Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Judging The Judges: Santamaria-Fox Scorecard Analysis

Lucas Santamaria and Mykal Fox delivered a terrific fight for home viewers, with their performances far exceeding that of the three judges assigned to their bout.

A hard-fought battle between aspiring welterweights saw Santamaria claim a 10-round unanimous decision win Saturday evening at Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles. The FS1-televised main event played well with home viewers, who witnessed a close fight with the possibility of an opening round knockdown providing the margin of victory for Santamaria.

Instead it became the start of what was somehow viewed as a wide win.


Judge Steve Morrow had it the closest of the bunch, scoring the contest 96-93. Dr. Lou Moret was one round wider at 97-90, while Rudy Barragan’s tally of 99-90 was flat out disrespectful to what took place in the ring.

Santamaria won eight rounds (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10) on at least two of the three scorecards, five of which he swept. Fox swept just one round (8), while winning round nine on two cards.

The opening round was a given for Santamaria, who floored Fox (22-2, 15KOs) for the first time in his career courtesy of a left hook. From there it became a struggle for the ringside officials, all of whom hail from California. Interestingly, they agreed on six of the 10 rounds scored—five of which (rounds 1, 3, 4, 6, 7) were awarded to Santamaria while Fox pulled a clean sweep in round eight.

Judges Barragan and Moret were in sync on eight of the 10 rounds scored, which explains why their cards were a mess. Santamaria—a 22-year old prospect from Garden Grove, California—claimed rounds one through seven on both cards, while both judges had Fox winning round eight.

The 75-year old Moret—a former veteran referee before sticking strictly with judging—had Fox winning the final three rounds on his scorecard. Round eight was the only round awarded to Fox on the card of Barragan.

Judge Morrow’s card was the closest to being in line with home viewers. The 20-year ring official from Hollister, California was the lone judge to award Fox rounds two and five, though taking the fight off of the table for the Hyattsville, Maryland welterweight by round seven, at which point he had Santamaria ahead by four points with just three rounds to go.

Morrow agreed with the other two officials on seven rounds apiece. Morrow and Barragan were in sync for the six aforementioned common rounds, along with both awarding Santamaria the 10th and final round. Moret and Morrow both scored round nine for Fox, while Barragan saw Santamaria taking the frame.

The same officiating team all worked the opening televised bout of the evening, in which Dave Morrell Jr. outpointed Lennox Allen over 12 rounds in an interim title fight which aired live on Fox prime. Morrell won the super middleweight contest by scores of 118-110 (Morrow), 119-109 (Barragan) and 120-108 (Moret), with the shutout bid from Moret somewhat of an eye-opener—though paling in comparison to what took place in the FS1 headliner.

Jake Donovan is a senior writer for Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Al Broker on 08-09-2020

One judge had it for Santamaría all rounds innit? I should watch this fight. I did see highlights on Instagram. I think PBC’s wallpaper of fake blurred people affected the scorecards. Ghetto ass production.

Top Headlines
UK Boxing: Fans Dealt Blow, Crowds Not Returning Any Time Soon Nery: Would Really Love To Hold World Titles In Two Divisions At Same Time Josh Taylor: Whether Ramirez Fight Is In Scotland Or America, I'm Not Fussed Rosario: It Has Been Easier For Me To Train During Pandemic, No Distractions Charlo Twins Vow Same In-Ring Energy Even Without Fans In Attendance Panama Lewis, Requiem For a Cheater Maxi Hughes Aims To Continue Big Run in Viktor Kotochigov Fight Yildirim's Promoter Hopes Canelo Alvarez Deal Gets Done Reynoso Confident Andy Ruiz Can Accomplish Even More in Career Niall Kennedy Vows To Shut The Mouth of Alen Babic Daniel Roman: I Gotta Look Good, Send a Message I'm Still The Champ Jermall Charlo: My Toughest Fight Was Korobov On Date Jermell Got Robbed Of His Title Josh Taylor Admits That He Hasn't Secured Recognition He Deserves Alejandro Davila Very Motivated To Shock Serhii Bohachuck Shannon Briggs: Jones Having Second Thoughts? Tag Me In - I'll Fight Tyson! Villa Promoter: Ruben Will Rise To Occasion, Beat Emanuel Navarrete Jermell Charlo: Me & Jermall Will Leave Legacy Like Klitschko Brothers Chocolatito Will Head To Mexico To Finish Camp For Gonzalez Fight Euro News: Serrano-Mahfoud?, Faust, Olsen, Ziani, Much More Derevyanchenko Vows To Apply Pressure Early, Start Faster on Charlo Chris Kongo Confident That He Would Knock Conor Benn Out Roy Jones Jr. Putting in Work For Mike Tyson Clash Ricards Bolotniks Wants a 'Real Fight, Real War' With Hosea Burton Lomachenko To Lopez: If You Say Something - You Need To Prove It in The Ring! Josh Taylor: Not Often You Get To Fight For All The Belts, The Fight I Want Next Lubin: Gausha Was Badly Hurt; Could've Stopped Him If I Had 1 More Minute Spence on Charlo-Rosario: Jermell is Going To Try To Dominate, Knock This Dude Out Muhammad Ali Comparisons Are "Inappropriate" Says Khabib Nurmagomedov Nakathila's Promoter Open To Stevenson Fight For WBO Belt if Herring Vacated 2020 USA Boxing National Championships: Shreveport to Host Fury Dares Joshua: If I'm Old and Need To Retire - Come and Retire Me! Canelo vs. Yildirim WBC Purse Bid Postponed To October 6 Murat Gassiev's Return To Be Announced in Coming Weeks Jaron Ennis Boots In The Door Of Welterweight Title Contention Fury To Joshua: Vacate WBO Title, Forget Usyk, Fight Me in 2021 Sylvester Stallone on Tyson vs. Jones: It's Matching a 22 Against a 45 Dorticos Vows To Return To Miami With Muhammad Ali Trophy Lubin: Bouncing Back From KO Loss To Charlo Tells You A Lot About Me Rene Alvarado Training in Las Vegas For First Defense Nyambayar Edges Cobia Breedy in WBC Eliminator
Latest Forum Threads