Wilder Forces Us To Confront Our Fears & Joys In Boxing Fandom


By Corey Erdman

Knockout punches are the ultimate eraser. They can erase errors made in the ring. They can make up for up to eleven rounds lost in the course of the fight. And they can wipe out any amount of criticism from the general public in one concussive instant.

Deontay Wilder didn’t have the greatest week in the public eye leading up to Saturday’s bout against Dominic Breazeale. There was the ongoing annoyance over him not facing fellow heavyweight titleholder Anthony Joshua immediately. Then, there were his comments to a throng of gathered reporters about his lurid desire to kill an opponent in the ring, and wanting that opponent to be Breazeale, for whom he would pay for a funeral.

These cast Wilder in extreme shades of negative light no fighter wants to find themselves standing in: As both a fighter not willing to take the toughest available challenge, and also as one criminally disrespectful of the sport. Said viewpoints failed to take a variety of factors and context into consideration, but even for those holding them, Wilder’s sudden, violent one-punch knockout of Breazeale washed them away completely.

Those who were furious that Wilder wasn’t in the ring with Joshua on this night and scoffed at the perceived mismatch booked in its place were likely still thrilled to watch the knockout live, and likely a few more times on their social media timelines as well. Some of those who maligned Wilder for discussing killing an opponent were the same to share footage of him landing a shot so hard that it could have done just that.

To be clear, there is a significant difference between violence and death, and the desire for violence and the intention of death, both morally and legally speaking. Wilder’s remarks, then, were callous and irresponsible. However, it is an artificial and somewhat fluid line we draw in terms of both fighters’ behavior and their relationship with violence, as well as our own concern for fighter safety. In reality, we root for fighters to be rendered unconscious, and simply cross our fingers that it isn’t fatal every time their heads bounce off the canvas and their eyes gloss over.

wilder-breazeale-fight (26)

The grand irony is that all it took for public outrage towards Wilder, and the corresponding compassion for boxers’ livelihood to vanish was a brutal knockout to push it off our timelines. The television broadcast, in good taste, addressed Wilder’s comments indirectly by describing them as “controversial,” and lumping them in with general “bad blood” between fighters. Once the fight was over, Wilder apologized for his remarks, told Breazeale he loved him and that his comments were simply a means of fight promotion. Very little correspondence following the bout viewed Wilder’s pre-fight comments as contextually relevant to the result that unfolded.

When Wilder speaks of the desire to kill a man, we’re willing to make two allowances: We either don’t believe that he means it, or we believe that he means it, but we don’t think that he is going to follow through with it. Because if we accepted him at his word, one couldn’t ethically or legally allow him to enter the ring. Part of our discomfort with him saying what he said is that it forces us to confront the grave possibilities of this sport we enjoy. He comes perilously close to making us all accomplices in something we didn’t necessarily sign up for. But once he comes perilously close to doing so by knocking someone out in a satisfying way, we are not angry anymore.

The theatrical and performative side of fight build-ups is something we are all aware of and take part in. In the midst of them, mortality is often addressed in a variety of ways that don’t seem to discomfort the public. Fighters talk of “destroying” their opponents, or even “ending their careers.” One could take the leap to determine this means the fighter is intending to render his opponent physically incapacitated for the rest of time, which could logically mean the shortening of their life at best, and ending it at worst. However, most just characterize this as a laudable and understandable level of viciousness when entering a prizefight. Fighters also often speak of their willingness to “die in the ring,” which is met with approval and praise for showing bravery. Nobody takes this to mean “tune in tomorrow night, someone might die, and I’m okay with it being me!”

We don’t believe that fighters have a killer mentality heading into a fight—or that they are wholly unafraid of death--but we also don’t know for certain. But as long as mortality is either not addressed, or at least addressed in the abstract, we are able to maintain the illusion and veneer of the Gentleman’s Sport.

Wilder’s comments likely don’t speak to an actual murderous desire in his heart. But the reaction to them illustrates our core struggles with the harsh realities of boxing. Hearing explicitly that a man wants to kill another man in the ring offends our conception of how things ought to be—that this is just a sport, and just entertainment.

Our discomfort speaks to a darker, deeper part of our nature that we hope and believe is not motivating this industry. The reality is that in the name of entertainment, the industry walks all the way up to the line, and in turn we walk right alongside it.

The question now is what will we do with the information we’ve found in confronting this discomfort? Will we move away from treating boxing like a bloodsport? If we don’t want fighters discussing wanting to kill one another, because we know death to be a real--if undesired--possibility, will we then as observers stop questioning the courage of those who lace up the gloves and don’t perform with the ferocity we think we deserve?

If the reaction to Saturday’s bout is any indication, for many, nothing will change at all. All it took was the right kind of knockout to make us forget. Just as all it would have taken was the wrong kind of knockout to make us remember.

All it ever takes is a knockout.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Froch_uppercut on 05-23-2019

[QUOTE=Brettcappe;19760923]Bullocks! You must be a brit. A side/ B side. It's all B.S. Look at the last 10 fights for each guy. Very close competition. Joshua draws huge crowds in England because you have nothing else. Oh, I forgot, soccer!…

Comment by P4Pdunny on 05-21-2019

main thing is they're both cool.

Comment by DaNeutral. on 05-21-2019

[QUOTE=kafkod;19760598]You summed that up perfectly, which is good, because it means I don't have to bother doing it myself, and I have had it with talking about that bull**** $50milliom offer.[/QUOTE] Me too. But these guys keep bringing it up…

Comment by giant_king on 05-20-2019

There's only 3 fighters in the world who instilled that kinda fear besides deontay.Jack johnson a young George foreman and iron Mike

Comment by OPS on 05-20-2019

Great points, and articulate. No offense to Boxingscene but this article belongs on CNN. We're boxing fans not all of us are subtle, especially those stupid fans who would pick Fury over Wilder in a rematch. #BombSquad🥊

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (26)
Top Headlines Miguel Vazquez: I'm Supremely Confident I'll Beat Ohara Davies Kal Yafai: Jimenez First - But Then I Need a Massive Fight Next Shakur Stevenson vs. Franklin Manzanilla Set Down For July 13 Acosta May Have To Wait, Soto Could Get Hit With Mandatory Parker: I Know I Can Beat Ruiz A Lot Clearer If We Have Rematch Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Sulecki - Face To Face at State House Photos: Amir Khan Grinds Hard in Camp For Goyat Clash Wladimir Klitschko Rescued After Yacht Catches Fire in Spain Tony Luis Edges Adrian Estrella With Majority Decisions Win Herring Keeping Options Open While Negotiating Mandatory Mikey Garcia's Coach Believes Lomachenko Fight is Still Possible Pacquiao: Thurman Reminds Me of The Miguel Cotto Fight Photos: Pacquiao Continues To Look Fierce in Camp For Thurman BoxingScene Championship Stats, Records: June 2019 Update Gorman: When I Beat Daniel Dubois, What Will He Say Then? Hearn: Anthony Joshua vs. Andy Ruiz Rematch Will Be Massive Lee Selby's Coach: No Issue Fighting Adrien Broner in The U.S. Dawejko Received Death Threats Over Joshua Sparring Rumors Suddenly Violent Rigondeaux Renews Case For 122 Supremacy Adrien Broner vs. Lee Selby in The Works For Later This Year Rey Vargas Expects Fireworks, Vows To Turn Back Tomoki Kameda Andres Gutierrez Edges Tomas Rojas For WBC Regional Title Juan Manuel Marquez Returns To The Ring - As a Promoter McGregor Was Very Pleased That Lobov Defeated Malignaggi Tramaine Williams vs. Neil John Tabanao on Chad Dawson Card Khan: Hopefully Pacquiao Beats Up Thurman, Then We Can Fight! Warren Fires Back at Hearn, Rolls Eyes at Matchroom DAZN Shows Bellew: Tyson Fury Beats Anyone - If It Goes Past 4 Rounds Callum Smith Hopes To Get Clarification on Canelo Possibility Andrade: GGG, Canelo Not The Best Talents at 160 - Just Popular Photos: Amir Khan vs. Neeraj Goyat - Jeddah Press Conference Hughie Fury vs. Sam Peter Set Down For Khan-Goyat Card Dirrell vs. Benavidez Targeted for Wilder-Ortiz Undercard on 9/28 Photos: Jermell Charlo Crushes Jorge Cota With Vicious KO Thurman Touched by Mike Birmingham Hall of Fame Induction Photos: Rigondeaux Goes To War With Ceja, Gets TKO Win Pacquiao-Thurman: No VADA Testing In Place for July 20 PPV Event Rigondeaux: I Wanted To Show Critics I Can Fight at Short Distance Charlo: Harrison is Lucky He Didn't Accept This Fight With Me! Blair Cobbs: I Have The Talent To Beat Anyone at Welterweight

Latest Active Forum Threads