Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Team Pacquiao's pursuit of Spence shouldn't progress beyond talk


By Lyle Fitzsimmons
I appreciate Manny Pacquiao.

The things he’s accomplished since reaching the championship level more than two decades ago measure up to anyone over the same time frame, and he’ll be a deserving International Boxing Hall of Fame inductee at the very instant he becomes eligible.

But in spite of the hype still resonating from a downing of intermittently active title-holder Keith Thurman nearly two months ago in Las Vegas, any days resembling his best ones are long, long gone.

The oft-injured Floridian had been campaigning on reputation alone for the more than two years, and Pacquiao, now 40, hasn’t beaten anyone capable of truly elite-level resistance – Tim Bradley, let’s say – since his odometer was a few months past 37.

Nevertheless, the Filipino camp was buzzing pre- and post-Thurman with talk of one Errol Spence Jr.

“If (Manny is) gonna continue in boxing, I want him to fight the best guys he can,” veteran trainer Freddie Roach said. “We’re not looking for any stiffs or any easy fights or anything like that. We will fight anybody out there. If Floyd doesn’t come, Errol Spence, all of them. Line them up.”

For those uninitiated, the Texan was an elite amateur, then a professional prodigy and has since become a three-defense champion since an impressive road KO of welterweight claimant Kell Brook.

He’s among the very best fighters in today’s world to these eyes – warranting a spot alongside Vasyl Lomachenko, Terence Crawford and Canelo Alvarez, among others – and he’s the kind of fighter who appears poised to maintain that status for the long term.

“The Mayweather era has stopped,” said veteran promoter Richard Schaefer, following Spence’s clinic against fellow pound-for-pounder Mikey Garcia earlier this year.

“A new era has started today – the Errol Spence era.”

pacquiao-spence (2)

Mayweather, for those who’ve forgotten, won 50 fights in a career (including a defeat of Pacquiao) that touched three decades and he will certainly be part of the IBHOF’s induction class come 2022 or beyond – alongside more recognizable surnames like Ali, Robinson and Marciano.

Whether Spence stays relevant long enough to record a worthwhile fraction of Mayweather’s relevance remains a mystery, but one Ali-era commandment seems clear from this vantage point:

If Pacquiao even dreams about beating Spence, he’d better wake up and apologize.

While a guy like Crawford has already leapt from 135 pounds to 140 and subsequently evolved into a terrific welterweight, those around the aging senator have long insisted he’d be more comfortable – and perhaps more devastating – with a move down to 140, a division he invaded with a two-round erasure of Ricky Hatton in 2009 before chasing bigger names and purses at 147 and beyond.

Making a play for Spence, then, would be a bite far more than the Filipino is capable of chewing.

Spence would stand four full inches taller in a press conference staring contest while possessing an even more significant five-inch edge in reach, and a successful match with a certified pay-per-view stalwart would go a lot further toward putting the 29-year-old over with mainstream fans – and tilling the ground for even bigger shows – than unifications at 147 with the rugged, albeit lesser likes of Shawn Porter.

Porter puts his recently-won WBC slice of the 147-pound pie against Spence’s IBF portion on Sept. 28.

The IBF title, incidentally, belonged to Porter before he lost to Brook.

“It's going to be a very exciting fight,” Spence said. “Shawn is never in a boring fight and I always entertain. It will be a Fight of the Year type fight because our styles mesh. Shawn Porter is a guy who tries to rough you up. That's what he's always done. With Yordenis Ugas he tried to box and he said he didn't like that style. He said he is going back to his original style. If he brings that style to me, it's going to be a great fight because I'm going to bring it right back to him.”

In other words, it's a coming-out party waiting to happen.

Presuming he gets past Porter, Spence will be squarely on the “eventually, he'll get Pacquiao” path promoter Bob Arum used to suggest for Brandon Rios – before age, weight and brawls took their toll on “Bam Bam” and ultimately made the duel more sparring than scintillating.

Spence seems in no danger of such precipitous fizzling, thanks to both talent and will.

“I always want to outperform my foes,” he said. “There’s a lot of people salivating for me to be No. 1, and I should be by next year. Hopefully I’ll be mentioned as an all-time great like Sugar Ray Leonard and Floyd Mayweather, and Tommy Hearns and Oscar De La Hoya.”

Indeed, headliner shows warrant far better than bar-band encores.

And given the 29-year-old’s comfort on the big stage, there seems no reason not to start the tour.

* * * * * * * * * *

This week’s legit title-fight schedule:

Vacant IBF mini flyweight title – Taguig City, Philippines
Samuel Salva (No. 1 IBF/No. 29 IWBR) vs. Pedro Taduran (No. 3 IBF/No. 27 IWBR)
Salva (17-0, 10 KO): First title fight; Won lone 12-round fight by decision
Taduran (13-2, 10 KO): Second title fight (0-1); Two career wins in 12-rounders, both by KO/TKO
Fitzbitz says: Neither guy really belongs in a title fight. Still, it’s an interesting match of Filipino kids. Salva may have a high ceiling, but Taduran has fought better guys. Tie broken. Taduran by decision (51/49)

Last week's picks: 1-0 (WIN: Lomachenko)
2019 picks record: 69-14 (83.1 percent)
Overall picks record: 1,080-357 (75.1 percent)

NOTE: Fights previewed are only those involving a sanctioning body's full-fledged title-holder – no interim, diamond, silver, etc. Fights for WBA "world championships" are only included if no "super champion" exists in the weight class.

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Tosaken on 09-09-2019

[QUOTE=Twako;20035363]and spence intentionally didn’t fight physical against the much much smaller much predictable and stationary mikey when he had the chance? lol. [B] imo, spence is the least technical among the top ww’s. he’s just big, with the least defense.[/QUOTE][/B]…

Comment by TheUptownKid on 09-05-2019

I think these articles get clicks and that is a success for a writer. I think if you write an article everyone can generally agree on no one will remember your name so I appreciate the slight controversy. That being…

Comment by FredRekk on 09-05-2019

[QUOTE=Roadblock;20033966]Errol is not coming off major surgery and two years out with a poor performance comeback fight, to be honest Porter will be tougher for Errol to beat than Manny will be, youre a fan boy you can only see…

Comment by Oregonian on 09-05-2019

[QUOTE=hugh grant;20036464]Spence needs to beat thurman to prove he really is best WW first.[/QUOTE] ——- Didn’t Thurman just lose? Thurman should do what PAC did after he got KO’d by Marquez - PAC fought Brandon Rios so Thurman should fight…

Comment by Jesse Wick on 09-05-2019

[QUOTE=Oregonian;20035501]———— Which pretty much proves my point. They call out the top WW then proceed to fight Brandon Rios or Mathysse or Broner and now I hear Danny Garcia is being floated to fight pac.[/QUOTE] I was agreeing with you.…

Top Headlines
Michael Dutchover vs. Manuel Mendez Set For November 1 Tyson Fury Vows To Fight in 2020 - Against Wilder or Someone Else Turchi vs. Grisunins Tops Matchroom Italy Card on October 23, DAZN Frank Warren: Jose Ramirez Must Face Catterall or Vacate Title! Ronnie Shields: Jermall Will Fight Canelo At 168, 175, Wherever He Wants Lomachenko: Lopez Talks Too Much - If You Insult Me, Prepare For Pain Chisora: Tyson Fury Has Promised Me A Third Fight; He Owes It To Me Joshua Buatsi Expects Tough Clash With Marko Calic Chantelle Cameron Could See a War in Araujo WBC Title Clash Pacquiao: I'd Only Fight McGregor If I'm Co-Promoter of The Event Gamboa's Manager: Fight With Devin Haney Will Not Disappoint Bryan Polaco, Omar Rosario Grace Undercard Of October 2 Boxeo Telemundo Show Boxing's Competitive Health Merits Celebration Andy Ruiz Says Ring Return Pushed To 2021, Training With Reynoso Davis vs. Santa Cruz Moves To Oct. 31 In San Antonio With Fans In Attendance Usyk's Handlers Believe Joshua Will Vacate WBO Belt To Fight Fury Charles Conwell Hopes To Fight For a World Title By The End of Next Year Ohara Davies Edges Tyrone McKenna in Golden Contract Final Arum: Fury-Wilder III No Longer Scheduled For 12/19; Could Occur Earlier Devin Haney-Yuriorkis Gamboa: Announcement Imminent For 11/7 Fight Hearn: Joshua Will Go To Great Lengths To Make Fury Fight Happen Daniel Jacobs, Gabe Rosado Reach Agreement To Fight November 27 David Navarro, 2020 U.S. Olympic Alternate Signs With Split T's Tim VanNewhouse Jose Zepeda: I Want To Make It Clear That I Am Ready For Anybody Teixeira: If WBO Authorizes, I Will Be Happy To End Charlo's Career And Then Fight Castano Mikey Garcia: Manny Pacquiao Fighting Me Next 100%, Not Conor McGregor Ohara Davies: I'm Ready To Shut Everyone Up; I'm A Lot Better Than Fans Think Kane Baker Feels Mentally Ready For a Good "Tear Up" With Aqib Fiaz Linus Udofia: I Want To Show John Harding is Not On My Level Joshua: Fury Went Pro in 2008, Never Thought I Would Catch Up To Him News: Petros Ananyan, Atid Oberlton, Joe Ham, More Manny Pacquiao Ring Return Will Likely Require Some Fans in Venue Ivan Baranchyk: To Be The Best at 140 - That's My Motivation Cazares: I'll Knock Canelo's Freckles Off, Reynoso Can Pick Them Up! Canelo Alvarez Refiles Breach of Contract Suit Against DAZN, Golden Boy, De La Hoya Casimero Wants Inoue But Now Has Other Options, Says Gibbons Angel and Chavez Barrientes Discuss Upcoming PBC Bouts Edgar Berlanga's Promoter Hopes Bellows Will Last a Few Rounds Mikaela Mayer vs. Ewa Brodnicka Added To Inoue-Moloney Card Jose Pedraza Ring Return Targeted For First Quarter of 2021
Latest Forum Threads