After Broner dismantles and knocks out Maidana he's the #5 P4P

[Bring It On]

He barely beat Paulie and Maidana hasn't done **** at WW.

[Syf]

He barely beat Paulie and Maidana hasn't done **** at WW.

Maidana has put togetherTKO stoppages over Lopez, who broke Ortiz's jaw, and Karass.. who went on to beat Berto. He has a solid run at ww so far. So your statement is erroneous to say the least

[El Angel]

Maidana has put togetherTKO stoppages over Lopez, who broke Ortiz's jaw, and Karass.. who went on to beat Berto. He has a solid run at ww so far. So your statement is erroneous to say the least

That doesn't mean beating him should make top 5 P4P. Their is huge gulf between top 10 WW and top 5 P4P.

[-Kev-]

I wouldn't say Maidana hasn't done anything at 147, but he really hasn't beaten any top welter up there. The only top 10 guy he fought, was Alexander, who come to think of it debuted against Maidana, so not even Alexander was top 10 when Maidana fought him. Which leaves Maidana's 147 resume 2-1 against no top 10 guys.

I don't think Broner beats Maidana the same way Alexander did. Alexander is more skilled, more fast, and more ring savvy, the way he turned Maidana around constantly, and smother his punches.

[shenmue]

Maidana has put togetherTKO stoppages over Lopez, who broke Ortiz's jaw, and Karass.. who went on to beat Berto. He has a solid run at ww so far. So your statement is erroneous to say the least

Karass beat Aydin and Berto which was good enough for Robert Guerrero. Maidana beating Karass is a good win as is the Lopez win .

[PAC-BOY]

If Broner beats Madina...no doubt he will fight winner of Pacquiao/Rios

[PAC-BOY]

Pacquiao/Broner...


Coming Soon.....

[-Kev-]

Pacquiao beats Broner easy.

[OJ Simpson]

How can a guy who ducks fighters and ducked his main nemesis be a pound for pound fighter. Bradley lost two of his last three fights and arguably his last three fights. Ward is the most overrated boxer in the game. He's good don't get me wrong but crazy overrated. Only guy in your list that actually belongs there is Rigo. Mayweather would be in the top 10 if he wasn't a duck.

[-Kev-]

I can only see this on a boxing forum.

Olympic Gold Medalist, Ring Champion of his division, 2011 FOTY, #2 best fighter according to The Ring, Yahoo Sports, Sports Illustrated, ESPN, Boxingscene, an a host of other boxing websites, hasn't lost a fight since he was like 12 years old, by 25 pro fights he already had wins over Kessler, Froch, Bika, Abraham, Miranda, Green.

"He's good"?...Come on.

And how is he overrated? How is e supposed to be rated in your opinion? Under who should he be listed? How many fighters are actually better than him P4P?