Bring on an IBF Rematch Order!: The Post Report Card

by Cliff Rold

It’s the sort of boxing crime that will spawn urban legend, touches of myth.  As the days pass into months and years, many will forget how good a fight it really was, how closely competed and how much of a rally now former IBF Bantamweight titlist Joseph Agbeko (28-3, 22 KO needed.

He might have been on the verge.

He wasn’t there yet.

The egregious incompetence referee Russell Mora showed in round eleven, ruling a nut shot a knockdown, sealed the fate of Agbeko.  Because of that call, because of its blindness and stench, time will likely remember August 13, 2011, as a night when Joseph Agbeko came to the land of dreams and found a nightmare.

Found himself robbed.

As in all good myths and urban legends, there will be strong hints of truth. 

It’s not all true. 

Let’s go to the report cards.

Pre-Fight: Speed – Agbeko A-; Mares B+/Post: B+; B+
Pre-Fight: Power – Agbeko B; Mares B-/Post: B; B
Pre-Fight: Defense – Agbeko B+; Mares B/Post: B; B
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Agbeko A; Mares A/Post: Same

For a full recap of the fight, consult here:

It’s not all true because Mares (22-0-1, 13 KO) did a lot of things right in the fight.  He wasn’t responsible for the unwillingness of Mora to deduct points and worked what was available.  Mares was ahead as both men hit the final third of the contest.  Sure, part of that was working the fringes of the rules by way of belt line.

A lot of it was accurate punching above the waist.  Agbeko started slow, and somewhat lethargic, a not so surprising development from an aging little man who had to sweat extra to make weight.  The failure to make weight on the first try Friday looks to have been telling.  Agbeko was not as sharp as he was for his bout with Yonnhy Perez in the first round of the tournament.

Once Mares started to slow down, Agbeko’s physical strength and guts made the fight entertaining.  Beginning in round nine, the tide turned and maybe he could have pulled off the comeback. 

We’ll never know for sure.  The assumption by some is that if Mora takes a point in the eleventh, Agbeko wins the round and the rally plays to him.  The problem with that assumption is it creates a whole new final round.  Mares gave away the twelfth on Saturday.  He could not have in what DC Comics fans might call the “Earth-2” version of the fight.   

One wishes they could have seen such drama.  Mora may have been distracting but he didn’t stop the leather flying.  Mares and Agbeko fought their hearts out on Saturday, fouls and all. 

There is a perfect place to settle all this and it need not be on a world where Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle made a Huntress all their own.

The place is a ring, right on this world, in an immediate rematch.  Fans who saw what was often excellent action Saturday, between controversies, deserve to know who the better man is.  So do the fighters.  Abner Mares is an entertaining, tough kid who should be able to wear or not wear his belt with dignity.  Agbeko is a proud warrior who has experienced sure defeat only once in three blemishes and needs to know whether the latest truly belongs.

This is the part of the show where typically the fighters can be laid against the tapestry of their division, weighing their options.  It would be fine to debate their chances against a Nonito Donaire or Anselmo Moreno. 

It’s just not what it right. 

The IBF is in the best position to make the right thing happen and there can be only one just call. 



Without Mora.


Report Card Picks 2010: 25-10

Ratings Update

Time is always of the essence and there just hasn’t been enough in the last couple weeks to give the divisional ratings the update they need (and deserve).  That should be rectified between now and next week.

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by mshap on 08-16-2011

it's true that out Agbeko was mostly ineffective and tentative until about round 9 when Mares starting tiring -- but the constant low blows definitely were a factor -- Agbeko needs to start stronger mext time and wear Mares down…

Comment by SlimTim on 08-16-2011

If the ref hadn't been paid off by golden girl he would have taken a point early in the fight and Mares would have either A: stop throwing low blows, which would have left Agbeko with fresher legs late to…

Comment by PRBOXINGCOTTO on 08-16-2011

mares already ducking the rematch

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (3)
Top Headlines Judah: Brook Showed Golovkin is Not Invincible, Canelo Can Win Photos: Sam Eggington Drills Frankie Gavin in Birmingham War Photos: Craig Cunningham Shocks Anthony Ogogo By TKO Pacquiao's Co-Trainer Expects Vargas To Fall in Later Rounds Chavez Sr: My Son Will Continue Relationship With Al Haymon De La Hoya: I Knew Pacquiao Would Beat Me Up, I Was a Dead Man Provodnikov, Pirog, Avanesyan, Troyanovsky Part of Reality Show Eduardo Hernandez Blasts Out Victor Terrazas in Two Rounds Luis Nery Closes in on Title Shot at Bantamweight David Lemieux Dominates Cristian Fabian Rios, Wins Decision Steven Butler Crushes Trotter in One, Maduma is Upset Photos: Manny Pacquiao Mobbed as He Arrives in Los Angeles Kevin Lerena Edges Micki Nielsen: Budler, Van Heerden Win Mikey Garcia Aims To Make a Statement With Dejan Zlaticanin Vazquez: I Took 'Worst Deal of My Career' To Get Juanma in There Marquez: I Beat Pacquiao Four Times, No Reason For Fifth Time! Jamie Cox Outpoints Rios in Foul-Fest, Wins WBO Regional Belt Sam Eggington Drops, Batters Frankie Gavin for Knockout in Eight Craig Cunningham Drops, Shocks Anthony Ogogo For TKO Win Kal Yafai Wins, Faces Luis Concepcion on 12/10 in Manchester Sean Davis Edges Paul Economides For WBC Regional Title Hisashi Amagasa Wins Ten Round Decision Over Carlo Demecilo David Price: I Can Knock Joshua Out, Dropped Him Bad in Sparring Lemieux's Manager Confident Canelo Fight Can Be Made For May Luis Nery Looks To Take His Career To Next Level in Tijuana Hekkie Budler Aims To Bounce Back at Kempton Park Josh Taylor Continues To Rise By Drilling Dave Ryan in Edinburgh Magdaleno on Track To Make 122-Pounds For Donaire Title Shot Hassan N'Dam Aims To Revamp Career, Hires Pedro Diaz Shane Mosley: I'm Semi-Retired - But For Right Opponent I'll Fight! For Better or Worse, Heavyweight Glory Still Runs Through Klitschko Golovkin's Coach: Mayweather Deserves Catch-Weight, NOT Canelo! Frank Warren: Klitschko Does NOT Deserve Shot at WBA Title! What To Do With Tyson Fury? - BoxingScene Ratings Update Arum Explains Manny Pacquiao's Lack of Knockouts Since 2009 McGuigan: Frampton Will Make an Impact in Vegas With Santa Cruz Golovkin Warns Saunders: I Want Your Belt, That is My Goal! Joe Hanks, Denis Douglin Return To Action on November 5 Manny Pacquiao Gets in One Last Workout Before Leaving To LA Hearn: I 100% Want Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye in 2017

Latest Active Forum Threads