Greater fighter: Calzaghe or Hopkins?

[RubenSonny]

Also do you consider them ATGs?

[Barn]

Hopkins and it shouldn't be debatable.

Calzaghe - Near Great
Hopkins - ATG.

[New England]

hopkins and it's not close for me


he's been at pinnacle of the sport for quite some time now



and yes, both men are absolutely great fighters. at their respective best weights they are a handful for any man who has ever laced up boxing gloves


i don't have a line in the sand for "ATG" status like a lot of the people on the board
that's just not how i look at it. maybe i'm not understanding the way you guys look at it here.

[Vadrigar.]

Hopkins is definitely an ATG and greater than Calzaghe.

Hopkins has wins over Trinidad, Tarver, Wright, Echols, Johnson, Eastman, Pavlik and a draw with Pascal at 45 doesn't hurt either.

[CarlosG815]

lol, this is hilarious. What's with all the zags threads lately? And most of them aren't even from JoeyZags.

[Joeyzagz]

Calzaghe and its not even close.

H2H: Calzaghe
Resume': Calzaghe
Record: Calzaghe
Title Defenses: Calzaghe
Integrity: Calzaghe

Bernard Hopkins made a career out of fighting welterweights and juniormiddles. He is a steroid abuser, cheater and a master of headbutts and cheap tactics, He is also an ex-convict and a racist.

[Joeyzagz]

lol, this is hilarious. What's with all the zags threads lately? And most of them aren't even from JoeyZags.

I cant post in any of them because that coward Toney aka Ironmike blocked me.

[Vadrigar.]

I cant post in any of them because that coward Toney aka Ironmike blocked me.

Why did he block you?

[RubenSonny]

Why did he block you?

Because hes a troll.

[Vadrigar.]

Because hes a troll.

zagz or ironmike?