Hall of Fame: Rafael Marquez, Yes; Ricky Hatton, No


By Michael Rosenthal

The 2019 class of International Boxing Hall of Fame candidates is not inspiring.

None of the 32 “modern” fighters on the ballot recently sent to voters is a slam dunk, at least not on the scale of Erik Morales last year and Evander Holyfield and Marco Antonio Barrera the year before that.

There are many exceptional fighters on the list, just none that stands out as a “yes” at first glance.

I look for defining victories on the records of the candidates as one indication that he is worthy of serious consideration and there aren’t many among these fighters, although there certainly are some.

Here are 10 names that stand out to me and my immediate thoughts on their hall of fame credentials, or lack thereof.

DONALD CURRY (34-6, 25 KOs)

Curry had two careers in one, the first one spectacular and the second mediocre. The talented Texan seemed to have it all in Career I, winning his first 25 fights (including two victories over Marlon Starling and one over Milton McCrory) to climb to the top of the pound-for-pound list and to the precipice of greatness. Then, in 1986, he was stopped by huge underdog Lloyd Honeyghan and was never again a dominating fighter. He went 9-6 in his last 15 fights and was only 9-5 in title fights when he was finished. He’s a tough sell for voters.

RICKY HATTON (45-3, 32 KOs)

I don’t see it. I think Hatton was a very good fighter, as he demonstrated by stopping Kostya Tszyu, but not Hall worthy. He deserves credit for the victory over Tszyu but Tszyu was approaching 36 years old and never fought again, which indicates he was not at his best. Who else was there? No other victory really grabs your attention. And Hatton was blown out in his two highest-profile fights, a 10th-round TKO against Floyd Mayweather Jr. and a one-punch knockout against Manny Pacquiao. Good fighter. Not a Hall of Famer.


I’m biased when it comes to the late Hernandez because he was one of my favorite people in the sport. He was also a hell of a boxer. His run at 130 pounds stands out, as he won a major title in 1991 and successfully defended eight times before challenging Oscar De La Hoya at 135. Hernandez entered the ring with a broken nose and quit after six rounds. He later won another junior lightweight title in his most memorable victory, a split decision over the great Azumah Nelson. Hernandez isn’t an obvious Hall of Famer but he deserves consideration.



Jackson is an intriguing candidate because of his legendary punching power but he falls short here. He won three major titles in two divisions and was one of the biggest punchers of his generation but he generally lost his biggest fights. He stopped Terry Norris and In Chul Baek (to win his first title) but was knocked out himself by Mike McCallum, Gerald McClellan (twice) and three others. Jackson can take pleasure in the knowledge that he was a fan favorite, which is admirable, but he probably isn’t destined to get a plaque in Canastota, New York.


I think Marquez will be among the three who will be inducted in June. He split four fights with Israel Vazquez in their epic series, although the fourth installment (which Marquez won) was more like an old-timers dustup than a legitimate fight. He twice beat Hall of Famer Mark Johnson and outpointed then-unbeaten Tim Austin. And he had a long stretch as a bantamweight titleholder, seven defenses over three-plus years. True warrior at a high level of skill, defining victories, a long reign as champion. Solid credentials.


Michalczewski is often cited as a fighter avoided by a prime Roy Jones Jr., as if he was in Jones’ class. He wasn’t. That said, Michalczewski was a very good fighter. He defended his 175-pound title a remarkable 23 times and also wore a belt at cruiserweight. And he beat a number of big-name opponents, including Montell Griffin, Graciano Rocchigiani and Virgil Hill. The knock on him is that he fought only twice outside his boxing base of Germany, each time in inconsequential fights. That’s too convenient to be ignored when we assess Michalczewski.

MICHAEL MOORER (52-4-1, 40 KOs)

One could argue that Moorer deserves induction. The lefty was a terror at 175 pounds, finishing his light heavyweight career by stopping all 22 of his opponents. That run included 10 title fights. The problem was mediocre opposition at that weight. Moorer moved up to heavyweight in 1991 and won his first 13 fights, including the biggest victory of his career – a majority decision over Evander Holyfield to become champion. Moorer was stopped by George Foreman in his next fight but went on to win another title. Borderline Hall of Famer.

SVEN OTTKE (34-0, 6 KOs)

Ottke might seem like an obvious Hall of Famer at first glance but take a closer look. The native of Berlin retired undefeated and reigned as a titleholder for seven years but only once campaigned outside the safe confines of Germany, fighting early in his career in neighboring Austria. He probably benefitted from friendly judges in a number of fights that could’ve gone the other way. He deserves some credit for outpointing Charles Brewer (twice), Glen Johnson, Thomas Tate (Twice), Byron Mitchell and Robin Reid but probably not enough to enter the Hall.

MELDRICK TAYLOR (38-8-1, 20 KOs)

I think of what might’ve been when I think of Taylor. Few could match his combination of skills, speed, athleticism and fighting spirit but his willingness to mix it up at all times probably shortened his reign as an elite fighter. He lost his defining victory when he was stopped by Julio Cesar Chavez with two seconds remaining in a fight he was winning. He was never the same after that. Taylor did beat the likes of Buddy McGirt and Aaron Davis and won titles in two divisions but isn’t the Hall of Fame slam dunk his talents suggested he might’ve been.


Vargas might’ve had Hall of Fame ability but didn’t put together the requisite resume. The 1996 Olympian was only 21 when he stopped the rugged Yory Boy Campas to win his first of two major titles, which was soon followed by consecutive victories over Raul Marquez, Winky Wright and Ike Quartey. Vargas was at his best against Quartey, an imposing figure at that time. However, he subsequently suffered brutal knockouts against Felix Trinidad and Oscar De La Hoya, after which he was never as sharp as he had been. He was only 29 when he last fought.

Michael Rosenthal is the most recent winner of the Boxing Writers Association of America’s Nat Fleischer Award for excellence in boxing journalism. He has covered boxing in Los Angeles and beyond for almost three decades.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by b00g13man on 10-15-2018

Hatton >>>>>> Vitali

Comment by vitali1999 on 10-15-2018

[QUOTE=kidbazooka;19188921]Hahahahaha Ottke but not Marquez and Vargas two guys that clearly have better resumes and fights compared to Ottke who no one outside the uk has ever heard of lol[/QUOTE] I'm not from the U.K. and I heard of him.…

Comment by DramaShow on 10-14-2018

[QUOTE=just the facts;19193544]Need flash dummyshow,Cotto isn't in the HOF[/QUOTE] This very site were treating him as a legend and calling him a first baller hall of famer when he retired

Comment by just the facts on 10-14-2018

[QUOTE=DramaShow;19192568]who was cottos best win? how did he got on in his other big fights?[/QUOTE] Need flash dummyshow,Cotto isn't in the HOF

Comment by Boksfan on 10-14-2018

[QUOTE=just the facts;19190483]Thank you! I'm kinda having a bad day and needed a good laugh and you have provided it with your ignorant post.[/QUOTE] Hey nuthugger, suck them German Ottke balls :lol1: every cheating boxer have his own nuthugger like…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (87)
Top Headlines Canelo-Fielding: No Rematch Clause in Contracts, Says Hearn's Television Pick of The Week - October 19 Murata: I'd Like To Fight Canelo - But Without The Mexican Beef! Bradley Skeete: I Ain't Got Time To Be Treading Water! Caoimhin Agyarko Very Pumped For Pro Debut in Brentwood Khan Sees No Reason For Brook To Reject Rehydration Clause Canelo: I'm Not Desperate, Mayweather Rematch is Good For Fans Jason Quigley Overcomes Freddy Hernandez For Decision Win Peter Fury Assures That Hughie is Beyond Ready For Pulev McGuigan Confident of Josh Taylor Beating Everyone in WBSS Felix Alvarado Prepares To Hit Philippines For IBF Title Rumble Middleweight: A Possibly Complicated Sandbox Pacquiao Wants To End Adrien Broner in Seven Rounds or Less Francisco Vargas Would Embrace Direct Crack at Machado Photos: Murata-Brant, Dadashev-DeMarco - Face-Off at Presser Photos: Saul Sanchez, Fernando Saavedra - On Weight To Fight Anthony Yarde vs. Walter Gabriel Sequeira Picked Up By ESPN+ WBC Prez Overjoyed By Canelo-DAZN Deal: Time To Celebrate! Gloferson Ortizo Hopes To Rebound From First Defeat Arum: Linear/Stream Combo Gives ESPN Advantage Over DAZN De La Hoya Unloads on Mayweather: We Don't Hit Women! Photos: Kid Galahad, Toka Kahn Clary - Face To Face at Presser Photos: Rodriguez-Moloney, Dorticos-Masternak - Face To Face Photos: Katie Taylor, Cindy Serrano - Face To Face at Presser Photos: Tevin Farmer, James Tennyson - Face To Face at Presser Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Walter Kautondokwa - Face To Face Mayweather To 'Cheating' Canelo: I Make $300M in 1 Fight, Not 11! Agit Kabayel vs. Otto Wallin is Ordered By The EBU Hearn: Jacobs To Fight Canelo in May If He Beats Derevyanchenko Joseph Parker vs. Alexander Flores Set Down For December 15 Cheeseman: Byfield Does Not Deserve British Title Shot Arum: Crawford-Spence Fight Could Be Made in 3 Hours! Frank Warren: Buglioni Rejected Over 100K For Yarde Fight UK News: Tommy Langford, Savannah Marshall, Sunny Edwards Hughie Fury: After I Take Out Pulev, Fans Will Talk Me & Joshua Golovkin Undecided, Still Choosing a Television Outlet Hearn: Canelo-Fielding Probably Gets DAZN 1 Million Subscribers Arum: Golovkin is Best Middleweight, He Clearly Beat Canelo! Taylor Confident He'll Beat Martin, Then Baranchyk In WBSS Semis Daniel Dubois: I Want To Fight Gorman When Time is Right

Latest Active Forum Threads