is Miguel Cotto a Top 15 All-Time Great ?

[Barn]

what in the living fuck of christ kind of question is that

[BOXEO _]

No doubt, (fuk you Trout!)

[285Kid]

The I guess Froch is top 10 then

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Well he lost to Mayweather and Pacquiao- neither of whom should be in the top 15. The Martinez win was tainted by Martinez's knees. His win over Mosley was pretty solid, but Mosley is not top 15 either. Just not enough there to make a case. Honestly cannot see him in top 100 or even 200 really. The four divisions thing holds some weight but those are getting to be many with all the belts and divisions.

[Build That Wall]

Poll is up.....imo he is !!!

YOU SUCK.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

The dude lost his 3 biggest fights, and best wins are past prime shane and serg and undefeated pauli

Cotto is a hall of famer, but not an ATG

[betmen]

[b00g13man]

Yeah.......no

[Ahmed_Ismail]

More like top 30-40, but that might change though after November 21.

[RINGG]

Nobody today is top 15 atg yet.