Rate ali,srr,rjj,tyson,manny,cotto,pbf,mosley,and j.marquez's offense and defense

[vince_carter123]

and dela hoya, in their prime

1-10
10-best

[Zarco]

marquez
offense-9
defense-7

[vince_carter123]

in their prime

[vince_carter123]

i think there are few boxing experts here

[thriller91]

Muhammad Ali:
Off - 10 Def - 9.5

Sugar Ray Robinson:
Off - 10 Def - 9

Roy Jones
Off - 10 Def - 8

Manny
Off - 9 Def - 8

Pretty Boy Floyd
Off - 8 Def - 9.5

Mike Tyson
off - 10 Def - 8.5

[sycomantz]

Muhammad Ali:
Off - 10 Def - 9.5

Sugar Ray Robinson:
Off - 10 Def - 9

Roy Jones
Off - 10 Def - 8

Manny
Off - 9 Def - 8

Pretty Boy Floyd
Off - 8 Def - 9.5

Mike Tyson
off - 10 Def - 8.5

are you kidding. you gave floyd a 9.5 for defense when hes takes he least punishment in the sport. and you gave him a 8 for offense when his connect % is over 45-50% every fight?

manny gets a 8 for defense? dudes defense is a 6-7 at best.

ali a 9.5 for defense?

dude, lay off the crack

[thriller91]

are you kidding. you gave floyd a 9.5 for defense when hes takes he least punishment in the sport. and you gave him a 8 for offense when his connect % is over 45-50% every fight?

manny gets a 8 for defense? dudes defense is a 6-7 at best.

ali a 9.5 for defense?

dude, lay off the crack

HHAHAHA...you know why i gave Pretty Boy a 9.5 because he fights freaking bums....tell me one devestating puncher he has faced?????? and yes i did give Ali a 9.5 for defence you muppet....Ali actually deserves a 10 for taking every shot Foreman dished out...Ali's defence is supreme....so go cry in your little corner now

[sycomantz]

HHAHAHA...you know why i gave Pretty Boy a 9.5 because he fights freaking bums....tell me one devestating puncher he has faced?????? and yes i did give Ali a 9.5 for defence you muppet....Ali actually deserves a 10 for taking every shot Foreman dished out...Ali's defence is supreme....so go cry in your little corner now

hatton, judah, DLH, dumb ass ratings

[5betlight]

Too lazy to do all those ratings, but I know if Ray's offense is a 10 then everyone else's should start at 8...

[Syf]

Muhammad Ali:
Off - 10/10 Def - 10/10

dude wasn't touched in his prime. As for his offense, he was Ali

Sugar Ray Robinson:
Off - 12/10 Def - 8/10

Dude had devastating strikes for his weight. Just unworldly. Def was good, but wasn't extraordinary to me.

Roy Jones
Off - 10/10 Def - 7.5/10

Great offense..No one could stand before him in his prime. Defense was pretty nonexistant even then, he just relied on beating them to the punch, and his athleticism..so..

Manny
Off - 9/10 Def - 7/10

his last three fights he's been utilizing a sort of Tyson'esque defense. But imo, cotto is the proving ground. If he beats Cotto, def goes way up. Same for offense.

Pretty Boy Floyd
Off - 8/10 Def - 10/10

Offense would be higher if he threw more. Defense is superb

Mike Tyson
off - 10.5/10 Def - 8.5/10

Dude was a wrecking machine. Pretty damn good defense in his prime

Cotto
off - 8.75/10 def - 8/10

Prime Cotto, imo, was before Marg. He was wrecking dudes. Solid boxing skills.

Mosley
off- 9/10 def 7.5/10

good hitter..he can be caught and out boxed

JMM
off 8/10 def 8/10

good..but compared to these guys...

DLH
Off 8.5 Def 8


and im done