Mayweather or Who Cares?: Post-Pacquiao Report Card

By Cliff Rold

Being it’s closing in on the Christmas season, let’s pretend fight fans have been more nice than naughty.  Twitter timelines may indicate otherwise, but like kids waiting for Santa, impatience can be well earned.

For five years, there has been one capital “S” superfight.  It’s past time to get it.  Jerry Jones is back talking Cowboy Stadium.  Bob Arum is talking about his buddy Les Moonves.  Stephen Espinoza of Showtime seems relatively muted.

And how many fools would pay to see Manny Pacquiao fight someone like Jessie Vargas? Arum bandied that around some more after the fight.

That idea can rot in hell.

Give us Pacquiao-Floyd Mayweather. 


Let’s go the report card.

Pre-Fight: Speed – Pacquiao A-; Algieri B+/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Power – Pacquiao A; Algieri C+/Post: A; C-
Pre-Fight: Defense – Pacquiao B; Algieri B-/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Pacquiao A; Algieri B+/Post: A; B-

When a guy who suffered a violent knockout three fights past just starts letting the other guy have his best shot, one knows that the drama is gone.  After defending well early against the Algieri right hand, Pacquiao eventually just gave him the shot and ploughed forward. 

Algieri couldn’t budge him.  Algieri’s chances were as slim as assumed.  One fight after earning the chance of a lifetime with a questionable decision over Ruslan Provodkinov, Algieri saw first hand what the levels to the boxing game really are.  Provodnikov is good.

Pacquiao is one of the greatest ever to lace them up.  Even at 35, he’s still not far enough from prime to lose to someone at the level of Algieri.  Algieri, whose best shot was to keep his hands moving, dropped the volume of his offense and survived.  Survival, on a $70-plus pay-per-view, isn’t enough.

Algieri will still have fights he can win.  He was at least tough enough to finish and got up from a whale of a shot in the ninth.  He sometimes made Pacquiao miss badly.  He’ll be cycled back into the mix somewhere.  This cynical promotion, marketed on ‘college’ and ‘hotel room’ locations didn’t win him many fans among hardcore heads. 

Pacquiao scored six official knockdowns, a couple of them spotty, to remind everyone he can still crack.  He seemed almost to be going through the motions as the fight wore on, doing little to set up his shots and abandoning the body.  He was trying for the highlight reel. 

After the fight, he said all the right things.  He’s looking for the missing highlight fight in his career.  He says he wants Mayweather.

Mayweather said he’s open to it after Maidana.

It is at least a different tone than we’ve heard the last couple years.  With Miguel Cotto-Saul Alvarez possible, it’s the one fight in 2015 that could dwarf it. 

It all feels like déjà vu, with the Moonves/CBS wrinkle this time that wasn’t there when the fight fell apart in early 2010.  If they can make it, and make it in Cowboys Stadium, they should.  It’s been an embarrassment to the sport that this fight hasn’t happened. 

Sure, big ones have been missed before.  Lennox Lewis-Riddick Bowe is always an easy one that comes to mind.  It’s never been like this.  Imagine if Leonard-Hearns was nearly signed in 1981 and was still imaginary in 1986?  What if Ali returned in 1970 and hadn’t fought Frazier by the time of the “Thrilla in Manila” in 1975?

Boxing is a business.  It is also a sport.  A sport that can’t make its Super Bowl is a joke.

Pacquiao-Vargas or Mayweather versus the winner of Devon Alexander-Amir Khan, with appetites being whetted for the main course again, would be a punch line.

No more punch lines.

It’s time for the punches to fly.    

Report Card Picks 2014: 55-23 (Includes picks at for Cleverly-Bellew and Vargas-DeMarco)

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by [email protected] on 11-25-2014

leonard never ducked anyone...he even fought donny lalonde for the light heavyweight belt and knocked lalonde out cold... chickenfloyd should make up his mind and take the challenge...the ball is in his hands...

Comment by Det. Conan on 11-24-2014

[QUOTE=Black Barty;15128049]Agree with everything, except Manny vs Vargas would be 1000 times more of a joke than Floyd vs Khan. They aren't even comparable.[/QUOTE] I think you are wrong. Mexican style Vargas Vesus Pacmonster is kinda fireworks guaranteed a KO/KD…

Comment by martin_1995 on 11-24-2014

If he's willing to bet 50 millions on Pac then if mayweather dares (wich I doubt) then we know the fight will happen. Lebron is a winner. I will also bet some $ on Pac. Thanks Lebron for the advice.

Comment by crold1 on 11-24-2014

[QUOTE=Black Barty;15128049]Agree with everything, except Manny vs Vargas would be 1000 times more of a joke than Floyd vs Khan. They aren't even comparable.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE=Jayallday9;15128551]Floyd vs Khan is not a joke fight and it's one Floyd could very well lose...Pac…

Comment by Yogi007 on 11-24-2014

[QUOTE=TMTForever;15129961]you conveniently focused on khan but ignored pacs next fight jessie vargas..typical pacfan always using misdirection.. khan is greater than jessie vargas.. floyd fighting khan while pac fights jessie vargas fopr an interm title at 140..pac and his fans are…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (21)
Top Headlines Wilder: Eddie Hearn is Not a Guy That You Can Trust Liam Williams: Jaime Munguia vs. Liam Smith is Difficult To Call Abel Sanchez: If Usyk Fights Like Before, He's On His Back in 9! Dec Spelman Makes a Successful Ring Return, Back on 9/7 The WBSS at Cruiserweight Worked (and That’s No Small Feat) Hearn: No One Knows Who Wilder is - 50-50 Will Never Happen! Povetkin: I've Always Been Clean, Failed Tests Were Suspicious Christian "Macho Time" Camacho on Boxeo Telemuno Card Crawford Tops Lomachenko, Wins ESPY For 'Fighter of the Year' Teofimo Lopez To Undergo Surgery on Right Hand on Friday Rey Vargas Already Back To Work, Hopes For Quick Return Photos: Jean Pascal, Steve Bosse - Face To Face at Final Presser Anthony Joshua: I'd Rather Lose Than Use PEDs To Win Toka Kahn Clary vs. Kid Galahad - IBF Eliminator Ordered Jazza Dickens vs. Martin Ward Rematch Off Due To Injury Dmitry Bivol: Fight Against Kovalev 'Most Likely' Will Happen Kalle Sauerland Talks WBSS Season 2 Draft, Usyk vs. Gassiev Photos: Mario Barrios Putting in Work For Jose Roman Jean Carlos Torres Headlines Return of PRBBP Series, August 10 Promoter: I Really Believed Munguai Would Knock Golovkin Out Lucas Matthysse Blasts Critics Who Claim He Quit With Pacquiao Abner Mares Joins Announce Team of Boxeo Telemundo Saunders vs. Andrade Purse Bid is Set By WBO For July 25 Anthony Joshua: This is Chapter 2 For Me - All Comers Welcome! Photos: Anthony Joshua, Alexander Povetkin - Face To Face in UK Ryan Martin, Terry Flanagan Aim To Shake Up WBSS Tourney Top Rank President is Very High on Teofimo Lopez Demetrius Andrade Not Expected To Face Billy Joe Saunders Next Miller: I Knew Joshua's a Punk; Wanted to Push His Buttons Manny Pacquiao vs. Lucas Matthysse: Afterthoughts Carl Frampton Getting Annoyed By Trash Talk of Luke Jackson Kamil Delighted After Winning The Right To Remain in Scotland Jermaine Franklin Decisions Craig Lewis at Motor City Casino Bellew: I Prefer Usyk-Gassiev Winner - But Fury Easier, Pays More Joshua: Wilder is Definitely Going To Happen - Confident I'll Win! Zeuge's Coach, Braehmer, Went Bonkers After Upset Loss Shakhram Giyasov Picks Up Stoppage Win in First Round Usyk, Gassiev Could Be One Step Away Before Heavyweight Leap Nacho: Canelo Needs The "Perfect Fight" To Beat Golovkin Subriel Matias vs. Breidis Prescott Set For August 18

Latest Active Forum Threads