Paul Mendez and D. Livingston Already Talking Rematch

By Ryan Maquiñana

Following an unsatisfying ending to last Saturday’s Solo Boxeo main event between California-based super middleweights Paul Mendez (10-2-1, 4 KOs) and DonYil Livingston (8-2-1, 4 KOs) in Woodland, Calif., both fighters have already commenced talks of a rematch.

“I got a lot of respect for DonYil.  Like I said on TV, if he wants a rematch, I’ll give him one,” Mendez told  “It will give me an opportunity to win it even more convincingly and clearly the second the time around.”

“I’ll give him that he was ahead about four rounds to two,” Livingston said.  “But the last punch was low, even if it was unintentional, and the ref should’ve given me five minutes to recover and finish the fight.  I definitely want a rematch.”

Mendez floored Livingston with a left hook in the seventh round that landed below the beltline.  Referee Dan Collins mistakenly started administering a count to the fallen Livingston and counted him out.  After much confusion, the California commission officials confirmed Collins’ call, and Mendez was named the victor.

The finish spoiled an entertaining scrap between two promising prospects.  Mendez has shown gradual improvement compared to his last few outings on TeleFutura, and had done enough to win four rounds on this writer’s scorecard.

“I’ve definitely felt a difference in there over the past couple fights training with Garcia Boxing in Salinas,” Mendez said.  “I’ve really gotten better with my boxing skills and setting up my right hand and power shots more.  I’m also in better shape.”

Livingston found success in the third round with a few short uppercuts inside and seemed to have taken the fifth as well.

“I was coming on in the last couple rounds, and I think the next time around, I’ll make a couple adjustments,” Livingston said.  “For one, I could see his jab coming and I just waited too long to throw the right hand.  Actually, ‘Dre was asking me why I didn’t throw the right hand after the fight.”

‘Dre would be Andre Ward, Livingston’s cousin.  The super middleweight champion was in attendance, and if a return bout can be finalized, he might show up to support family once again.

However, unless Livingston wins his appeal with the California commission to change the result from a knockout to a no-contest or at least a technical decision loss, Ward will have to wait at least a month to see it.  By rule, Livingston would be suspended for that duration of time by virtue of being stopped.

“I let Mario [Yagobi], my promoter, handle all that,” Livingston said of the status of the protest.  “Whether they should’ve used the TV replay because we’re in California, I don’t know.  I do think I deserve a rematch.”

Ryan Maquiñana writes a weekly boxing column for  He is a full member of the Boxing Writers Association of America and the Ratings Panel for Ring Magazine. E-mail him at [email protected], check out his blog at, or follow him on Twitter: @RMaq28.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by tostao on 09-27-2012

Chudinov won at least 5 rounds out of 6 vs. fraud mendez , after that fight anybody who fights mendes in california is not in good mind . i wonder why california comission turnes their eyes away on such terrible…

Comment by macman on 09-27-2012

I was wondering how Mendez got what looked to be a gift draw against the slightly smaller Dmitry Chudinov, as I thought Chudinov was the touted prospect & Mendez an 'opponent', & that rarely happens in such circumstances. Turns out…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (2)
Top Headlines Kemahl Russell Drills Michi Munoz in The Second Round The Real Reason Why Floyd Mayweather Is Training MMA Antonio Orozco Wins Return, Estrada and Durate Shine in LA Chavez Sr. Gives Canelo The Edge, Picks Him To Beat Golovkin Undefeated Prospect Gets 11 Years For Being Illegal Drugs Kingpin Miguel Berchelt vs. Miguel Roman May Head To a Purse Bid Top Contender is Accused of Hiring Hitman in Murder of Lawyer Photos: Michael Dutchover, Scott Alexander Ready For Bouts Isaac Chilemba Wins Decision Over Blake Caparello Bellew Frustrated, Explains His Beef With Canelo's Positive Tests Arum on 'Improved' Verdejo: I Have To See it With My Own Eyes Photos: Gvozdyk vs. Amar, Michael Conlan - Ready For Action Photos: Verdejo, Diaz, Pedraza - Puerto Rico Triple Weigh-In Photos: Jose Ramirez, Amir Imam - Ready For Battle in New York Jorgen Hansen Passes Away at 74 Years Old Imam-Ramirez ESPN Tripleheader Weights From MSG Theater Chisora: Little Trainer Won't Help, Bellew Will Knock Haye Out! Yamaguchi Falcao Aims To Impress Against Richard Gutierrez Jose Ramirez: Nothing Amir Imam Does Worries Me Too Much Joe Joyce vs. Donnie Palmer To Be Streamed Live By Ringstar BBBoC news: Andrew Selby must travel to France for Legrand Joshua Doesn't Want Wilder In Ring Post-Parker to Hype Fight News: Oliver Flodin, Stephon Young, Bare Fist Boxing Nietes: Sor Rungvisai, Estrada, Chocolatito - I Want Them Next! Gvozdyk Unsure WBC Will Make Stevenson-Jack Winner Face Him Crawford Erupts, Tells Jeff Horn: You Know I'm F***ing You Up! Parker Warns Joshua: I Look Forward To Handing Out a Whipping!'s Television Picks of The Week - March 16 Felix Valera, Popeye Lebron return to action in the DR on 3/17 Agit Kabayel vs. Miljan Rovcanin Set Down For May 21 Haye Expects Joshua To Take Easier Fight Next - Not Wilder Wilder Reacts To Ortiz's Claim That He Was Saved From KO Loss Photos: Walter Kautondokwa, Billi Godoy - Go Face To Face Photo: Sammy Valentin, Roberto Arriaza Ready For Battle Selby, Warrington Engage in Verbal War During 'Face To Face' Imam: I'll Show Against Ramirez My Loss to Granados Was a Fluke Horn's Promoter on Crawford: Not That Tough, Will Get a Slapping Tomasz Adamek vs. Joey Abell Tops Tripleheader on April 14 Photos: Jose Ramirez Explores The Sights of New York City Canelo-GGG, Joshua-Parker To Have Special WBA Belts at Stake

Latest Active Forum Threads