Who looked better against Montel Griffin?

[IronDanHamza]

Just curious...

Roy Jones - Ahead on two of the three cards, staggered him, dropped him and got DQ'd in the first one, blasted him out in a round in the second one.

Or James Toney - Lost twice, 6 score cards, not a single one had Toney as the winner.

[OctoberRed]

Hard to says Toney looked better after Jones got a KO in 1. I felt Tony looked lackluster in the two fights. I would have to watch it again, but for some reason I remember feeling that Toney edged the rematch.

[IronDanHamza]

Hard to says Toney looked better after Jones got a KO in 1. I felt Tony looked lackluster in the two fights. I would have to watch it again, but for some reason I remember feeling that Toney edged the rematch.

I had it 1-1 but both were either way.

Same way I had McCallum beating Toney the second time but it was either way.

[IronDanHamza]

But a poster told me that the "consensus" is Toney performed better against Griffin than Roy Jones.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Well obvious that the dude with ko1 looked better.

But I thought Toney beat montel

[phallus]

roy looked better in both fights, but james won the rematch with griffin and got robbed by the judges.

[IronDanHamza]

roy looked better in both fights, but james won the rematch with griffin and got robbed by the judges.

Wasn't robbed.

Close either way fight, both of them.

[IronDanHamza]

Well obvious that the dude with ko1 looked better.

But I thought Toney beat montel

You'd think that would be obvious wouldn't you?

I had it 1-1 but neither were robberies.

[OctoberRed]

roy looked better in both fights, but james won the rematch with griffin and got robbed by the judges.

Then I guess my memory is not shot, because I remember thinking Toney edged out a win.

[billeau2]

But a poster told me that the "consensus" is Toney performed better against Griffin than Roy Jones.

Stop it Dan Montel was a very slick fighter, always liked him. Obviously the Jones fiasco was silly and should not have happened. I don't think either fight was a robbery either. Both could have gone either way, I would have given the second to Toney.