BScene Staff Predictions: Austin Trout vs. Miguel Cotto

By Jake Donovan

Miguel Cotto has never lost before at Madison Square Garden – or anywhere in New York.

Austin Trout has never fought before at Madison Square Garden – or anywhere in New York.

Both statements mean about as much as the fact that prior to November 24, Ricky Hatton was undefeated in the U.K.

The more being, you still have to fight it out in the ring.

Cotto (37-3, 30KO) attempts to start a fifth title reign in a career spanning three weight classes. The Puerto Rican superstar enters on the heels of a competitive points loss to Floyd Mayweather Jr. this past May. The loss ended a 154 lb. title which lasted nearly two years, including his revenge 10th round stoppage win over Antonio Margarito at the Garden exactly 52 weeks ago.

He enters Saturday’s fight as the challenger for the first time since facing then-unbeaten Yuri Foreman in June ’10 at Yankees Stadium in Bronx, NY. Cotto emerged victorious on that night, battering a mobile Foreman in nine rounds to claim a 154 lb. belt.

Trout (25-0, 14KO) attempts the fourth defense of the belt he won nearly two years ago on the road in Mexico. The 27-year old southpaw is no stranger to performing in hostile territory, winning big in Canada, Panama and Mexico long before taking a clear decision over Rigoberto Alvarez in Feb. ’11.

Saturday night marks his third straight appearance on Showtime, having also scored televised wins over Delvin Rodriguez and Frank LoPorto in his past two fights, with the LoPorto bout serving as a showcase in his birth town of El Paso, Texas. Prior to that fight, Trout won two straight in Mexico, winning a decision over David Lopez four months following the title win over Alvarez.

Does Trout have what it takes to overcome Cotto’s considerable hometown advantage to win at the Garden?

Does Cotto have one truly great performance left in him, or has the 32-year old seen the last of his championship days?

Which way does the staff lean?

Read on to find out…


Austin Trout may be a good boxer with a good jab who has won on the road (Beating Saul Alvarez's brother in Mexico to win the vacant title) but going to MSG against a dramatic step up in class such as Miguel Cotto is a whole different animal. Cotto surprised a lot of people with his performance against Floyd Mayweather in May. While he lost the fight he hit Floyd more than he has been hit since the 1st Castillo fight. I expect Trout to have early success before Cotto figures him out and slowly breaks him down. Cotto by TKO in 10.
– Ryan Burton (Cotto)

With my pick, make sure to lay down cash betting against the opposite! That said, going against the grain a bit on this one. It will be tough for Trout to “just” win a decision in NYC against Cotto. I believe he’s aware of this and will truly rise to the occasion. Not to mention the fight now comes with the kiss of death – Golden Boy preparing a future fight (Saul Alvarez-Miguel Cotto being planned for next year) before the one in front of them is in the books. One day they’ll learn. Trout by SD.
– Jake Donovan (Trout)

Trout is a nice talent who's climbed the ladder successfully enough, but it's my guess he'll be surprised at the distance between his and the very top rung at 154. Cotto, even after a few losses, remains a resolute and skillful grinder who'll chip away at anything less than the highest level pound-for-pound foe. Trout doesn't pass that litmus, and, though he may indeed lead after six rounds, the guess is he won't be standing after 12. Cotto KO 10.
– Lyle Fitzsimmons (Cotto)

This is the classic veteran vs. up & comer. Many have counted Cotto out before only for him to comeback with great back to back performances (even in loss). Trout has not been overly impressive but can box tremendously. The key for Cotto will be to apply pressure and smother the younger Trout but if Trout can find his groove he can completely out box Cotto. I expect Trout to hit the deck earlier but work his way back only to lose a razor thin probably controversial split decision to Cotto.
- Tim Kudgis (Cotto)

Austin Trout W12 Miguel Cotto. While Miguel Cotto surprised most observers by giving Floyd Mayweather his toughest fight in years, I still believe his best days are behind him. Austin Trout is a tricky southpaw with the type of style that can disrupt Cotto's offensive gameplan. I think Trout takes a tactical affair.
- Ryan Maquiñana (Trout)

Trout is coming to fight. He is young, strong, and a champion. He's naturally larger than Cotto. He's also used to fighting on the home turf of his opponent. Those strengths will serve him well and make this a rough and tough fight, but it's unlikely they will guide him to victory. Cotto has too many advantages. He's been in championship fights for years on end. He's undefeated in New York and Madison Square Garden, where 20,000 Cotto faithful will be present to cheer him on. Cotto also handpicked Trout as the 154 pounder with a belt that he wanted to beat, thus giving him greater bargaining power for a fight with Saul Alvarez next May. There will be blood, and Cotto may have to swallow some of his own, but with a $10-15 million payday in the balance against Alvarez, I see Cotto bringing forth enough grit for a hard fought UD,
- Richard Najdowski (Cotto)

I started out, at the announcement of this fight leaning to Trout. The problem is, the closer it gets to fight time, it's hard to think of a single time Trout impressed against a single opponent who really measures up to what Cotto has done a) generally and b) at 154 lbs. I like Cotto to outjab Trout and score enough heavy stuff to pick up another alphabet strap. Cotto by decision.
– Cliff Rold (Cotto)

Cotto UD - While there's no doubt Austin Trout (pun intended) is preparing for this fight like never before, I still think Cotto's experience and skill set will be too much. Trout is making a huge leap in quality of opponent and while I think he gives Cotto some problems, Cotto will eventually begin to breakdown Trout late in the fight. Cotto has looked great under Pedro Diaz and I think we'll see another good performance.
- Luis Sandoval (Cotto)

I don't really believe in what I haven't seen much before. I have seen Trout fighting twice - against Frank LoPorto and against Delvin Rodriguez. Against Rodriguez he was hardly impressive but very effective, and LoPorto was too weak for the fight to matter something. So, Austin Trout is a USA Mystery Man. I don't think he has power to hurt Cotto, and his skills and speed aren't enough to outbox and to outsmart the four-time world champion. Cotto won't hurt him bad but his punch load will be a decisive factor in the fight. Cotto UD
– Alexey Sukachev (Cotto)

Total: Miguel Cotto 7, Austin Trout 2

The Trout-Cotto super welterweight title fight headlines live on Showtime from Madison Square Garden in New York City (Saturday, 9PM ET/6PM PT). The evening also features a 10-round middleweight bout between Daniel Jacobs and Chris Fitzpatrick, as well as a featherweight showdown between unbeaten Jayson Velez and fringe contender Salvador Sanchez II.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Follow Jake on Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by techliam on 12-01-2012

I picked Trout by TKO I can see hunger for him and his family. Cotto seems to want to finish his career to focus on his children. Just my opinion. Cotto isn't the beast he was at 140/147 Can't wait…

Comment by .:: JSFD26 ::. on 12-01-2012

[QUOTE=kiaba360;12756919]It's possible he could get out-maneuvered, but I think Trout is a bit too big and fresh for Cotto to straight-up punk him like Guerrero did Berto. Trout has to make some stylistic adjustments so that he can capitalize Cotto's…

Comment by Motofan on 12-01-2012

This fight may shock a lot of people...maybe not...but I think it's a toss up.

Comment by b morph on 12-01-2012

[QUOTE=wizard king;12757520]Some people are going to be very upset when trout whoops that a$$$ people are going to see that cotto doest belong at 154. 11 rd tko win for trout.[/QUOTE] its not like trout possesses a lot of punching…

Comment by wizard king on 12-01-2012

Some people are going to be very upset when trout whoops that a$$$ people are going to see that cotto doest belong at 154. 11 rd tko win for trout.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (26)
Top Headlines Video: Manny Pacquiao Talks Camp, Retirement, Vargas, More Demetrius Andrade Very Motivated as Jack Culcay Clash Nears Photos: Manny Pacquiao Putting in Work at Wild Card Gym Canelo Says The Ball is in Golovkin's Court: Accept The Offer! Ricardo Mayorga Crashes Into Taxi, Pursued For 200K in Damages Canelo Eager To Prove WBO Prez's Prediction of Mayweather KO Vences: A Win Over Casey Ramos Will Open A lot of Doors For Me Photos: Juanma, Vazquez Explode in Very Tense Final Presser Ustinov's Manager Expects WBA To Order Klitschko Title Fight Premier Boxing Champions Reveal Season 3 Schedule Helenius Faces Basile on 12/17, Chisora Rematch Eyed For March Arthur Abraham Shelved For Three Weeks Due To Elbow Injury SHO's Espinoza: Mayweather Won't Even Joke About Ring Return Curtis Stevens-De La Rosa Added To PPV Portion of Kovalev-Ward Briggs Claims Haye Used His Name: He Backed Out of Our Deal Cuellar Vows To Take Mares Out - Targets Frampton, Santa Cruz Klitschko: No Retirement, Joshua Fight Will Be Biggest in Years Wilfredo Vazquez Jr: Juanma Repulses Me, I Will Knock Him Out! Jarrett Hurd vs. Jo Jo Dan Set, Jorge Cota is Now Out Badou Jack Thinks Ward-Kovalev is 50-50, Leans Ward With Pick De La Hoya Not Concerned With The Return of Richard Schaefer Andre Ward: Kovalev Won't Bully Me - He Tires, He Gets Frustrated Arum: Trump Thought of Andy Ruiz When He Said 'Bad Hombre' Tino Avila Wants To Dominate Ramirez, Fight For Title in 2017 Molina: Look at My Wilder Fight, I'll Raise Hell Against Joshua! David Haye: In 2017 I Will Be Heavyweight Champion - I Know It! De La Hoya To Critics: I Strongly Feel Canelo-Golovkin Will Happen Taras Shelestyuk Aims To Follow Gold Path of His Olympic Mates Brandon Rios a Free Agent, No Longer a Top Rank Fighter Katie Taylor Mulling Pro Move, Heading To Eddie Hearn? Fenech: Mundine-Green II is Bullsh*t Fight - Must Be Stopped! Nonito Donaire: I Want The Frampton vs. Santa Cruz Winner Next! Jack Doesn’t Take Much From DeGale’s Tough Fight with Medina Joshua's Fight Will Land on Showtime - Price, Jennings or Molina Keith Thurman vs. Danny Garcia Could Air on CBS in Prime Time George Foreman: Joshua Could Be Become an All-Time Great Andy Lee Wants Tough Fight, Gennady Golovkin Showdown Carl Frampton: I'll Beat Leo Santa Cruz Even More Convincingly! Jack: DeGale is Very Tough, I’ll Win and Be Best at 168 Arthur Abraham Out Of Martin Murray Rematch In Monte Carlo

Latest Active Forum Threads