Top 5 P4P Ranking

[matt0021]

Haven't seen a thread like this, which I'm very surprised about, so I'm probably looking in the wrong place.

Anyways, as the title says... Pound for Pound, top 5.

Here's mine;

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammed Ali
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Roy Jones Jr
5. Rocky Marciano

Post yours

[Canelo and GGG]

1.Harry Greb
2.SRR
3.Ali
4.Henry Armstrong
5.Jack Britton/Archie Moore/Tony Canzoneri

[Sugar Adam Ali]

1 robinson
2 Ali
3 Armstrong
4 ray Leonard
5 ezzard

[matt0021]

1 robinson
2 Ali
3 Armstrong
4 ray Leonard
5 ezzard

I love sr leonard, and think he's a quality and talented boxer, if he didn't have that layoff, due to a detatched retina, he could have been in the list

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I love sr leonard, and think he's a quality and talented boxer, if he didn't have that layoff, due to a detatched retina, he could have been in the list

He has the best wins ever, only Ali or robinson can really compare..

Leonard like Sanchez, had a very short reign but they did more than most guys in a 20 year career

[Canelo and GGG]

He has the best wins ever, only Ali or robinson can really compare..

Leonard like Sanchez, had a very short reign but they did more than most guys in a 20 year career

Greb and Langford have some wins too dont be to fast.

[matt0021]

He has the best wins ever, only Ali or robinson can really compare..

Leonard like Sanchez, had a very short reign but they did more than most guys in a 20 year career

He was in an elite era, and am I right in assuming that when you say "the best wins ever", you're relating to Hagler, Hearns and Duran?

I rate him highly, but he wasn't convincing enough against Hearns in either fight, and for me, a result might says who's won on paper, but the performance can sometimes tell a different story

[DJ Enerate]

Greb
Robinson
Armstrong
Ali
Duran/Pep

[Canelo and GGG]

He was in an elite era, and am I right in assuming that when you say "the best wins ever", you're relating to Hagler, Hearns and Duran?

I rate him highly, but he wasn't convincing enough against Hearns in either fight, and for me, a result might says who's won on paper, but the performance can sometimes tell a different story

Dont forgot Benitez,but i wouldnt call it best wins ever,Greb win over Tunney is more impressive imo.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

He was in an elite era, and am I right in assuming that when you say "the best wins ever", you're relating to Hagler, Hearns and Duran?

I rate him highly, but he wasn't convincing enough against Hearns in either fight, and for me, a result might says who's won on paper, but the performance can sometimes tell a different story

Name a better win a fighter has than beating prime tommy hearns at welter, with a shattered eye socket no less...

Name a fighter that could have beaten that tommy in an easier fashion?