Keith Thurman-Danny Garcia: Post-Fight Report Card

By Cliff Rold

Hardcore boxing followers may have been intrigued. Having seen far worse fights, they’ll easily convince themselves that ‘it wasn’t that bad.’

It would miss the point.

In the most anticipated fight so far of 2017, after a string of exciting fights this year including a blazing upset earlier in the day when Tony Bellew beat David Haye, boxing laid an egg. It was exactly the wrong kind of fight in front of the wrong mass of audience.

Last summer, Keith Thurman-Shawn Porter drew boxing’s biggest US television audience since Mayweather-Pacquiao. Free network television matters. Let’s hope some of that good will remains because any channel surfers on Saturday night wouldn’t have seen much to get them fired up about boxing in Thurman’s win over Danny Garcia.

No, it wasn’t a bad fight.

It was just pedestrian.

And, given a CBS stage and some solid promotion, that’s bad enough.      

thurman-garcia-fight (11)

Let’s go the report card.


Pre-Fight: Speed – Thurman B+; Garcia B+/Post: B+; B

Pre-Fight: Power – Thurman A-; Garcia B/Post: B+; B

Pre-Fight: Defense – Thurman B; Garcia B/Post: Same

Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Thurman A; Garcia B+/Post: A; B

It didn’t start out that way. Round one was compelling stuff. Thurman rocked Garcia hard with Garcia seeming to buzz him shortly before the bell. By the midway point of the fight, the fight had lost a lot of that sizzle.

Much of that came down to a difference in speed. The hand speed wasn’t dramatically spread, but Thurman’s foot speed was a decided edge. He figured out early that Garcia could be handcuffed by movement. In a low output fight, that meant Thurman controlled the pace and often dictated when the exchanges would occur.

For most of the night, that meant it was his fight to lose.

Could he have tried to be more compelling? Yes, but in the end he got the victory without it. There were several rounds that could be circled in the swing category but it was hard work to try to find reasons to give them to Garcia. At the end of the night, the split decision came out right but it was still wrong. Thurman won the fight.

Garcia, who has been both the stunning underdog and the lucky receiver of scores, was more the latter on Saturday. Some fighters just have a consistent ability to draw scores even when they don’t appear to be winning. Garcia was just too ordinary this time for the judges to let him get away with it and Thurman had the name value men like Lamont Peterson and Mauricio Herrera didn’t.

But the closing scorecards were still aided a bit by the victor. Thurman gave away at least a couple of the last three rounds.

It might have been even closer than that if Garcia had ever really fought with urgency. Perhaps not realizing how much he needed to change the flow of the fight, the desperation he showed in the last minute of the fight was absent when it could have helped a lot more. To his credit, Garcia still showed some canny accuracy in counter punching, and was solid defensively in the pocket. However, he showed no ability to cut off the ring and made the mistake of following a moving target with one punch at a time too often.

In the end, some fighters just don’t mix for great action. These two appear to be that kind of pair. Split decision or not, nothing here screamed rematch. For Thurman, a mandatory against Lamont Peterson could be intriguing while a rematch with Shawn Porter would be welcome. Garcia can always chase the winner of Kell Brook-Errol Spence or perhaps take what would be an interesting fight with Adrien Broner.

Every fight can’t be a classic. This one was not. Get both men back in with opponents who bring out their more exciting qualities and this will just be one more night that folds into boxing’s past.          

Report Card and Staff Picks 2017: 3-4 

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by marikudo on 03-05-2017

[QUOTE=Drew Bundini Br;17476660]PAC VS THURMAN anyone??[/QUOTE] Let them do it!

Comment by avidbxfan on 03-05-2017

I don't understand the negative outlook on this fight I thought it was very entertaining had me off the edge of my seat. These two gentleman have tremendous power Danny and his deadly hook you have to be anxious with…

Comment by bronx7 on 03-05-2017

And thurmans corner kept saying keep doing what you are doing giving away the late rounds instead of saying keep Boxing but land more when he's turned more combos

Comment by bronx7 on 03-05-2017

Angel gave horrible advice you were winning you can't lose with him running that's the advice he gives in the late rounds instead of your being outboxed go for ko and Angel said boxing is the punch business not run…

Comment by IRONCHINHAGLER on 03-05-2017

Good win for Thurman in a forgettable fight that underwhelmed considering the hype and comparison to Hearns-Leonard. Lacked drama and signature Rd.

Top Headlines
Otto Wallin Reacts To Tyson Fury's Win, Talks Cut Ben Davison Reacts To Tyson Fury's Win, Talks Cut Bob Arum Reacts To Fury's Win, Talks Cut, Slams Hearn Andy Ruiz: After That, No Way Does Fury Beat Me With One Hand Tyson Fury's Father Furious, Wants Him To Dump Team Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - CompuBox Punch Stats Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - Official Scorecards Tyson Fury Overcomes Horrible Cut To Decision Otto Wallin Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jaime Munguia Drops Allotey Three Times, Stops Him in Four Emanuel Navarrete Batters, Stops Elorde in Fourth Jose Zepeda Wins Decision, Spoils 140 Debut of Jose Pedraza Jose Pedraza vs. Jose Zepeda - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Carlos Cuadras Edges Cardenas By Majority Decision Fury-Wallin - LIVE Results From Las Vegas Munguia vs. Allotey - LIVE Results From Los Angeles Ben Davison: Fury-Wallin Won't Be A Quick Blowout Warren: We Got Wilder For Fury - Hearn Was Unable For Joshua Fury Eager To Find Out if He's Better Than He Was in 2015 Sunny Edwards Boxes Past Guarneros Over Ten Rounds Parker's Trainer: Otto Wallin is a Safe Fight For Tyson Fury Promoter: Fury Obviously Overlooking Wallin; Feels It'll Be Easy Tyson Fury-Otto Wallin: Stats and Stakes Gamache: Fury Has Holes That Haven't Been Exploited Salita: Come Sunday, Wallin Will Be Biggest Name In Sports Martin Murray Back on November 15 in Liverpool David Allen No Longer On 10/19 Newcastle Card Morales: Not Here To Change Munguia, Just Make Him Even Better Fury: Wladimir Was Over Hill With Me, Prime With Joshua Devin Haney Batters Zaur Abdullaev For WBC Interim Arum: Crawford-Spence Can Be Made With Wilder-Fury Blueprint De La Hoya: Munguia Was Best Option After Canelo To Rep Date Pedraza: Lomachenko Definitely Would Beat Gervonta Davis Daily Bread Mailbag: Canelo-Kovalev, Golovkin, Spence-Lara Amanda Serrano Punishes, Decisions Heather Hardy Michael Hunter Drops, Outworks Sergey Kuzmin Devin Haney: Put Me On A Plane, I'll Fight Ryan Garcia Saturday! Bomac Talks Crawford-Kavaliaskas, Spence, More Crawford Talks Kavaliaskas, Spence-Porter, Wilder-Fury Teddy Atlas on Spence-Crawford, Fury, Dirrell-Benavidez
Latest Forum Threads