-fight tirade against the officiating merits more consideration as well. He did not unanimously sweep the last two rounds on all three cards in another example of judges who are more impressed by amateur flurries than professional bombs. For shame; it was an honorable display from an underappreciated warrior in Johnson who stands out as one of the better late peaking fighters ever. He deserves a rematch.
The hype around this card was that it featured the four best Light Heavyweights in the world; hype is the prefix of hyperbole, a better description of that billing. Dawson, like Lightweight Juan Diaz and Welterweight Paul Williams, has been anointed a wee bit too soon. It’s easy to understand. When fighters only go 2-3 times per year, it magnifies performances.
Conversely, the wide victory margins Tarver amassed against Woods are about equal to the distance he has to go to prove he can beat Bernard Hopkins. It’s just fact that he can beat everyone else around him and still be about ten rounds to two behind Hopkins and the onus is Tarver’s to prove otherwise. The winners on this card made it easy to declare the winner of next Saturday’s Hopkins-Joe Calzaghe showdown the best Light Heavyweight in the world.
That doesn’t mean that a Dawson-Tarver winner would be anywhere else but first in line to challenge the claim. Dawson is still probably the 175 lb. future, Tarver its strongest available link to the past. Woods was so bad that Tarver’s status can’t be gauged today. It could be the day after a Dawson fight. Let’s hope to see it as soon as possible.
Switching channels…
HBO Welterweights Post-Fight Grades
Miguel Cotto: A
Alfonso Gomez: Incomplete
Antonio Margarito: A
Kermit Cintron: B-
I didn’t disguise my feelings about this card going in. It was what it looked like before the first bell clanged: a commercial for a much better fight down the road between Cotto (32-0, 26 KO, WBA titlist) and Margarito (36-5, 26 KO, now-IBF titlist). Gomez (18-4-1, 8 KO) was so out of his league with Cotto that it’s unfair to grade him at all. That Cotto-Gomez received so little criticism while Floyd Mayweather eats critiques almost down to the way he ties his shoes (and I’m one of those pesky critics) is patently ridiculous. Not saying Cotto has to fight murderer’s row every time out, but for seven figures, no one should get the sort of walk Gomez was and should have been recognized as all along.
Then again, if you’re Team Cotto, you’ve got to be glad not to have spent any bullets last Saturday because he’ll need a full clip to beat Margarito. I don’t know if Margarito is Boxing’s most feared man, but he is probably the most underrated and has been for awhile. While Cintron (29-2, 27 KO) was improved from their 2005 encounter, that improvement was worth all of about two minutes of extra beating. What a dismantling Boxing fans witnessed.
For Cintron, it’s back to the drawing board and retirement wouldn’t be an awful idea. He’s a solid athlete, but that’s not enough. At some point, the fighter has to come out. When he’s pressured, he gets frustrated and looked the part of a man absorbing the inevitable rather than a warrior resisting it.
And so Boxing turns to the best available fight at 147 lbs. (and a reasonable place to pick on Mayweather). Cotto-Margarito should be a corker, a pier-six brawl with breathtaking possibility. Cotto has the tools to win, but Margarito is just so black and white movie. Only one fighter has legitimately beaten him in the last near decade and Paul Williams had to find every ounce of himself to make it to the finish line. Cotto has never been in with anyone this relentless. If Margarito can take the heat early, this could evolve into an all-time Mexican Puerto Rican epic. The winner will have earned a shot at the Welterweight champion Mayweather and, short of that fight, the right to demand that Mayweather abdicate a throne he seems so willing to disregard the obligations to.
All in all, factoring in both the finished results and results to be contemplated, it was an A+ weekend for the sweet science.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com