Who wins: the Pacquiao that beat Margarito vs the Canelo that lost to Mayweather?

[Thuglife Nelo]

I'm not defending him. I'm just making you aware that you are lacking common sense.

Right... like “slow motion...”

[john l]

Nelo would have ended the Margarito Pac fought.

Agree...….

[FredRekk]

Agree...….

Yeah, Canelo would have ended the Margarito fight. He would’ve ended it with a TKO LOSS on his record. The Margarito that Pac fought would be too much for Green Nelo. He would succumb to a barrage of body shots and wilt like a plant.

[thedarkdragon11]

Since you're talking about the guys who showed up that night, I say Pacquiao wins, but not as easy as how he defeated Margarito or how TBE (not The Best Ever) defeated Canelo... The reason is because of the weight difference (check their official and same-day weights during those respective fights; how Margarito hurt Pacquiao), and the speed difference (Prime Pacquiao is faster than Fading Mayweather; Green Canelo is just a bit faster than Margarito)...

[Curtis Harper]

Agree...….

Since you're talking about the guys who showed up that night, I say Pacquiao wins, but not as easy as how he defeated Margarito or how TBE (not The Best Ever) defeated Canelo... The reason is because of the weight difference (check their official and same-day weights during those respective fights; how Margarito hurt Pacquiao), and the speed difference (Prime Pacquiao is faster than Fading Mayweather; Green Canelo is just a bit faster than Margarito)...

Since when is massive amounts of speed needed to beat a plodder like Margarito ????

Margarito's plan throughout his career was to get hit, often, and hope a telegraphed punch lands.

Green Nelo would still have enough boxing smarts to handle a powerless Pac. Pac is fast but can be timed.

[FredRekk]

PAC slaughters Canelo if we’re talking those versions. He actually breaks Canelo’s orbital bone and ends his career before it starts.
That’s why Canelo fought Floyd instead. Pillow jabs wouldn’t even threaten his career.
PAC breaks people’s face and retires his opponents.

[john l]

Since when is massive amounts of speed needed to beat a plodder like Margarito ????

Margarito's plan throughout his career was to get hit, often, and hope a telegraphed punch lands.

Green Nelo would still have enough boxing smarts to handle a powerless Pac. Pac is fast but can be timed.

Yes he could be timed, and Canelo would be the best counter puncher he has faced outside of JMM and of course May. We all know what trouble JMM gave Pac, and MUCH smaller then Canelo.

[FredRekk]

Yes he could be timed, and Canelo would be the best counter puncher he has faced outside of JMM and of course May. We all know what trouble JMM gave Pac, and MUCH smaller then Canelo.

We all know the trouble PAC gave JMM, knocking him down 6 times and all!

PAC slaughters Canelo.
If you disagree,
then YDSAB!!!

[Death_Adder]

Roided up Pac beats a green, weight drained Canelo.

[CodeBreaker]

2010 Pac would obliterate that ginger