Who is greatest? Roy Jones Jr. or Bernard Hopkins

[nujabes77]

Is a though one but...
I'll give it to Bernard Hopkins cause is the only one that has ever beaten Pavlik... and the fight with Calzaghe was very close.

joe calzaghe... he beat them both hehe

[dans]

Imagine if Roy Jones had retired after beating John Ruiz. This would be a non issue.

[MELLY-MEL...]

prime 4 prime, roy. longevity, and improving with age Bhop.

[ИATAS]

Imagine if Roy Jones had retired after beating John Ruiz. This would be a non issue.

Or better yet fought and beat one other heavyweight, like maybe even Mike Tyson (who wasn't the same anymore). He could have retired 50-1 with his one loss really being a win.

[IMDAZED]

Roy Jones Jr is the best fighter of my generation.

[dans]

Or better yet fought and beat one other heavyweight, like maybe even Mike Tyson (who wasn't the same anymore). He could have retired 50-1 with his one loss really being a win.

Fighting even a washed up Tyson would be a dangerous move, but yes could you imagine? He would be a top 10 ATG, no doubt.

[Adamantium]

I've got to go with Jones on this one, based mainly on the fact that he has spent the bulk of his career fighting naturally bigger guys. Bhops best wins are all over guys moving up in weight, maybe if Bhop had fought some more lightheavys then I would give him more credit.I still cant figure out what happened in Jones fight with Calzaghe though, its like the dude gave up after rnd two.

[S.G.]

Personally I find Hopkins' career ever so slightly more impressive.

[JM1]

bhop for me

[Chr0nic]

roy jones, and im not even a jones fan.....or am i?