James Toney Vs. Shane Carwin

[Gorilla Dogs]

He doesnt need to be a big puncher, he would land at will on someone like Carwin, but Carwin would be stupid to stand with a boxer

hahahahahahahhahah


land at will?


hahaahhahahahahahahahhaha


You think Carwin is gonna stand there at will and chin sticking out letting him hit him?


Carwin is a fkn wrestler dumb ass. And kn ows BJJ. Fk carwin would make Toney look like a complete fkn IDIOT! LMFAO

[them_apples]

LMFAO

You guys are fkn hilarious. Carwin would eat him for lunch **** him up and eat him again




Toney has NO Power compared to Carwin. Carwin walks around over 300 lbs. Toney is a natural Middleweight.



Toney doesnt have mike tyson power here. Carwin probably has a 1200 PSI punch




Man you boxing fan boys are fkn riduculous LMFAO

you'd be surprised..these MMA fighters can't punch worth **** because they have **** technique. Houston Alexander couldn't even hit harder than Ricky Hatton on the punch test. Think of the weight difference. Alexander was supposed to be a big puncher too. these meathead UFC fighters are a joke.

[Gorilla Dogs]

you'd be surprised..these MMA fighters can't punch worth **** because they have **** technique. Houston Alexander couldn't even hit harder than Ricky Hatton on the punch test. Think of the weight difference. Alexander was supposed to be a big puncher too. these meathead UFC fighters are a joke.

becuz mma is all about PUNCHING and nothing else



When Couture beats Toney's ass this song will go on in all your heads

[Left2theliver]

If they fought in MMA, if Carwin was smart he'd know to shoot and take Toney down, which he should be able to easily do. If he tries to stand and bang, Toney's obviousl the much better boxer so there's no surprise who'd win there.

btw, i can't wait for the excuses these guys are gonna pull when Couture mauls Toney. I love how everytime a boxer beats an MMA fighter, no matter how irrelevant that fighter is, it proves that boxing > MMA, but when it's the opposite...it means nothing and boxing is still better ahhahahaha

ignorance is a bliss

[Gorilla Dogs]

If they fought in MMA, if Carwin was smart he'd know to shoot and take Toney down, which he should be able to easily do. If he tries to stand and bang, Toney's obviousl the much better boxer so there's no surprise who'd win there.

btw, i can't wait for the excuses these guys are gonna pull when Couture mauls Toney. I love how everytime a boxer beats an MMA fighter, no matter how irrelevant that fighter is, it proves that boxing > MMA, but when it's the opposite...it means nothing and boxing is still better ahhahahaha

ignorance is a bliss

fk 2 blows from Carwin toney is sitting on his ass



Hell me made a 400 pound lesnar fall down countless times. toney fkn sucks


why the fk ppl think he can win? HE FKN SUCKS!!!

[BigStereotype]

are their fairies in the magical world of MMA fanboy land?

Hahaha, I'm an MMA fanboy? Are you kidding me? Read my posts, I'm all boxing. I'm also realistic. Carwin might be a ****ty wrestler, but he'd take Toney down and ground and pound him to death. Stand up, Toney stands a much better shot on pure skill. But MMA, I don't think so just because of the sheer strength and size difference.

[res]

If they fought in MMA, if Carwin was smart he'd know to shoot and take Toney down, which he should be able to easily do. If he tries to stand and bang, Toney's obviousl the much better boxer so there's no surprise who'd win there.

btw, i can't wait for the excuses these guys are gonna pull when Couture mauls Toney. I love how everytime a boxer beats an MMA fighter, no matter how irrelevant that fighter is, it proves that boxing > MMA, but when it's the opposite...it means nothing and boxing is still better ahhahahaha

ignorance is a bliss

if i'm a shot 50 year old fighter that was last relevant 20 years ago and i beat you, it proves i would have murdered you when i was young. if you beat me, it just proves you can beat an old man.

Why is this concept difficult for you to grasp?

Beating a young Boxer proves that MMA is better (if that kind of thing can be proven for either sport) getting beat by an old Boxer just proves that your sport is sad lol.


It's not the Boxing fans i hear talking the crap. I have heard countless boxing fans say that Randy can win, I'm one of them. In fact i can count on one hand the number of Boxing guys that have said that Toney will definitely win and still have plenty of fingers left over. The MMA fans i hear on the other hand say that Couture will murder Toney easily. It is YOU guys that are taking the absolute stance and it is you that will eat it if your man gets embarrassed.

Excuses? lol You mean like trying to make a 2 TIME UFC CHAMPION who was never koed in his entire career into a nobody because he embarrassed you?

[res]

Hahaha, I'm an MMA fanboy? Are you kidding me? Read my posts, I'm all boxing. I'm also realistic. Carwin might be a ****ty wrestler, but he'd take Toney down and ground and pound him to death. Stand up, Toney stands a much better shot on pure skill. But MMA, I don't think so just because of the sheer strength and size difference.

Oh ok, i thought you were talking about Carwin taking Toney out with blows on their feet.

[kaps]

I'm closing this thread, boxing vs mma debates are useless and redundant....