WBC: Porpramook vs. Taconing Should Have Been a Draw

by Ronnie Nathanielsz

The WBC Ring Officials Review Committee chairman , veteran boxing judge Tom Kaczmarek who reviewed a DVD copy of the WBC light flyweight title fight between Thai champion Kompayak Porpramook and Filipino challenger Jonathan Taconing last May 3, 2010 has “found that the fight should have been a draw, 47-47” although Kaczmarek conceded that “the referee acted with some confusion in the 4th and 5th round.”

WBC president Don Jose Sulaiman had asked for the review after Porpramook was awarded a hugely controversial 5th round technical decision over the No. 6th ranked Taconing, prompting the Filipino boxer’s manager Johnny Elorde to tell Sulaiman he was “disappointed the way the fight ended” when Korean referee Jae Bong Kim stepped in and stopped the barrage of punches that Taconing was landing in the 5th round after he trapped the champion in a corner.

The referee stopped the fight, ordered a one point deduction against Taconing because of a cut suffered due to an accidental clash of heads in the previous round.

In his letter to Sulaiman, Elorde said “we feel the fight should not have been stopped because the cut was too small.”  His view was supported by boxing writers including the report on and Fight News which also ran a video of the fight. Elorde also noted that the Thai ring doctor was “atop the ring even if the fight was still going on.”Elorde claimed that “Kompayak could have gone down if referee Kim did not stop it.”

The WBC president told the Manila Standard that from what he saw “the DVD is not very clear in the critical moments of the fight.”  Sulaiman said the referee “made a mistake by not deducting a point from Taconing for the accidental head-butt (immediately) but also one other in not deducting a point from Porpramook.”

Sulaiman said the cut was “not seen well in the DVD but it was not bleeding much. I think the referee acted too soon to take the boxer to the doctor but it was the doctor who stopped the fight.” The WBC president said the doctor has been in the WBC for about 15 years.

When asked by the Manila Standard about a possible rematch in the wake of the controversy, Sulaiman said WBC rules “ do not accept rematches unless the original fight was of such world acceptance that a rematch would be convenient for the sport.”

He also noted that former champion Adrian Hernandez made a voluntary defense against Porpramook and “got back two options and as the WBC did not accept an immediate rematch that Hernandez wanted. Porpramook was allowed a voluntary defense.” This means Porpramook’s next fight must be against Hernandez simply because he owns an option” otherwise both the Thai champion and the WBC may be liable for a lawsuit.

Sulaiman revealed that Thangarajah’s report stated that “even in the arena the cut was not seen as important” but they thought it was about 3” long and 6” deep and needed surgery “with the beginning of the cut at a dangerous place on the eye.”

In reference to Hernandez’s request for an immediate rematch after losing by a 10th round TKO, he said it was because the Mexican on his arrival “was taken to a ‘hot bed’ motel and that he was treated without any consideration and was left under the sun for about two hours just before the fight.”

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by nycsmooth on 05-26-2012

as oveseeing/governing body the WBC can change it, so do it & make it right...

Comment by jucare2 on 05-26-2012

Last May 3,2010?..Ronnie has hang over or what? Taconing needs to look for another way the WBC will approve a rematch.

Comment by komandante on 05-26-2012

Taconing was clearly robbed of that decision and if he's a Mexican surely Sulaiman will order an immediate rematch. :fing26:

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (3)
Top Headlines Gervonta Davis Says He'll Fight Abner Mares February 9 In SoCal Michael Conlan Very Comfortable With The Pressures of Boxing Canelo on Mayweather Rematch: Anytime He's Ready! Rigondeaux Training With Ronnie Shields, PBC in Corner Too Luis Nery vs. Carlos Sardinez on December 1 in Saltillo Lipinets: Loss To Mikey Garcia Prepared Me For Lamont Peterson Broner: Pacquiao is a Black Fighter - F***ed Up Money & Taxes! Photos: Manny Pacquiao, Adrien Broner - Face To Face in LA Manny Pacquiao, Freddie Roach Have No Deal Yet Rob Brant Inks Co-Promotional Deal With Top Rank Espinoza: If You Think Broner Is Easy For Pacquiao, Think Again Canelo Alvarez vs. Rocky Fielding To Hit Movie Theaters LIVE STREAM: Pacquiao-Broner - Los Angeles Press Conference Deontay Wilder vs. Tyson Fury: More Tickets Released at Staples Photos: Pacquiao Hits The Basketball Court, Becomes 'Air Manny' Bryant Jennings vs. Oscar Rivas Finalized For January 18, ESPN+ Giovanni Mioletti Keeps Record Intact With Another Stoppage Win Peter Kadiru Goes Pro, To Be Advised By Klitschko's Manager Wilder, Fury, Hurd, Ortiz Share What They Are Thankful For Martin Murray vs. Hassan N'Dam is Set For Warrington-Frampton Wilder vs. Fury PPV Will Be Available Via The Showtime App Breazeale: The Ultimate Goal is Anthony Joshua Rematch Pacquiao: Right Now, I Have No Intention Of Running For President Sanchez: They Are All Using Golovkin's Name To Stay Relevant! Joseph Parker on Dealing With Adversity Versus Dillian Whyte Frank Warren: I've Never Seen Tyson Fury This Determined Tommy Coyle: I Fight Because I Love it, But It's a Dangerous Game Sergio Martinez Still Aims To Return, Continues To Train Hard UK News: Brian Rose, Troy Williamson, Tyrone McKenna, More Pacquiao is Focused: We Can't Underestimate Adrien Broner Jarrell Miller Wants Anthony Joshua in April at Wembley Giving Thanks For a Boxing Dream Come True Pacquiao: I Think Fans Are Excited For Rematch With Mayweather Adonis Stevenson Hopes Pascal Wins, Not Impressed By Bivol David Lemieux: I Want Canelo Because I Know I Can Beat Him! Ellerbe: Broner Will Look To Defy The Odds, Shut Everyone Up Vijender Singh Inks Promotional Pact With Top Rank News: Christopher Diaz, Bryant Perrella, Tori Nelson, Luis Lebron Hearn: Hooker is The Standout at 140, I Want Defense in Dallas Broner: F*** The Money, I'm Not Just Coming To Get a Check

Latest Active Forum Threads