Top Rank Content With NYSAC Reconsideration Verdict

By Jake Donovan

Representatives at Top Rank were pleased – relatively speaking – with the verdict from Friday’s meeting held by the New York State Athletic Commission regarding the license status for Antonio Margarito.

A 45-minute discussion amongst the panel revealed that the commission wants its recommended physician to examine Margarito and also review testimony from two of the leading ophthalmologists in the country during Wednesday’s closed-doors hearing before making an official ruling.

At stake in Margarito getting a license is his already scheduled December 3 grudge rematch with longtime rival Miguel Cotto at Madison Square Garden. The fight is roughly 1,500 tickets away from being a sellout, but everyone’s plans are on hold until the NYSAC makes an official decision.

As rough as it sounds, it certainly beats the alternative, which was to relocate the fight to a state where Margarito is already licensed for the sake of saving the show, which also includes an undercard loaded with action fights.

“It’s better than being denied, that’s for sure,” said Bob Arum upon hearing the news that the commission’s final decision wasn’t so final after all.

It’s been a crazy stretch for the Hall-of-Fame promoter and the rest of the folks at Top Rank. After covering ground of more than 20,000 miles to promote last weekend’s third chapter in the memorable rivalry between Manny Pacquiao and Juan Manuel Marquez, the soon-to-be 80-year old promoter has traveled to New York and Texas in the past week to cover hearings, press conferences and a fight.

Plans were already in place for Arum to be in Houston for the finishing touches on the promotion for this weekend’s middleweight title fight between Julio Cesar Chavez Jr and Peter Manfredo Jr. The bout headlines a nine-fight card at Reliant Arena in Houston, airing live on HBO’s Boxing After Dark, along with the exclusive replay of Pacquiao-Marquez III (Saturday, 10:30PM ET/PT).

His travel itinerary was altered due to Wednesday’s hearing in New York to obtain testimony from ophthalmologists regarding Margarito’s eye surgery following last November’s battering at the hands of Manny Pacquiao. The bout was the last time that Margarito has stepped foot in the ring, taking off most of 2011 before agreeing to terms for a rematch with Cotto.

Margarito handed Cotto his first loss in their July ’08 thriller, which was stopped in the 11th round. The troubled Mexican endured an embarrassing scandal in the moments before his nine-round shellacking against Shane Mosley just six months later, when it was discovered that his handwraps were doctored.

The fallout resulted in a one-year ban from fighting anywhere in the United States, along with a lifetime suspension issued to then-trainer Javier Capetillo. The incident became an issue with the Nevada State Athletic Commission, who held a hearing last summer only to table the application until Margarito agreed to appear in front of the California panel, since they issued the initial suspension.

It also served as a roadblock for Margarito fight in Texas last March, as the commission was urged by Tim Lueckenhoff, president of the Association of Boxing Commissions, to strongly consider all factors before blindly defaulting to a license renewal. The series of events resulted in his planned bout with Carson Jones hitting the scrap heap.

Margarito then took his act to Mexico, scoring a 10-round decision over Roberto Garcia last May in what represents his last win as his record stands at 38-7 (27KO).

However, his in-limbo standing with the New York State Athletic Commission has nothing to do with the aforementioned scandal, but more so concerns over his health.

Top Rank representatives understand the precautionary measures being taken and are far more confident than they were a day or two ago that justice will ultimately prevail.

“Bring it on,” stated Lee Samuels, publicist for Top Rank, when informed of the NYSAC’s decision to request a medical exam. “We have absolutely nothing to hide. We’re confident that the commission doctor will find Margarito fit to fight.”

Backup plans have already been discussed in the wake of previous suggestions that Margarito’s license would be denied. The strongest rumors suggested an unspecified location in Texas hosting the show, which will air live on HBO pay-per-view. Colorado and Mississippi were also mentioned as alternate locations, since Margarito is licensed in both states.

For now, everything remains in place until the New York commission decides one way or another.

“No matter the outcome, we’re doing everything in our power to save the show,” Arum insists. “The show must and will go on, as planned on December 3.”

Such efforts mean that a trio of can’t miss televised undercard fights – Pawel Wolak-Delvin Rodriguez II, Brandon Rios-John Murray and Mike Jones-Sebastian Lujan – remain on as planned, which in turn means that none of the fighters have to break camp for a huge opportunity just two weeks away.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Follow Jake on Twitter at or submit questions/comments to [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by KTFO on 11-19-2011

[QUOTE=flint;11446090]money talk. war cotto. if the eye is ok then it won't be after the fight. cotto has one of the stiffest jabs in the sport and i hope he recracks the cheaters face. boxing is better off without a…

Comment by prime minister1 on 11-19-2011

i still dont understand how margarito is allowed to fight...they should treat him like Luis Resto or any other criminal.

Comment by paulf on 11-19-2011

[QUOTE=NWO4Life;11444977]They should hold it in an "undisclosed" location, all underground style and ****. Like something out of that Van Damme movie "Lionheart" where they are fighting in a parking garage inside a circle of limousines with a bunch of high-rolling…

Comment by Hyper Knuckles on 11-19-2011

If Arum can pay the judges off to rob Marquez of a win in a legendary trilogy, then surely he can bribe the commission into making this fight happen in NY.

Comment by flint on 11-19-2011

money talk. war cotto. if the eye is ok then it won't be after the fight. cotto has one of the stiffest jabs in the sport and i hope he recracks the cheaters face. boxing is better off without a…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (12)
Top Headlines Hearn: When Jacobs Beats Canelo - He'll Be Pound For Pound #1 Roach: Joshua is Best in Division, But Better Beware of Tyson Fury Photos: Jessie Vargas Sharpening Moves For Humberto Soto Photos: Daniel Roman, TJ Doheny - Put in Work For Unification Photos: Srisaket Sor Rungvisai Grinds For War With Estrada Photos: Juan Francisco Estrada Puts in Work For Sor Rungvisai Photos: WBC Reveals The "Mayan Belt" For Canelo vs. Jacobs Photos: Rances Barthelemy Grinds For Robert Easter Title Clash Photos: Mohamed Mimoune Putting in Work For Viktor Postol Hunter: I Told Hearn I'm Ready For The Challenge of Joshua Mikey Garcia To Be Champion Emeritus, Campbell Goes For Title Garcia-Granados Main Event Peaks At 1.468 Million Viewers Team Luis Ortiz Reject Hearn's "Lowball Offer" To Face Joshua Oscar Rivas Was Close To Top Rank Deal When Whyte Offer Came Chauhan and Kumar Battled To a Draw in Mumbai, India Ruben Villa vs. Luis Alberto Lopez Tops ShoBox Card on May 10 Virgil Hunter Agrees That Amir Khan Still Has A lot Left in Tank Wilder-Breazeale - 'All Access' Series Starts on May 10, Showtime Golovkin Wants To Try Out 164 Pounds, Rolls 'To Be Comfortable' Roy Jones: Amir Khan Quit, He Should Be Honest and Apologize World Boxing Super Series Inks Pact With Sky Sports, Matchroom Darmani Rock Stays Busy With Hometown Return in Philly Barthelemy Still Plans To Go Back Up To 140 For a Title Shot Daniel Jacobs Unconcerned About Getting Fair Shake With Judges Crawford’s Trainer: F*** That; Not Fighting Brook In England BoxingScene Pound for Pound: April 2019 Update Chisora's Coach Does Not See Usyk as The Right Fight Enock Poulsen vs. Michal Syrowatka For Vacant EU Title in Play Amir Khan: Retiring at The Wrong Time Would Haunt Me Dana White: After Summer - I'm Making All of My Boxing Moves Froch Believes Time is Right For Dave Allen vs. David Price Rolls Admits on Golovkin: I've Got Mount Everest Ahead of Me! Victor Ortiz Raises Hand: Willing To Do Marcos Maidana Rematch Sergey Kovalev: Facing Artur Beterbiev is a Priority For Me Danny Roman Breaks Down His Unification With TJ Doheny Joe Noynay Stops Kosuke Saka, Wins WBO Regional Belt in Osaka Andy Ruiz Confirms He is in The Mix To Face Anthony Joshua Bob Arum is Pleased, Saw Improvements in Felix Verdejo Joshua: Jarrell Miller Does Not Deserve To Be in The Ring Estrada: I Feel Very Strong, Very Fast - I'll Take Sor Rungvisai's Belt

Latest Active Forum Threads