Joe Montana is the greatest QB of all time.

[TredKiller]

Enuff of this "peyton is the GOAT" why do people forget about joe:

joe: 3x MVP, 4x SB Champ > Peyton: 4x MVP, 1x SB champ

peytons gr8, but not the greatest.

[MidnightSpecial]

right now....you are right.


Peyton has alot left in the tank though

[TredKiller]

right now....you are right.


Peyton has alot left in the tank though

but i alwayz see posters claiming peyton is better, id love to know how.

[street bully]

Joseph was a beast. Peyton is up there with him. Howeve, both **** on Brady.

[MidnightSpecial]

Peyton in place of Montana would get the same results i truely do believe.


Peyton does it by himself...yes he threw a pic six but he carries that team by himself

[TredKiller]

Joseph was a beast. Peyton is up there with him. Howeve, both **** on Brady.

na, brady is up there with him, he's very clutch, i consider brady and peyton equal. peyton has the better skillz, brady has the better clutch play.

Peyton in place of Montana would get the same results i truely do believe.


Peyton does it by himself...yes he threw a pic six but he carries that team by himself

lol, i strongly disagree.

[MidnightSpecial]

if jerry rice alone was playing with peyton it would be nasty

[boxingfan_123]

but i alwayz see posters claiming peyton is better, id love to know how.

better than montana??? he's got a long way to go!! niners never lost a superbowl!! 5 for 5

[heat27]

Joe Montana>>>>>>>>>>>

[Stab Judah]

Statistically Manning is the greatest ever.

I think they are just about even awareness/ but Montana was better in a clutch.

Manning has better arm power/ Montana was just a little 'very little' more accurate.

Manning needs a pocket/ Montana could run when needed.

Manning calls his own plays/ Montana never did.

Manning has very good teams/ Montana had dream teams.


Manning has a team that he can't seem to beat [Patriots]/ Montana never had that.

Manning has never missed a game/Montana was injury prone but played with different rules during a tougher era.

Pretty close.