Kell Brook-Shawn Porter: Post Fight Report Card

By Cliff Rold

It looked like a good fight going in.

It wasn’t much of that. 

It looked like it was a 50-50 fight.

It was…for about six rounds.  That’s how long it took before Kell Brook, behind a long jab, more accurate punching, and using a wise variety of clinches frustrated and solved the pressure of Shawn Porter.  It was a dominant second half.

It was a new titlist at 147 lbs.

Let’s go the report card.


Pre-Fight: Speed – Porter B+; Brook B+/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Power – Porter B; Brook B/Post: B; B+
Pre-Fight: Defense – Porter B; Brook B/Post: C+; B+
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Porter B+; Brook B+/Post: B; B+

Going into the fight, two things stood out in Brook’s favor.  Brook has good head movement and that could be useful against a winging puncher like Porter.  Also, Brook is quicker than a lot of people gave him credit for.

In the first half of the fight, both factors were at play.  Porter, attacking to the body and making the fight, stayed in the game for six.  He had to attack downstairs because he was often missing badly to the head.  Brook’s chin is an inviting target and he doesn’t always tuck it.  It’s a sucker bet, daring fighters in before he slips away.  He doesn’t always avoid contact but Porter could be seen getting flustered at the elusive target.

Brook doesn’t appear to have much of an inside game when he isn’t clinching.  He’s not going to bang away and doesn’t go to the body much.  As he showed, against Porter tying up and landing the cleaner shots (both from range and catching Porter on the charge), was enough.

It wasn’t always pretty but it worked. 

In a fight where both men suffered cuts on head clashes, it was the man who fought with his head better who won the day.  Brook was a clear winner (117-112 on this card).  That didn’t mean we weren’t without curious scoring.

Porter, credited for ineffective aggressiveness, got a draw on one card and in statement after the fight made clear he felt he’d won.  He hadn’t and the other two judges got it right.  Porter’s ties to advisor Al Haymon made scoring an interesting subplot going in as sometimes his fighters get strange scores.  Two judges got it right this time.

Kudos for doing their jobs.

The fight brings back into perspective some of the hype Porter had picked up in his last two fights.  He’s clearly become better than the fighter who managed only a draw against the chinny Julio Diaz in their first fight and couldn’t put him away in the second.  He’s also not the destroyer he appeared in running over Devon Alexander for a decision or stopping Paulie Malignaggi.

Neither means he’s done.  Porter comes to fight.  He’ll have more chances ahead.

Brook will have stadiums.

Let’s be clear: Brook has already been selling tickets in the UK.  Now, with a title in tow, the chances are bigger.  He may think it’s a good time to thumb his nose at Amir Khan, but it doesn’t erase the possibilities.  Brook-Khan at one of the outdoor venues overseas is a monster.  Juan Manuel Marquez might want a shot too.  A living legend like Marquez, if he would travel, could also put butts in the seats.

It’s an enviable position.  Brook didn’t have to be pretty every moment of the fight to win.  He just needed to be better than Porter and leave with his strap.  Mission accomplished.

Now it’s his turn at the box office.

Report Card Picks 2014: 35-17

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene and a member of the Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by baddog on 08-20-2014

read your review of the fight..........curious why you never mentioned the head butting and CONSTANT hitting behind the head by Porter, you and Pat Russell, the REF, must have been getting snacks at the same time...................

Comment by Straightener on 08-20-2014

I thought it was pretty clear that brook won the fight shame that prick jim watt didn't think the same . hell knows what he was watching sky needs to bin that old fruit

Comment by gmc_rfc_06 on 08-20-2014

Similar fight stylistically. Maidana had a LOT more success though, he still lost but he at least landed some good shots in most rounds. I count about 5 clean punches for the entire fight.

Comment by FLY TY on 08-20-2014

This fight reminded me a lot of mayweather-maidana....a lot!

Comment by LouIE G on 08-20-2014

Brook made a believer of me, but i still think NAZ is the better fighter from sheffield.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (7)
Top Headlines Naoya Inoue's Power Has Improved at 118, Says Sparring Partner Hearn: Anthony Joshua is Very Interested in Rematch With Whyte Frank Bruno Issues Joseph Parker Warning To Anthony Joshua Golden Boy Prez on Golovkin: Sounds Like Fear, Making Excuses Liam Smith: There is No Way Ali Beats Even a 75% Version of Cotto Willy Vlautin and His Love For The Sport of Boxing WBC Prez is Waiting For Mikey Garcia To Make His Decision Golden Boy Prez Reacts: It Sounds Like Golovkin Wants Out! Golovkin: Those Responsible For Draw Are Terrorists, Need Jail! Golovkin: Canelo is Cheating, Using Drugs - De La Hoya is Dirty Yuriorkis Gamboa, Golden Boy Promotions Part Ways Jorge Arce Comes Out Firing in Defense of Canelo, Luis Nery Hearn Reacts To Wilder Calling Him 'White Man Milking a Brother' Ryota Murata vs. Emanuele Blandamura Will Be Carried By ESPN Julian Williams vs. Nathaniel Gallimore Finalized For SHO Triple ESPN Names Mayweather 8th Most Dominant Athlete of Past 20 Years Kautondokwa: After Godoy, I am ready for Billy Joe Saunders! Jose Ramirez's First Defense Targeted For Ballpark in Fresno Tyson Fury's New Goal - Break Joe Louis' 25 Defense Record News: Payano vs. Plania, Braulio Rodriguez, Vicente Eyes Dogboe Photos: Dillian Whyte, Lucas Browne, Frank Buglioni - Workouts Ramirez-Imam Tripleheader Averaged Only 488K Viewers for ESPN Anthony Joshua Won’t Discuss What He'll Weigh for Parker Fight News: Klara Svennson Update, Rocco Wadell Back on April 21 Billy Joe Saunders vs. Martin Murray Moves To June 23rd Parker on Joshua: Somebody is Getting KO'd - It Won't Be Me! Prograis Sees 'Lots of Holes' in Jose Ramirez, Respects His Chin Mikey Garcia Explains Why He'd Want Spence Bout Over Crawford Jose Ramirez vs. Amir Imam: Afterthoughts Liam Smith: I Think Ali Might Be Tougher Fight Than Miguel Cotto Hughie Fury: I'll Be World Champion, I'm a World Level Fighter! Kudratillo Abdukakhorov Rising in Ranks After Malaysia Win Whyte Shakes Head: Joshua is Not Going To Fight Wilder Next Sanchez: If Canelo Dominates Golovkin, I'll Admit GGG Got Old Ismael Salas Denies Rumors of Split With Jorge Linares March Madness shocker yields memories of giant ring surprises Ellerbe Concerned, Would Advise Mayweather To Avoid MMA McGregor Opens as 10-1 Favorite in Mayweather MMA Fight Wilder: I'm Convinced Joshua, Hearn Are Definitely Scared of Me! Buitrago Pulled From Hard Rock Card Over Murder For Hire Beef

Latest Active Forum Threads