NSAC Head: No Corruption, Byrd Feels Terrible Over Canelo-GGG

Canelo Alvarez and Gennady Golovkin did their part Saturday night to make their middleweight showdown a memorable one, putting on the kind of big drama show both had promised. They traded big shots and battled for 12 rounds, and when it was over they leaped into the arms of their corner men, both certain they had won.

That the judges ruled it a draw wasn’t out of line. It was that kind of fight, a close, tense bout that could have gone either way, but only slightly.

Unfortunately, one judge somehow had Alvarez winning all but two rounds. The 118-110 margin in favour of Alvarez by Adalaide Byrd was so stunningly off that it dominated the talk at a post-fight press conference that otherwise would have focused on one of the better fights of the year.


Perhaps overlooked by those complaining about the score is that if Byrd had Alvarez winning by a closer margin, say 115-113, the fight would still be a draw and no one would be talking about the judges. It wasn’t that she necessarily got the winner wrong, but by too big of a margin.

Still, there was plenty of venom on social media and from outraged television types for Byrd’s inexplicable card. Golovkin also wasn’t happy about the scorecard in a fight he seemed to be controlling until Alvarez rallied in the late rounds.

The other two judges saw the fight that most at ringside thought they were watching, a bruising affair that appeared to be going Golovkin’s way until Alvarez rallied to take the last three rounds on all three scorecards.

One favoured Golovkin 115-113, while the other had it 114-114.

According to the head of the Nevada Athletic Commission, Bob Bennett, Byrd feels terrible about the entire situation. She is under review, but has not been punished by the NSAC.

“She is not under suspension or been reprimanded in any way. We had a debriefing after the event. She feels terrible that she saw it differently from the other two judges. She explained what she saw and she feels shattered. We’ll review everything in the next few days with the commission and (NAC chairman) Anthony Marnell," Bennett told the Las Vegas Review Journal.

“Adalaide and I will sit down and watch the fight and go over it round by round. She’ll articulate to me what she saw and we’ll move forward.
“She’s an outstanding judge who had one bad night. She’s a professional who always wants to get it right. She looks forward to watching the fight again and seeing what she missed.

“Anyone reporting corruption couldn’t be any further from the truth. Adalaide is a woman of integrity and a judge many around the world have requested for.”

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by keepemup on 09-20-2017

[QUOTE=MisanthropicNY;18067211]White Knight Mangina Cuck to the rescue! Now she's the victim lol... It's Maginas like this that have helped FemiNazis ruin society through forced diversity... This is a Boxing forum... go to take your Victim Card to some Social Justice…

Comment by bigjavi973 on 09-20-2017

[QUOTE=kilojay505;18066660]Your a f#cking idiot you dont know shjt about boxing thats BS he stopped training with Cus because Cus' kicked him out for threating a young Mike Tyson with a gun you bjtch. And after he left he went to…

Comment by thack on 09-20-2017

She is without defence. I'm not certain if she is bent but if she isn't then she's most certainly totally inept to judge fights. If we all carried on in such a manner at work then apart from this human…

Comment by millcitymauler on 09-19-2017

[QUOTE=kilojay505;18066647]Do you not know the difference between a MOVIE and REAL life you dick riding moron.[/QUOTE]I was pointing out that acting in a movie was about the closest thing Atlas has ever been to a real fight. Sheesh. Where does…

Comment by Dle on 09-19-2017

How could Oscar lose when they had one Byrd in the ring and one on the panel of judges. That's what I call "a Byrd in the hand"

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (80)
Top Headlines Daily Bread Mailbag: Canelo-GGG, Hopkins, Spence, Hurd-Charlo McGuigan: Taylor and McGregor Are Going To Be Superstars Frank Warren Expects Dubois, Yarde To Get Tested at O2 Liam Smith: After I Beat Munguia - Khan, Brook Will Want a Shot! Josh Taylor: Postol is Perfect Test, Really Put The Fire in My Belly Sanchez: Canelo Will Only Avoid a KO Loss if He Runs - He Knows! Dubois Vows: Little is Mentally Weak, I'll Show That, He's Nothing How Errol Spence Jr. Became Everyone's Favorite Welterweight Claressa Shields Gets Off The Floor To Decision Hanna Gabriels Claressa Shields, Hanna Gabriels - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Christina Hammer Handles Tori Nelson Easily, Retains Titles Umar Salamov Knocks Out Brian Howard in Ninth Round Photos: Manny Pacquiao Battering Sparring Partners in Camp Shields vs. Gabriels - CompuBox Historical Review De La Hoya Steps Up Vergil Ortiz, Predicts a Very Bright Future Marcus Morrison Loses In Manchester As Show Called Off Lara: Now That Hurd is Injured - I'm Ready To Fight Charlo Next! Photos: Miguel Berchelt, Jonathan Barros - Ready for Mexico War Munguia-Smith, Machado-Mensah Finalized For July 21, HBO Pacquiao Continues To Reject Talk of Matthysse Event Issues BoxNation, Lou DiBella Reach Deal To Air 'Broadway Boxing' Cards Mickey Bey Erupts Over Parting of Ways With Floyd Mayweather Muhammad Ali Book Brings New Insight To Legendary Career Dana White Takes a Swipe at "Very Oversensitive" Eddie Hearn Joe Cordina is Pumped To Face Sean Dodd For Vacant Belt Alfonso Lopez, Raphael Igbowke Return at Humble Civic Center Martin Murray Lashes Out, Shoves Roberto Garcia at Weigh-In Oscar Valdez: I Want Unify Titles With Leo Santa Cruz Parker's Trainer Leans To Deontay Wilder To Beat Joshua Spence: People Will Want to See Thurman Fight Once He Comes Back Tommy Coyle Keen On Facing Lewis Ritson After U.S. Debut 'The New Blood' Series Continues at The Doubletree's Television Picks of The Week - June 22 Jazza Dickens-Martin Ward Set For July 27 At Rainton Meadows Isaac Zarate, Ramiro Robles Ready To Collide at The Doubletree Hearn: If Whyte Wins Big, The Joshua Rematch Has Huge Potential Terence Crawford on Errol Spence: There Can Only Be One King! Hammer: Shields Looking Past Gabriels, Toward Our Fight Next Ellis vs. Mosquera Tops Golden Boy on ESPN Card in Cancun Sanchez: Golovkin Did Not Care About Money, He Wanted Respect!

Latest Active Forum Threads