Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Judges Had Lomachenko-Walters Right Through 7 Rounds, But…

By Keith Idec

LAS VEGAS – The scorecards submitted Saturday night by all three judges reflected Vasyl Lomachenko’s dominance against Nicholas Walters.

Adalaide Byrd and Glenn Trowbridge had Lomachenko in front by the same score, 69-64, when Walters told referee Tony Weeks he didn’t want to continue in what was becoming a completely lopsided fight it appeared Walters couldn’t win. Burt Clements (70-63) scored each of the first seven rounds for Lomachenko, who is rapidly establishing himself as one of the best boxers, pound-for-pound, in the world.

Those three scorecards wouldn’t be noteworthy had it not been for what occurred before Lomachenko (7-1, 5 KOs) and Jamaica’s Walters (26-1-1, 21 KOs) entered the ring Saturday night at The Chelsea, a sold-out, 2,000-seat arena inside The Cosmopolitan.

LOMACHENKO_VS_WALTERS_VASYL_CONNECTS (720x506)_1

Clements and Trowbridge both scored Andre Ward a 114-113 victor over Sergey Kovalev the previous Saturday night at T-Mobile Arena. Those scores, though reasonable based on the very competitive nature of the Ward-Kovalev light heavyweight title fight, caused great debate because many fight fans and numerous members of the boxing media scored that 12-round fight for Russia’s Kovalev (30-1-1, 26 KOs).

Kovalev dropped Ward (31-0, 15 KOs) in the second round, but Ward was resilient and rallied in the second half of their 12-round fight for the IBF, WBA and WBO titles.

Clements and Trowbridge had already been assigned by the Nevada State Athletic Commission to score Lomachenko-Walters before the Kovalev-Ward fight took place. Byrd, however, worked Lomachenko-Walters despite promoter Top Rank’s documented objection to the NSAC assigning her to it.

Carl Moretti, Top Rank’s vice president of boxing operations, voiced the company’s displeasure with Byrd working Lomachenko-Walters in this BoxingScene.com exclusive: https://www.boxingscene.com/another-judging-controversy-brewing-lomachenko-walters--111029

Byrd scored Walters the winner of the sixth round, a three-minute period Lomachenko seemingly won. Trowbridge, who scored only the first round for Walters, and Clements scored the sixth round for Lomachenko, who retained his WBO world super featherweight title.

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for BoxingScene.com. He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Raonic on 11-28-2016

[QUOTE=uniquehump;17236849]That may be a good idea, but it can be confusing. And that would mean that the 4th judge wouldn't really be a judge. It would just be a system put in place to ensure that the majority rules, in…

Comment by bojangles1987 on 11-28-2016

Of course people are going to b*tch when all three judges had it a wipeout for Lomachenko. Come on, they were all watching and judging the same domination we were.

Comment by Lou Cipher on 11-28-2016

[QUOTE=aboutfkntime;17237072]turns out [/QUOTE] Peter gazer

Comment by aboutfkntime on 11-28-2016

[QUOTE=Lou Cipher;17236949][B]Turns out[/B] all three judges had Walters ahead by one point. They all had heard erroneously that Walters was promoted by ROC (Robber Of Champions) Nation and they already had their bags packed for a free Hawaaiin vacation and…

Comment by Lou Cipher on 11-28-2016

Turns out all three judges had Walters ahead by one point. They all had heard erroneously that Walters was promoted by ROC (Robber Of Champions) Nation and they already had their bags packed for a free Hawaaiin vacation and had…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (21)
Top Headlines Keith Thurman vs. Josesito Lopez - Undercard Information News: Ceylan, Otha Jones, Kem Ljungquist, Alejandro Jimenez Ray Beltran-Hiroki Okada Announced For Ramirez-Zepeda Card Wilder-Fury Rematch: Purse Bid Set For February 5, 60-40 Split Boxeo Telemundo Returns on February 22 In Kissimmee Daniel Dubois, Nicola Adams Returns Confirmed By Warren Pablo Cesar Cano To Impose Will on Aging Jorge Linares Jarrell Miller Tabs Joshua as 'Turd' - Gives High Praise To Hearn Arum: Haymon Only Promoter Who Won't Work With Others Zerafa Warns Jeff Horn: I'm No Faded Old Man Like Mundine Amanda Serrano: Things Much Better Now For Female Boxers Nathan Gorman Aims For Spectacular KO on February 23 Photos: Manny Pacquiao Continues To Grind in Las Vegas Amir Khan: Hearn is Pissed Off, But I Control My Own Destiny Jarrell Miller Will No Longer Appear on Jan. 18 DAZN Show Kambosos Details Lessons Learned as Pacquiao Sparring Partner Crawford: I'm Better Than Anyone Amir Khan Has Ever Faced Photos: Andrade, Algieri Visit South Bronx Middle School Photos: Badou Jack, Browne, Warren - Las Vegas Grand Arrivals Photos: Manny Pacquiao, Adrien Broner - Las Vegas Grand Arrivals Arum: Crawford is Best Welterweight Since Sugar Ray Leonard Amir Khan To Return To Trainer Virgil Hunter For Crawford Fight Andrade 'Don’t Wanna Hear' Saunders’ Excuses For Akavov Fight Vergil Ortiz could fight for 140-pound title in 2019, Says Gomez Espinoza: Mayweather 'Up In the Air' About Pacquiao Rematch Plant-Uzcategui PBC on FS1 Card Peaks at 986,000 Viewers Dmitry Bivol Makes Promotional Pact With Eddie Hearn Official Photos: Adrien Broner Putting in Work in Las Vegas Dmitry Bivol-Joe Smith To Land on DAZN on March 9, Site TBD Photos: Terence Crawford, Amir Khan - Face To Face in London Derevyanchenko-Culcay Title Eliminator: DIBella Outbids AGON Joe Smith Jr. Finally Moves On From Artur Beterbiev Plant: It Was Destiny To Win My First Title in the City of Angels Mares: Why Isn't Leo Santa Cruz Fighting Gary Russell Next? Tony Harrison: I'll Beat Jermell Charlo 'Even Easier' in Rematch Terence Crawford-Amir Khan Officially Set for April 20 ESPN PPV Caleb Plant-Jose Uzcategui: Afterthoughts Photos: Ted Cheeseman, Sergio Garcia - Face To Face at Presser Amanda Serrano Won't Stop, May Go For Belt in Eight Division Trainer: Chisora Will Repair, He's Force To Be Reckoned With
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement