Imagine you are the Head Coach of a new NFL team

[Rip Chudd]

to me please no hate...... and i will also say i'm a denver bronco fan. John Elway was the best quarterback to ever play the position please no hate just my opinion and no one in this world will sway me to say anything different.

No hate coming from this way. I'd pick Elway as well.

[the mesiah]

give me the man,the myth ,the legend..montana was way more on another level than the other guys, PERFECT in super bowls, beating those teams with HOF qb's easily and just too cool with poise, and precision.this dude was a surgeon on the field not a butcher .don't care about the system,dont care who the coach is HE won those rings.

[SkillspayBills]

Peyton Manning. I honestly can't think of one person that is more valuable to his team than him.

[Jack3d]

Nobody from that list. No Homer, I'd take Aaron Rodgers. I want to win not only now but in the future for a long time. Plus skill wise and from an athletic standpoint, Aaron Rodgers is better than everyone on that list. deadsrs

Manning is a choke artist and he plays in one of the most shallow divisions in the league. They are a given to win the AFC south every year not because Peyton is that good but because that division is that bad.

Brady would be a close second.

[street bully]

Nobody from that list. No Homer, I'd take Aaron Rodgers. I want to win not only now but in the future for a long time. Plus skill wise and from an athletic standpoint, Aaron Rodgers is better than everyone on that list. deadsrs

Manning is a choke artist and he plays in one of the most shallow divisions in the league. They are a given to win the AFC south every year not because Peyton is that good but because that division is that bad.

Brady would be a close second.

man rodgers always gets concussions, he will be done like aikman very soon.

[Addition]

Nobody from that list. No Homer, I'd take Aaron Rodgers. I want to win not only now but in the future for a long time. Plus skill wise and from an athletic standpoint, Aaron Rodgers is better than everyone on that list. deadsrs

Manning is a choke artist and he plays in one of the most shallow divisions in the league. They are a given to win the AFC south every year not because Peyton is that good but because that division is that bad.

Brady would be a close second.

Rodgers was the first name that came to my head.

I unfortunately never got the opportunity to see Elway, Marino or Montana play.

[Jack3d]

man rodgers always gets concussions, he will be done like aikman very soon.

He just needs to learn how to slide when he tucks and runs. And he's already seemed to learn how to do that. Some improvement to his offensive line would help as well.

Seriously though, for how long Aaron Rodgers has been the starting QB, I don't think there has ever been a QB who has developed and improved as fast as he has. He hasn't even peaked yet and he's already won a SB with a beat up football team, he's been the MVP, holds the record for passer rating and he's still getting better.

[street bully]

He just needs to learn how to slide when he tucks and runs. And he's already seemed to learn how to do that. Some improvement to his offensive line would help as well.

Seriously though, for how long Aaron Rodgers has been the starting QB, I don't think there has ever been a QB who has developed and improved as fast as he has. He hasn't even peaked yet and he's already won a SB with a beat up football team, he's been the MVP, holds the record for passer rating and he's still getting better.

Rodgers is definetly a problem, but man he gets concussed a lot. His throwing ability is amazing though, he can find you with an accurate pass anywhere on the field, and he can scramble if need be, which is why he will have a short career from trauma man.

[Jack3d]

give me the man,the myth ,the legend..montana was way more on another level than the other guys, PERFECT in super bowls, beating those teams with HOF qb's easily and just too cool with poise, and precision.this dude was a surgeon on the field not a butcher .don't care about the system,dont care who the coach is HE won those rings.

Oh yeah because he never had that Jerry Rice guy to throw to or anything.

[oside4life]

Rodgers was the first name that came to my head.

I unfortunately never got the opportunity to see Elway, Marino or Montana play.

u should def try to watch some old games of those guys they put up stats where defense could mug the wr. Elway montana and marino were just ridiculusly awesome