Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight: HBO Film Finds Fresh Angle

By Cliff Rold

Not another Muhammad Ali movie.

When first it was announced that HBO would be producing a film about Ali’s Supreme Court case, this scribe can’t be alone in the sentiment.  For all his stature, there is a fair feeling that the Ali story at times has over saturated the market.  After Michael Mann’s biopic Ali, When We Were Kings, and even the TV film King of the World, along with countless documentaries, what’s left?

It turns out there was another story to tell.

Reviewing an advance copy of Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight, debuting Saturday on HBO (8:00 PM EST), the story left to tell really wasn’t about Ali at all.  It’s a story about process, politics, the US Constitution, and the men appointed to decipher, interpret, and defend it.

It’s worth a view.

The movie isn’t without its issues.  The juxtaposition of documentary style footage of Ali with the fictionalized depiction of the inner workings of the court wreaks havoc on the pace of the film.  The rationale for structuring the film that way makes sense.

Ali is an icon.  His charisma lights up the screen and it helps to frame the humanity of the case.

The details are known to most by now.  Ali refused induction in the US Armed Forces to serve in Vietnam on conscientious objector grounds growing out of his conversion with the Nation of Islam.  He lost in court and was sentenced to five years in jail and a fine.

The appeals process would take years in the courts and years off his fistic career.

The problem for the film, from a narrative standpoint, is that for the first hour the momentum of the drama seems to come to a standstill when Ali is on screen.  It was a case where less actual Ali would have been better for Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight.

Ali’s is not the only historical footage used.  There is also ample footage of anti-war protests, in particular a Supreme Court enforced ruling against protestors that is portrayed in the film both as a First Amendment betrayal and as a moral fulcrum for Justice John Harlan.  That footage does more to advance the feeling of immediacy in the film and push the plot forward.

And when it gets to its second half, the actors on screen take over and the movie sails.  Harlan, as portrayed by Christopher Plummer, is the real star of the show but meets his match in the form of a court clerk portrayed by Benjamin Walker.  Their interplay, and the relationship between Harlan and Chief Justice Warren Burger, plays like a game of chess as the court moves from a 5-3 vote against Ali to history’s ultimate vindication.

Despite knowing where the story is going, there is real drama on screen as viewers are reminded that while the Court as an institution may stand apart, the men who make it up are just men.  In this case, they are men of real intelligence struggling with issues small and large to try and find something that shouldn’t be so tough: justice.

For older viewers, the film may provide new insights.  For younger viewers, it is a wonderful chance to learn and foster conversation about American jurisprudence.  And for all, if the muddled early part of the film can be weathered the payoff is strong.

Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight isn’t the best movie about the man.  That remains When We Were Kings.

But it isn’t just another Muhammad Ali movie either.

It’s a welcome addition to telling of an important tale.

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

Tags: HBO image   Boxing Television image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by richardt on 10-05-2013

With Ali's condition, it is surprising many of the guys he has fought have died. Not sure how much time Ali has left but so many have been inspired by him, fighters who we would never have seen because they…

Comment by crold1 on 10-05-2013

[QUOTE=mrjoeblive;13812510]Cliff Rold's skills would allow him to be a very good film critic. Politics from older era's robbed a lot of good fighters. Joe Louis thought he was doing the right thing doing exhibition matches for the troops. Some spiteful…

Comment by mrjoeblive on 10-05-2013

Cliff Rold's skills would allow him to be a very good film critic. Politics from older era's robbed a lot of good fighters. Joe Louis thought he was doing the right thing doing exhibition matches for the troops. Some spiteful…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (3)
Top Headlines Jack Catterall Confident That He Would Beat Ohara Davies Zelfa Barrett vs. Ronnie Clark For IBF European Title WBC Prez: Thurman Has To Fight Shawn Porter and Danny Garcia! Warren: Eubank is Domestic Level, How About Groves-Saunders? Golovkin's Coach: There is No Pressure To Knock Canelo Out Kem Ljungquist Feeling Pleased With Recent Performance Hall of Fame Promoter Reflects on Key Atlantic City Fights Frampton: I'll Need To Be at My Best To Beat Nonito Donaire Regis Prograis Very Motivated For Indongo Clash, Bigger Things Mikey Garcia: I'd Rather Fight Errol Spence Than Lomachenko Video: Richard Schaefer on Mayweather in MMA, Eubank's Future Video: Robert Garcia Talks Rios KO Loss, Mikey Garcia, Mares Andy Lee: It Was The Right Time To Retire From Boxing Photos: Jarrell Miller, Johann Duhaupus - Face To Face in NYC Photos: Daniel Jacobs, Maciej Sulecki - Go Face To Face in NYC Photos: Mikey Garcia, Sergey Lipinets - Open Workouts 'SuperFly' Concept to Continue, SuperFly 3 is Likely For The Fall Luis Ortiz Has Been Tested Seven Times for PEDs by VADA, NYSAC Patrick Teixeira vs. Davi Eliasquevici in April for WBO Latino Belt Granat To Train at Kronk With Banks, Tony Yoka Back on April 7 Hearn: If Joshua, Miller Win, They'll Fight in August at Barclays Katie Taylor Vows To Steal The Show at Barclays Center Photos: Callum Smith, Nieky Holzken - Go Face To Face at Workouts Andy Lee Announces His Retirement From Boxing Saunders: Eubank Jr. is Never, Ever Going To Be a World Beater! Wilder: I've Been Calling Out Anthony Joshua For Almost 2 Years! Bradley Skeete vs. Kerman Lejarraga For EBU Belt on March 24 Frederik Hede Jensen Set For Next Fight on March 10 Mikhalkin: It Was Inevitable For Me and Sergey Kovalev To Fight Duva Expects Good Crowd on Night of Competing Cards in NY Alexander Manager: After Robbery - We Want Danny Garcia Next! Rios Hopes 'I Don’t Get Back Down to F***ing Gutter' After Loss Abel Sanchez: Golovkin Turned 'Runner' Canelo into Mayweather! Lucas Browne: I Want a Good, Bloody Fight Against Whyte! Moses Not Happy With Scores, Wants Rematch With Ray Beltran Holzken Warns Callum Smith: Be Ready, I'm Coming To Beat You! Wilder To Luis Ortiz: I'm Gonna Beat Your Ass, You're Going Down! Mikael Zewski Drops, Decisions Jose de Jesus Macias Callum Smith vs. Nieky Holzken in Play For WBSS Clash Callum Smith To Fight New Opponent, Braehmer Withdraws
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement