Who do you rank higher as an all-time great, Pacquiao or JC Chavez?

[Suckmedry]

Its close but Pac edges it for me. Pac is a true modern day legend. We are actually all lucky to watch a warrior like him in action.

[Rustle Wilson]

Pacquiao.

And it's not even close.

[10,000 Days]

Chavez has
Mario Martinez
Rosario
Lockridge
Jl Ramirez
Camacho
Haugen
Meldrick
Mayweather twice

That's nine big wins over 3 weight classes across 10 pounds

Manny has

Sasquol
Ledbewa
Barrera twice
Marquez twice
Morales twice
Oscar
Hatton
Cotto
Bradley (basically twice)

That's 12 big wins across 7 divisions over 40 pounds


And one could argue that mosely, margarito, algieri, rios, larios are better than haugen or Martinez


I just don't see how it can be so clear cut for Chavez...


I believe manny has more titles, more weight classes, more big spectacular wins, more longevity at the world class level, and arguably the better list of foes, and I think the first Barrera win is the best win for either guy

Yeah, you maybe right. I mite just be biased since I'm a JCC fan and just can't shake the feeling that Manny in his prime didn't look as invincible as JCC did in his.

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

I vote Chavez even though he got that gift draw against Sweet Pea. Now if they fought each other....prime for prime...hmmm