Roach: Cotto Would've Been Criticized for Beating Smaller Garcia

By Keith Idec

NEW YORK – As much as some fans and media might’ve wanted to see Mikey Garcia move up two more divisions to challenge Miguel Cotto, Freddie Roach is glad it didn’t happen.

Roach is confident Cotto would’ve beaten Garcia and just as sure his fighter wouldn’t have received the appropriate credit for giving Garcia his first defeat because Garcia is “too small.”

Garcia (37-0, 30 KOs) revealed last week that he turned down a shot at Cotto on December 2 at Madison Square Garden because he didn’t want to sign a long-term contract with Golden Boy Promotions, Cotto’s promoter, to get that high-profile fight.


Puerto Rico’s Cotto (41-5, 33 KOs) settled for a farewell fight against Sadam Ali (25-1, 14 KOs), a welterweight contender from Brooklyn who’ll move up from 147 pounds to 154 to challenge Cotto for his WBO super welterweight title.

“[Cotto-Garcia] could’ve been a big fight, but I’m not really sold on it,” Roach told before the Cotto-Ali press conference Tuesday at The Garden. “A Puerto Rican against a Mexican is good value, but how well does [Garcia] draw? I’m not really sure. It would be a big fight for him, but if Miguel beats up on a little guy, then people are gonna say the guy was too small anyway. So I don’t think he would get the proper credit.

“So instead he’s fighting a guy who’s popular here in New York, the fight’s here at The Garden and it makes good sense. He’ll have a good fan base, we’ll have a good fan base and it should be a great night.”

Roach also indicated that he’s not sure Garcia, the WBC lightweight champion, really was willing to move up to 154 pounds to face Cotto. Garcia went up from 135 pounds to 140 for his last fight – a 12-round, unanimous-decision victory over four-division champion Adrien Broner (33-3, 24 KOs, 1 NC) on July 29 at Brooklyn’s Barclays Center.

“Mikey Garcia is making a lot of noise and stuff like that,” Roach said. “But he’s calling everybody out. He called Pacquiao out, too. But he’s a little guy and we can’t go in there beating up little guys.

“Obviously, they don’t like me, him and his brother and trainer [Robert Garcia]. They called out Pacquiao and they called out [Cotto], so whoever I have they’ll call out. But who does he really wanna fight? He’s been called out by a couple of guys, also, and he’s not going there.”

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by N!Ck F. on 10-18-2017

[QUOTE=revelated;18145608]Look at my quote, I'm specifically criticizing Roach's reason Manny ducked the fight. Cotto I'm fine with due to size, too much, but Manny? That easily could have happened @140.[/QUOTE] My b. Yes Manny at this stage of his career…

Comment by revelated on 10-18-2017

[QUOTE=N!Ck F.;18144832]Garcia for the Broner fight came in fight night at 150 approximately and was soft. Cotto for his last fight came in at 163 and was lean and solid. That is a HUGE natural size difference. Cotto would of…

Comment by daggum on 10-18-2017

no one would ever criticize him for beating smaller ali

Comment by mapleleaf27 on 10-18-2017

Roach sounds so lame when he states he is "not sure what kind of a draw is Mikey Garcia" if he is so worried about what kind of crowds his opponent can draw then why the F is he fighting…

Comment by DuckAdonis on 10-18-2017

Cotto and Mikey wouldnt be that big of a size difference actually, weight difference ? Yes Both 1.7m and Mikey has a 3cm reach advantage

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (34)
Top Headlines David Benavidez vs. Anthony Dirrell Deal is Reached Photos: Miguel Berchelt, Jonathan Barros - Go Face To Face Photos: Claressa Shields, Hanna Gabriels - Ready For War DiBella Expects Big Things To Come From Dejan Zlaticanin Paddy Gallagher Suffers Broken Jaw, Corcoran FIght is Off Michael Conlan Expected To Get Tested By Dos Santos Kownacki-Martin Probable for Garcia-Porter Card August 25 Taylor Feels Like ‘King Kong,’ Can’t Be Beaten Before Home Fans Jose Ramirez: O'Connor is Tough, Can Take Some Punches Parker Says Joshua Wasn't The Hardest Puncher He Has Faced Spence Would Fight Thurman Before Facing Garcia-Porter Winner UK News: Frampton on Crocker, Darryll Williams, Ryan Garner Frank Warren Breaks Down Murray-Garcia, Dubois, Yarde Card Cordina-Dodd To Contest Vacant Commonwealth Lightweight Title Parker: If I Have The Opportunity, I'd Love To Fight Tyson Fury Tyson Fury Tears Apart Deontay Wilder Over Mike Tyson Claim Shane Mosley Sues Doctor Over Surgery, Claims it Ended Career Lewis Ritson: I Feel Unstoppable, I'll Fight Anyone Hearn Gets Is Boxing About to Ask Fans to Dig Deeper Than Ever? De La Hoya Responds To Errol Spence's Stance on Promoters Sanchez Continues Training Gassiev, Pleased Usyk Fight is Done Photos: Jose Ramirez Putting in Work With Robert Garcia Photos: Miguel Berchelt, Jonathan Barros - Open Workouts WBC Prez: Canelo-Golovkin Has Tremendous Amount of Animosity Stevenson-Gvozdyk, Rivas-Jennings, Beterbiev-Johnson in Play Photos: Claressa Shields, Hanna Gabriels - Face To Face at Presser Munguia vs. Smith Set, July 21 At Vegas' Hard Rock Casino Billy Joe Saunders vs. James DeGale Being Explored For Sept. 15 Khurtsidze Found Guilty in RICO Trial, Faces Long Sentence Kerman Lejarraga To Face Michele Di Rocco Before Gavin Bout Gilberto Ramirez: I am Looking For Unification Fights Bellew: I'd Deal With Fury Swiftly, Viciously Like I Did Haye Spence Not Interested In Signing With Arum, De La Hoya or Hearn Martin Murray, Roberto Garcia Promise Fireworks at The O2 Lewis Ritson Inks New Five Fight Deal With Matchroom Parker's Trainer: We Put Dillian Whyte Fight Together in 3 Days Sanchez, Golovkin: His Riches Have Changed Canelo as a Person Spence on Crawford Fight: We're Gonna Meet Up, Make Big Money Frampton: Me vs. Santa Cruz is The Biggest Featherweight Fight John Ryder Eyes Chris Eubank Jr, Rematch With Rocky Fielding

Latest Active Forum Threads