Frazier would have won
I saw a few of Ron Lyle's fights, against Ali, Jimmy Young (2nd fight) and against George Foreman, and I don't think that he had the right style to deal with Frazier's pressure or left hook. Lyle had stamina problems in the fights of his that I saw. He really didn't fight with a lot of intensity. Instead he often had lapses of energy in the middle of a round, would lay on the ropes or just hang around in the middle of the ring without throwing anything. He was a big puncher, but lacked the aggressiveness of some of the other punchers that I saw from that era, such as Foreman, Shavers, Norton or Quarry.
Lyle tried to outbox Ali, and was doing rather well until Ali caught him with a good shot. However, Ali seemed to be clowning around in that fight, experimenting with different styles. Lyle got outworked by Young, laying on the ropes too much. Lyle's stamina problems cost him the fight with Foreman. Even in the 5th round Lyle hurt Foreman several times, but seemed to suddenly tire right near the end of the fight, backing up to the ropes and allowing Foreman to unload a combination which ended the fight.
Anyway, it's doubtful that a prime Frazier would have had much trouble with Lyle. If Jimmy Young could push him back to the ropes, so could Joe Frazier. Frazier worked hard all the time in the ring, and would have outworked Lyle quite easily, perhaps even stopping him if Lyle had 1 of his characteristic lapses of energy.
I saw a few of Ron Lyle's fights, against Ali, Jimmy Young (2nd fight) and against George Foreman, and I don't think that he had the right style to deal with Frazier's pressure or left hook. Lyle had stamina problems in the fights of his that I saw. He really didn't fight with a lot of intensity. Instead he often had lapses of energy in the middle of a round, would lay on the ropes or just hang around in the middle of the ring without throwing anything. He was a big puncher, but lacked the aggressiveness of some of the other punchers that I saw from that era, such as Foreman, Shavers, Norton or Quarry.
Lyle tried to outbox Ali, and was doing rather well until Ali caught him with a good shot. However, Ali seemed to be clowning around in that fight, experimenting with different styles. Lyle got outworked by Young, laying on the ropes too much. Lyle's stamina problems cost him the fight with Foreman. Even in the 5th round Lyle hurt Foreman several times, but seemed to suddenly tire right near the end of the fight, backing up to the ropes and allowing Foreman to unload a combination which ended the fight.
Anyway, it's doubtful that a prime Frazier would have had much trouble with Lyle. If Jimmy Young could push him back to the ropes, so could Joe Frazier. Frazier worked hard all the time in the ring, and would have outworked Lyle quite easily, perhaps even stopping him if Lyle had 1 of his characteristic lapses of energy.
Comment