Is Timothy Bradley really a top ten P4P boxer?

[The Hammer]

- Two losses to the past-best Pacquiao

- Draw with Chaves

- Gift decision over the limited Provodnikov

We can hear the HBO commentators (especiallly Max Kellerman) heap loving praise upon him every time he fights, but in reality is Bradley really a top ten P4P fighter?

[NEETzsche]

say what you will about the result of the first pacquiao fight, but bradley did fight on fairly even terms with pac for most of the fight. and last night was more of a questionable decision than the one against provodnikov

[Humean]

Bradley is a quality fighter but he has definitely been overvalued by many.

[-PBP-]

Last nights fight has zero impact on his pound for pound status.

[Pretty Boy32]

- Two losses to the past-best Pacquiao

- Draw with Chaves

- Gift decision over the limited Provodnikov

We can hear the HBO commentators (especiallly Max Kellerman) heap loving praise upon him every time he fights, but in reality is Bradley really a top ten P4P fighter?

he beat pacquiao? do you even watch boxing?

[WarMaidana]

It's funny that people will count last night as a draw (which we know wasn't) but then they discredit his "technical" win over Pacquiao. If you don't consider that a win then you can't consider last night a draw then. Either you take what the record says or you dont, no in between

[The Hammer]

he beat pacquiao? do you even watch boxing?

He never beat Pacquiao.

Bradley's first fight with Manny was one of the worst robberies ever.

Pacquiao clearly won the second fight as well, only that time the scoring was fair.

It's funny that people will count last night as a draw (which we know wasn't) but then they discredit his "technical" win over Pacquiao. If you don't consider that a win then you can't consider last night a draw then. Either you take what the record says or you dont, no in between

Last night was a close fight.

Bradley's first fight with Pacquiao wasn't close at all, Manny should have won a wide decision.

[bojangles1987]

Somewhere in the bottom half of the top 10, where he was before. A robbery doesn't make it okay to pretend he sucks now.

[SlySlickSmooth]

I think Floyd & Manny just make these guys look like regular joes. Are any of these young WWs really that good?

Sure they can be competitive with each other, but then when they face the other young WWs instead of the past prime legends we start to doubt our labels on them such as "elite" and "top p4p"

[Beercules]

I don't know.

Last night has rambled my brains. What if Chaves is better than we think? I had him beating Rios.