Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Judging The Judges: George-Escudero II Scorecard Analysis

The opening bout of Showtime’s first live boxing event in 141 days managed to deliver a leading candidate for 2020 Knockout of the Year.

Unfortunately, it also produced one of the worst official scorecards in a year filled with questionable judging.

Saturday’s edition of Showtime Championship Boxing featured two rematches, including the first leg of a televised tripleheader. Joe George (11-0, 7KOs) scored a dramatic, come-from-behind 9th round knockout of Marcos Escudero in their light heavyweight sequel live from Mohegan Sun Casino in Uncasville, Connecticut.

george-escudero-fight (13)

George was trailing in the eyes of two of the three judges through eight rounds, with judges Don Trella and Steve Weisfeld scoring the contest 79-73 and 77-75, respectively, in favor of Escudero at the time of the stoppage. Judge Tom Carusone was watching a different fight altogether, as the locally based official had George ahead 79-73 by the time a left uppercut crashed home on Escudero’s chin to end the fight 0:30 into round nine.

The two-point margin between the scorecards of Trella and Weisfeld were in line with how they both viewed the contest, agreeing on six of the eight scored rounds. Both officials had Escudero claiming rounds 4-7, while awarding George round eight—one of just two rounds where all three judges were in agreement.

Trella—an 18-year ring official from Suffield, Connecticuit—had Escoduero sweeping rounds 1-7, the lone judge to have scored the first two rounds for the 27-year old Argentinean prospect.

Weisfeld—a 29-year judge from River Vale, New Jersey and universally hailed as one of the best in the sport—had George taking rounds one and two, then not awarding the Houston native another frame until round eight.

Carusone apparently showed more ring rust than either of the two in-ring participants who hadn’t fought since their first bout last November. Carusone worked a fight for the first time since last December, though his scoring performance won’t earn him any favors in the near future. The 11-year ringside scorer from Connecticut had George winning all but round four—the lone frame in which Escudero swept on all three cards and the only other round besides eight (George) scored in the same direction.

Controversial scoring was a point of contention in the first fight, in which Houston’s George claimed a 10-round split decision last November, which aired as part of Showtime’s ShoBox series live from WinnaVegas Casino in Sloan, Iowa.

The dispute warranted an immediate rematch, which was originally due to take place as part of a Showtime Championship Boxing (SCB) tripleheader from Park MGM in Las Vegas. The event was shut down due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, with Saturday’s card marking the first boxing card since March 13, and the first SCB-branded event since February 8.

Escudero seemed to be in control far more in the rematch, as George was inactive for lengthy stretches in every round. The more substantive blows were landed by the unbeaten Houston native on the occasions he let his hands go, never more evident than the final left uppercut which put Escudero flat on his back and out for the night.

The knockout removed any controversy from the final outcome, though a fate that could not escape Tom Carusone once the scorecards to that point were officially submitted to the commission.

Jake Donovan is a senior writer for Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by BlackR0bbb on 08-03-2020

I had George trailing 7-1 after eight rounds. He wasn't letting his hands go. He landed the sharper blows when he threw punches, but he often laid against the ropes and blocked punches. But he was seldom active. He needed…

Comment by Coachcody on 08-03-2020

Terrible scorecard by the one judge.....I actually thought the referee was going to stop the fight if George didn't start throwing more punches.....Nevertheless, it was a great victory for George.

Comment by Calibaloc on 08-03-2020

George was setting him up the whole fight. Every time George hit Escudero, Escudero reacted poorly. Just like in the first fight. Alot of Escudero punches were landing on Goerge's arms.

Comment by Get em up on 08-03-2020

George got his ass handed to hi m.j pretty much the entire fight. I watched it twice and cant imagine how anybody had him winning.

Top Headlines
Sources: Canelo, Golden Boy, DAZN Meet in Effort To Work Through Impasse Memo Heredia Impressed With Lobo Torres, Will Make TMT Debut in November Pedraza: If Not A Title Shot Next, I Respectfully Request A Rematch With Zepeda Charlo Doubleheader: Top Fighters, Top Trainers Make Their Picks Briedis, Dorticos - Face-Off at Final Press Conference Lubin's Coach: We Are Ready To Fight The Charlo-Rosario Winner Next Matthysse Jr. Makes Pro Debut on Oct 24 in Sao Paulo, Brazil Dorticos: I Came Back To WBSS To Win It All, No Matter Who Or Where I Had To Fight Aaron Alameda: You'll Really See What I’m Made Of Against Luis Nery Roman: I Want A Rematch With Akhmadaliev; I Want Those Titles Back Derevyanchenko Promises To Be More Aggressive And Push Jermall Charlo Ellerbe: Charlos Will Begin Great PPV Run Like Mayweather - They Talk Sh-t But Back It Up! Josh Taylor Focused: It Only Takes One Punch in Boxing Dave Coldwell Has High Hopes For Lerrone Richards Haye Explains Why Chisora Will Down Usyk in Huge Shocker Povetkin Promoter: After Whyte Rematch, We Will Pursue Tyson Fury Loeffler: Bohachuk is One of The Most Talked About Rising Stars in Boxing What Next For The World Boxing Super Series? Nestor Bravo Decisions Jose Luis Gallegos Over Ten Rounds Fury Promoter: Wilder Trilogy Will Not Be Held Behind Closed Doors Vic Pasillas Takes Out Ranfis Encarnacion in Six Rounds PBC on FS1 LIVE Results: Maidel Sando Decisions Genc Pllana Jack Catterall: Jose Ramirez Must Fight Me or Vacate - I'll Beat Him! Cristofer Rosales Returns To The Ring in Miami, Florida Julio Cesar Chavez Jr, Mario Cazares - Face-Off at Final Presser Sergio Martinez vs. Jussi Koivula Deal Reached For December 5 Charlo-Derevyanchenko, Charlo-Rosario: Judges, Refs For Fights Leonard Ellerbe: Jermall And Jermell Charlo Will Each Win Via KO Charlo, Rosario - Face-Off at Final Press Conference Charlo, Derevyancehnko - Face-Off at Final Press Conference News: Pitters vs. Richards, Thorslund-Radovanvic, Ramla Ali Vic Pasillas: No Pressure To Get KO But I Must Look Impressive In This Fight Jarrell Miller Blames Sexual Performance Drug For Test Failure Beterbiev-Deines To Be Rescheduled For Dec. 11 in Moscow, Without Vlasov-Salamov Vasiliy Lomachenko vs. Teofimo Lopez - Undercard Information Josh Taylor On Khongsong: I'm Not Gonna Start Underestimating People Now Kevin Torres, Mark DeLuca Win Bouts in Tijuana, Mexico Josh Taylor, Apinun Khongsong - Face-Off at Final Presser Bob Arum: Ramirez-Taylor Won't Happen Until 2021, When Fans Can Attend Nery: After I Beat Alameda, I Would Like To Fight Brandon Figueroa Next
Latest Forum Threads