Herrera-Benavidez: BoxingScene Staff Predictions

By Jake Donovan

Top Rank and Golden Boy Promotions play nice for the second time in just over a month. Of course, the moment comes on a night where both companies are promoting shows in direct conflict with one another mere minutes apart in Las Vegas.

As it pertains to this show, a co-promotion is in store for the opening leg of an HBO-televised tripleheader, as Mauricio Herrera (Golden Boy) faces unbeaten Jose Benavidez Jr. (Top Rank). The 140 lb. title fight takes place at The Cosmopolitan in Las Vegas, in supporting capacity to a show topped by a welterweight clash between Timothy Bradley and Diego Chaves.

Herrera (21-4, 7KOs) has been on both ends of debatable decisions in his seven years as a pro fighter. The battle tested veteran from Riverside, Calif. was on the wrong end of a questionable call versus Mike Anchondo in his first loss in 2009, but was in the judges’ good graces in becoming the first to defeat Ruslan Provodnikov in their hotly contested Jan. ’11 clash on ESPN2.

The most egregious decision in his career came in March, when many felt Herrera did enough to unseat World lineal 140 lb. king Danny Garcia in Puerto Rico. The judges felt otherwise, handing Herrera his third loss in the span of five fights, though he bounced back strong to outpoint Johan Perez in their interim title fight this past July.

Benavidez (21-0, 15KOs) was a highly touted amateur when Top Rank signed him as a 17-year old prior to his pro debut in Jan. ’10. Approaching his fifth full year in the pro ranks, the Phoenix, Ariz. native is believed by his handlers to be ready for prime time.

The showdown versus Herrera represents a massive leap in competition for Benavidez, who has been heavily favored in each of his 21 bouts to date.

Saturday’s affair is anything but a walkover for either fighter, but who will ultimately prevail?

Read on to see how the staff at believes Saturday’s super lightweight action goes down in Las Vegas.
Ryan Burton (Benavidez SD): I expect a close fight but youth will be served as the 6' tall Benavidez gets the nod on 2 of the 3 cards.

Jake Donovan (Benavidez SD): “Most people picking against Benavidez are under the belief that this fight is too much, too soon for the former amateur standout. That could very well be the case, but my gut tells me he boxes just well enough to squeak out a close and highly disputed decision in his first true step-up fight against a fighter who’s no stranger to getting hosed by the judges.”

Steve Kim (Herrera Dec.): I think Herrera is too skilled and seasoned, he wins a decision

John MacDonald (Herrera UD): I feel this fight has come too soon for Benavidez. Herrera's high work rate, accurate jab and experience should be too much for the talented but green Benavidez.

Cliff Rold (Herrera Dec.): This is a genuine toss up.  Herrera has had a good year.  It should end well.

Reynaldo Sanchez (Herrera UD): In my opinion Garcia has a bad night versus Herrera. Benavidez he hasn’t the same opponent’s level in the paper to put in peril Herrera

Alexey Sukachev (Herrera UD): I've heard much of Benavidez somewhere in 2010-2011 but than he left out my memory. Was he fighting anyone with a pulse? I remeber seeing him against a limited fighter (maybe Pavel Miranda), when he was cracked badly and did his best to survive till the final bell. Is he the same kid? I think he is way too inexperienced against suched a gritty and skillful master as Herrera, who have seen it all. Vast UD for Herrera - and maybe with a couple of knockdowns.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by knockoutkid on 12-13-2014

i rekon benevidez although i seen hardly nothing of him, herreras more rugged journeyman and its a toprank card.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (1)
Top Headlines Wilder-Fury Rematch Could Land on April 27 or May, Says Warren Kell Book Looks at Jeff Horn, Jessie Vargas, Smith as Options Marcus Browne Dares Teddy Atlas: Bring Me Oleksandr Gvozdyk! Pacquiao Open To Rematch, Mayweather Remains Noncommital Photos: Manny Pacquiao Dominates Broner - MONSTER Gallery Photos: Marcus Browne Decisions a Bloody Badou Jack Photos: Nordine Oubaali Beats Rau'shee Warren, Wins WBC Belt Manny Pacquiao vs. Adrien Broner - CompuBox Punch Stats Pacquiao: I Proved it Again - The Pacquiao Journey Will Continue Broner: Everybody Knows I Beat Pacquiao; I Controlled Fight! Manny Pacquiao Rocks, Dominates Adrien Broner For Decision Manny Pacquiao vs. Adrien Broner - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Marcus Browne Beats Bloody Badou Jack in WBC Eliminator Badou Jack vs. Marcus Browne - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Nordine Oubaali Decisions Rau'shee Warren, Wins WBC Title Hugo Ruiz Drops, Decisions Alberto Guevara To Win Kambosos, Pacquiao Sparring Partner, Easily Out-Boxes Perez Badou Jack: Marcus Browne Definitely Lost To 'Hot Rod' Kalajdzic Pacquiao vs. Broner - LIVE Results From Las Vegas Broner Coach: If Manny is Aggressive, He'll Get KO'd The F*** Out Thorslund Retains: Sanchez KO's Ceylan, Khattab Wins Pacquiao vs. Broner - CompuBox Historical Review Ellerbe: This is must win fight for both Pacquiao and Broner Manny Pacquiao-Adrien Broner: Stats & Stakes Mike Lee Eyes Jack-Browne Winner; Shot At Beterbiev's Title Lolenga Mock's Long Career Likely Over, Loses Decision To Veron Ellerbe Compares Mayweather's First PPV To Broner's Meng, Rossing, Mafoud, Poulsen Win Bouts in Nykobing Falster Broner Wants To Give Hope To Young Kids, So They Follow Dreams Photos: Oscar Rivas Crushes Bryant Jennings in Final Round Jack: Talkative Browne Insecure, Trying To Build His Confidence Daily Bread Mailbag: Crawford-Khan, Pacquiao, Maidana, More Pacquiao: Broner, Trainer Think I'm Old, But They're Wrong! Photos: Demetrius Andrade Dominates, Stops Artur Akavov Photos: Pablo Cesar Cano Demolishes Jorge Linares in One Pacquiao-Broner: Aging Legend vs. Elite Gatekeeper Linares: Cano Surprised Me, I Felt Better at 135 - Hard To Make It Demetrius Andrade: Put Golovkin in Front of Me - I'll Destroy Him! Why Most of Us Still Root For Manny Pacquiao Lomachenko vs. Crolla Ordered To Purse Bid on February 4

Latest Active Forum Threads