Most Controversial Decisions

[iamboxing]

Besides the Ward/Kovalev fight, what other boxing decisions have been controversial? Have any ever been contested and reversed?

[Sadiqkingofko]

Jack/DeGale
Chisora/Whyte
Jack/Bute
Medina/DeGale
Hooker/Perez
McDonnel/Solis
Ruiz/Parker
Cuadras/Gonzalez
Bradley/Pacquio1

[Ray Corso]

Hearns vs Leonard 1989 Tommy won that fight and was given a draw! Bad decision and even though they were past their best it should have been a victory for Tommy and Leonard's second defeat!

Ray

[iamboxing]

Hearns vs Leonard 1989 Tommy won that fight and was given a draw! Bad decision and even though they were past their best it should have been a victory for Tommy and Leonard's second defeat!

Ray

What about Hagler vs Leonard? I thought that could have gone any way

[Ray Corso]

Hagler/Leonard was a close fight and could be judged a win for both.
Leonard/Hearn's 2 was NOT a close fight, Tommy dropped Ray twice and had him hurt a few times. Hearn's got screwed that's all there is to it.
Ray

[Sugar Adam Ali]

My lifetime, the biggest debates

Holmes-spinks 2
Leonard-hearns 2
Leonard-hearns
Chavez-Taylor
Oscar-Tito
Oscar-Shane 2
Floyd-Castillo
Manny-Bradley


Those have been discussed too many times, and always start huge debates

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Hagler/Leonard was a close fight and could be judged a win for both.
Leonard/Hearn's 2 was NOT a close fight, Tommy dropped Ray twice and had him hurt a few times. Hearn's got screwed that's all there is to it.
Ray

Leonard hearns 2, I always thought you can make a case for Leonard winning 7 rds but the 2 knockdowns make it 113-113.

[Elroy The Great]

im positive most on my list were already mentioned

pac - timmy 1
dlh - tito
dlh - ssm
may - jlc 1
hagler - srl
pea - ramirez
pea - jcc
pac - jmm 1

[TBear]

There have been so many...

[BKM-]

Hagler/Leonard was a close fight and could be judged a win for both.
Leonard/Hearn's 2 was NOT a close fight, Tommy dropped Ray twice and had him hurt a few times. Hearn's got screwed that's all there is to it.
Ray

What I remember most from that fight was 2 instances where Leonard was beating Hearns up so bad it could have easily been stopped by the referee.

By some miracle Hearns was able to stay on his feet, but those beatings he took from Leonard were more significant than the knockdowns he scored on Leonard imo and they should have been scored 10-8 rounds, if they weren't.