Who holds the most impressive win over each of these future Hall of Famers?

[Dr Rumack]

Roy Jones Jr
Manny Pacquiao
Bernard Hopkins
Sergio Martinez
Miguel Cotto

[Thraxox]

Sergio Martinez was beaten in his Prime. Manny Pacquiao was beaten 5 years passed his prime and he was beaten by Erik Morales though he was still green at that time. Roy Jones Was beaten was beaten when he was drained and passed his prime. Bernard Hopkins was beaten by prime Roy Jones, but at that point he was still green. Miguel Cotto was beaten in his prime by Margarito.

So It would be between Sergio Martinez and Miguel Cotto.

[BM dnobagaV]

Yeah... Probably Margs over Cotto or Pwill over Sergs.
Maybe Marquez over PAC.
Taylor over Hopkins.
Tarver over Jones.

[daggum]

tarver over roy jones

morales over pac

jones over hopkins(taylor didn't beat hopkins)

margarito over martinez(williams didn't beat martinez and cotto fight was a cripple fight)

margarito over cotto


the real question is who beat eric crumble the most impressively?

[Dr Rumack]

My picks:

Tarver over Jones (2004)
Morales over Pacquiao (2005)
Roy Jones over Hopkins (1993)
Williams over Martinez
Margarito over Cotto

[Dr Rumack]

the real question is who beat eric crumble the most impressively?

His best performance was his debut against Joe Watts III. Watts went the distance against a guy called Todd Nadon, who fought Otis Grant for the Canadian middleweight title in '97. One year before Grant fought Roy Jones Jr for the Light Heavyweight championship. If things had turned out different Eric Crumble might have got that shot.

[daggum]

His best performance was his debut against Joe Watts III. Watts went the distance against a guy called Todd Nadon, who fought Otis Grant for the Canadian middleweight title in '97. One year before Grant fought Roy Jones Jr for the Light Heavyweight championship. If things had turned out different Eric Crumble might have got that shot.

they really matched eric tough from the get-go. what a shame. he had the skills. he had the chin. they just threw him to the wolves.

[Dr Rumack]

they really matched eric tough from the get-go. what a shame. he had the skills. he had the chin. they just threw him to the wolves.

He should have fought a Salka.

[JJRod]

Roy Jones Jr
Manny Pacquiao
Bernard Hopkins
Sergio Martinez
Miguel Cotto

Morales out boxing Pac in their 1st fight.
Roy beating Hopkins with 1 hand.
Margarito KO of Sergio.
PAC destroying Cotto.

It's hard to say for Jones.
That KO loss Tarver was bad, but was he finished by then?

[DeLorean]

1) Marquez KO6 Pacquiao.. the punch that shook up the world.
2) Tarver TKO2 Jones ..any excuses tonight Roy?
3) Margarito TKO11 Cotto.. illegal handwraps? we'll never know
4) Kovalev UD12 Hopkins ..yea B-Hop was old but i picked him to win, he looked good in previous three fights (Shumenov, Murat, Cloud).

nobody has an "impressive" win over Martinez..he was damaged goods vs Cotto.