Porter-Garcia and a Round Robin With Room to Grow


By Cliff Rold

Fans of boxing in general had to be excited about the news. Fox is dramatically increasing their investment in the sport via the PBC side of the game. Any heavy investment that translates into revenue for fighters, more dates, and a network promising more viewer potential is a good thing for the health of the sport.

The PBC was already on Fox but this insures an enduring presence. They had already had presence and investment from Showtime, which sits under the CBS umbrella. The Showtime side has their third fight in what has become a sort of informal series in the welterweight division on Saturday night (9 PM EST).

The first fight in the series was a hit on CBS, matching WBA welterweight titlist Keith Thurman (28-0, 22 KO) and Shawn Porter (28-2-1, 17 KO) in 2016 for what was an entertaining brawl that did eye opening ratings for the network. 

Thurman’s win there led to a big showdown in March 2017 with the man who had been best positioned as a star alongside him from the birth of the PBC, former Jr. welterweight champion and WBC welterweight titlist Danny Garcia (34-1, 20 KO). Thurman-Garcia wasn’t as rough an affair as Thurman-Porter but it still entertained and produced even better numbers for CBS.

Thurman exited a unified titlist. Fans haven’t seen him since, injuries keeping Thurman on the shelf though he is still expected back. The layoff was long enough for Thurman to see the WBC belt vacated. Its owner will be decided this weekend when the wheel turns to Garcia-Porter.

Along the way, Thurman, Garcia, and Porter have beaten various other members of the field available under the PBC umbrella. Porter comes in off wins over Andre Berto and Adrian Granados since the Thurman loss while Garcia has knocked out Brandon Rios.

Those were fights Porter and Garcia were supposed to win. This is a fight where no one can be sure what’s coming. That makes it the right kind of fight, the kind of fight fans should be happy with and frankly expect.

garcia-porter (23)

Boxing’s inability to sometimes deliver fights between competing entities has been a problem for a lot longer than the Mayweather-Pacquiao saga that dominated so much of the 21stcentury. HBO and Showtime often operated in parallel universes in the 1990s as well. The winner of Porter-Garcia, or the loser, or a returning Thurman, isn’t likely to be in with Top Rank’s Terence Crawford in the immediate future.

That sucks but it can at least be countered under each promotional umbrella by making the best fights available to it. At welterweight, and indeed at Jr. middleweight, lightweight, and featherweight this year, we’ve been getting a lot of that from the PBC. Eventually, wells can run dry in any round robin.

There are only so many combinations of fighters, and rematches, that can be made before the fans get restless.

That’s a point of strength for the PBC welterweight crew right now. Round robins between well-matched fighters are never a bad thing and all the options aren’t exhausted. Rematches with Thurman for either Garcia or Porter wouldn’t be bad. New matches with one more piece of the PBC puzzle would be even better. We’ve seen a three man round robin unfolding but there is a chance to make a circle from a triangle.

No matter who wins this weekend, there is one potential superstar in the PBC stable who has yet to share a ring with Garcia, Porter, or Keith Thurman.

IBF welterweight titlist Errol Spence (24-0, 21 KO) is the tiger lying in wait.

Since stopping Kell Brook for his belt last year, Spence has defended twice and impressed both times with knockouts of Lamont Peterson and an overmatched Carlos Ocampo. The 2012 Olympian looks like he’s ready for anyone. The increase of revenue to the PBC should make anyone wondering when Spence will be fully drawn into the mix optimistic.

His time will come sooner than later and the welterweight scene will be the healthier for it. There is already a buzz about a Spence showdown with Crawford down the road but in the meantime we can root for the easiest fights to make first because that’s where the most realistic possibilities lie. Over time more names will surely emerge but there are fresh matches to be made with Spence right away coming out of this weekend. They might not happen next, but there’s no reason to think they won’t. The best thing the PBC can do for Spence is also what appears to be best for business.

This Saturday, we get chapter three in a round robin. Will Spence be there for chapter four? This is a round robin with room for one more.

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by HURTFEELINGS on 09-06-2018

Winner fights Spence, Thuman will get Garcia/Spence winner, then Spence will get Crawford in 2-3 years:boxing:

Comment by PapaBricks on 09-06-2018

Winner fights Spence. End of story no excuses. Cut the bull****

Comment by wrecksracer on 09-06-2018

I don't know...I'm a little tired of the Porter/Garcia/Thurman round robin. It seems like it's been going on forever. How long will it take for the winner to fight Spence? Is Thurman retired? Is Jessie Vargas going to get shoe…

Comment by SHO_RULEZ on 09-06-2018

The one thing that will keep Danny from becoming a mega star is, he's not a very charismatic talker. The post-Rios fight shouting match with Porter was the most fire I had ever seen out of him :lol1:. In recent…

Comment by Kiowhatta on 09-06-2018

Fox and PBC are the perfect match made in hell. Haymon and his stable of one man circus performers who appear on stage once a year in bed with the most nefarious, malevolent anti-ethical journalism network that ever existed. I…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (7)
Top Headlines DAZN Exec: No Reason Boxing Fans Shouldn't Come Check Us Out Iran Diaz Expects Tough Outing, Vows To Shock Sor Rungvisai Thurman: I Look Forward To Reminding Everyone I'm #1 at 147 Khan: I Can't End Career With Canelo Being My Only Big Fight! Photos: Michael Dutchover, Bergman Aguilar Ready For Battle Chocolatito Wants To Take Things Slow, Adapt More To 115 Lemieux on Canelo: I'll Be The Underdog, I Can Surprise Everyone Photos: Victor Ortiz, John Molina Come Together For Media Day Amir Khan: People Think I Can't Take a Shot Jhonny Gonzalez vs. Tomas Rojas on October 6, Mexico City Trey Lippe-Morrison Back in Training With Roach at Wild Card Joe Noynay Breaks Foe To Retain, Toyogon Vaporizes Bolcio Photos: Yuriorkis Gamboa, Miguel Beltran - Go Face To Face Alimkhanuly, Ualikhanov Set To Make Top Rank Debuts Joe Cortez Joins Devin Haney Promotions Magsayo, Brian Norman, Mendoza, Brandun Lee Back on 10/6 Lomachenko-Pedraza Shifts To MSG on 12/8, New Plans For 12/1 Gamboa: Me and Juanma Felt Marlins Park Was Perfect For Event HBO's Lampley: Overwhelming Majority Saw Golovkin Win, Twice Photos: Price vs. Kuzmin, Campbell vs. Mendy - Face To Face Charr Shocked as Positive Drug Tests Cancel Oquendo Fight Photos: Joshua, Povetkin - Face To Face at Final Press Conference O'Shaquie Foster Motivated To Shock Jon Fernandez on ShoBox Joshua Prepared For 'Good Scrap;' Hopes to Stop Povetkin in 8th Ryan Garcia Believes Tyson Fury Will Upset Deontay Wilder Bob Arum: HBO and Showtime Don't Belong In Boxing Anymore Whyte: I'll Get In Joshua's Head, Knock Him Out In Our Rematch Hearn: If Fury is KO'd By Wilder, The Joshua Fight Never Happens James Tennyson Aims To Dominate, Pressure Tevin Farmer Hearn Warns Team Wilder: Hurry Up, You Haven't Got Long Golovkin Opponents Split on Canelo Rematch Outcome Ngabu vs. Merhy in Play For EBU Strap After Jur KO Loss Joshua vs. Povetkin: The Joys of Disappointment Abel Sanchez Not Surprised Canelo Withstood Golovkin's Power Mikey Garcia: My Main Target, Focus and No. 1 Goal is Spence! Adonis Stevenson vs. Oleksandr Gvozdyk Card Coming Together Pacquiao Says No Tune-Up Needed, Mayweather May Have One Miguel Roman: Miguel Berchelt Will Not Withstand My Pace Yuriorkis Gamboa, Juan Manuel Lopez Doubleheader on 11/10 Sergio Martinez Discusses Unbeaten Prospect Jon Fernandez

Latest Active Forum Threads