Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Mayweather handpicking myth is a lie

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Mayweather handpicking myth is a lie

    Dispelling the myth that Mayweather fought his opponents at the wrong time. The short sightedness of fans is off the charts. One fan says it and All the boxing analyst run with it.

    Genaro hernandez. Only lost to delahoya in the mid 90s before Floyd was factor

    Angel Manfreddy. Was a feared boxer at the time and hadn't lost in years before Floyd. Lasted two or 3 rounds

    Diego corralles. Undefeated and Floyd was considered the underdog.

    Castillo went on to beat corralles and Joel Casamayor afterwards.

    Chop chop. This was his first fight at jr welter and he went toe to toe with him Chop chop had two losses at the time and one was to Judah. This is notable since in this fight Larry Merchant and the HBO cast said Gatti and sharmba Mitchell would beat Floyd and Floyd would not fight him. 2004(watch it on YouTube to hear, it was a good fight anyway)

    Gatti 2005. Only took one fight before this. But By the time this fight started regardless of what was said and forgotten two fights earlier- Floyds now the favorite. Gatti was still on his win streak since Mickey Ward2003. What changed ?

    Sharmba. 2005 Coming of lost to Tzu but still everybody said Floyd Couldn't beat him 3 fights earlier and e had already lost to Tzu back in 2003

    Judah was coming off loss to Carlos baldomir. This was floyds first fight at welter. Hardly cherry picking when moving up in weight

    Baldomir. Had just beaten Judah and Gatti. Had no recent losses. Only the losses he already had prior to beating Judah

    Delahoya. Was partially inactive before Mayweather other than a tuneup. Had been fighting at super welter and middle in his fights before being inactive

    Ricky Hatton. Was undefeated and had beat the feared kosta tzu

    Shane mosely had just beat the breaks of margarito one fight prior to Mayweather.

    Cottos only losses were PAC and margarito at the time

    Guerrero only had one loss and back then people on this forum thought he was the second coming. Had no recent losses.

    Victor Ortiz had beat berto and Nate cambell prior to the fight

    Canelo. Was undefeated. Had beaten cintron and mosely

    *** never fought TZU who was done after Hatton in 2005. Two years after Floyd entered the jr Welters
    *** never fought margarito at 147 who was proven to be a cheater later
    *** never fought Vernon Forrest, Quintana, Paul Williams
    *** mosely, Trinidad, and Vargas were in the welterweights when Floyd fought corralles at featherweight/lightweight

    The only the knock on Floyd is that he didn't fight PAC at the time when PAC destroyed Cotto. But in 2009 Pac was afraid of needles. He faced most of his biggest opponents within 2 fights of people calling them out for him. The real issue is that Floyd had a 13 year prime while most fighters primes only last 5 years.

    People just be rattling off names. Here's a realistic list of top guys in his weight classes -- you can go head and pick out who would have beat Floyd. Or how his resume would of been so much stronger. Lol

    -----------------------------------

    Super featherweight -2001

    Acelino Freitas, Joel Casamayor, Robert Garcia, Steve Forbes, Jong Kwon Baek, Takanori Hatakeyama, Lavka Sim and Jorge Barrios.

    Lightweight 2002-2003
    
Paul Spadafora, Leonard Dorin, Stevie Johnston, Artur Grigorian, Raul Balbi, Juan Lazcano and Javier Jauregui

    Light Welterweight 2004-2005

    Kostya Tszyu, Miguel Cotto, Ricky Hatton, Vivian Harris, Carlos Maussa, and Junior Witter

    Welterweight 2006
    
Antonio Margarito, Kermit Cintron and Luis Collazo

    Light Middleweight 2007

    Cory Spinks, Vernon Forrest, Joachim Alcine, Serhiy Dzinziruk

    Welterweight 2007
    Paul Williams
    ---------------------
    Last edited by whoelsebutjames; 09-03-2017, 11:35 PM.

  • #2
    Lets say that he did handpick or cherrypick......there aren't more than three fighters that can even argue to have a better resume than him in the last 20 years.

    Comment


    • #3
      He ducked a few guys.

      I wouldn't say Mayweather "didn't" cherry pick, but I would say that his cherry picking was overblown.

      Mostly it's just people wishing that he got beat by someone. prime Pacquiao, brick hands Margarito, and people were heavily calling for Floyd to fight Golovkin just to try to see him lose in any way possible

      You can't fight everybody.

      Comment


      • #4
        This is only brought up because people hate floyd he always fought champions ex champions or defended his title

        Comment


        • #5
          As a Floyd fan, I would say there are a few guys he danced around for a bit...and a couple guys he just didn't fight...one of the big ones being Margarito...but his reputation and accomplishments are gone because he was a complete cheat...

          He probably could have fought Cotto or Pacquiao earlier...he still probably would have beaten them regardless, but it is what it is....he fought just about everyone he could have...

          His resume is nearly unmatched...I'd be interested if someone could put together a list of 5 guys he DIDNT fight, that would have had an honest to goodness shot at beating him...and not asinine matchups like someone that was fighting at 154 while Floyd was at 130

          Comment


          • #6
            Lol
            Lol
            Lol
            Lol

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by whoelsebutjames View Post
              Dispelling the myth that Mayweather fought his opponents at the wrong time. The short sightedness of fans is off the charts. One fan says it and All the boxing analyst run with it.

              Genaro hernandez. Only lost to delahoya in the mid 90s before Floyd was factor

              Angel Manfreddy. Was a feared boxer at the time and hadn't lost in years before Floyd. Lasted two or 3 rounds

              Diego corralles. Undefeated and Floyd was considered the underdog.

              Castillo went on to beat corralles and Joel Casamayor afterwards.

              Chop chop. This was his first fight at jr welter and he went toe to toe with him Chop chop had two losses at the time and one was to Judah. This is notable since in this fight Larry Merchant and the HBO cast said Gatti and sharmba Mitchell would beat Floyd and Floyd would not fight him. 2004(watch it on YouTube to hear, it was a good fight anyway)

              Gatti 2005. Only took one fight before this. But By the time this fight started regardless of what was said and forgotten two fights earlier- Floyds now the favorite. Gatti was still on his win streak since Mickey Ward2003. What changed ?

              Sharmba. 2005 Coming of lost to Tzu but still everybody said Floyd Couldn't beat him 3 fights earlier and e had already lost to Tzu back in 2003

              Judah was coming off loss to Carlos baldomir. This was floyds first fight at welter. Hardly cherry picking when moving up in weight

              Baldomir. Had just beaten Judah and Gatti. Had no recent losses. Only the losses he already had prior to beating Judah

              Delahoya. Was partially inactive before Mayweather other than a tuneup. Had been fighting at super welter and middle in his fights before being inactive

              Ricky Hatton. Was undefeated and had beat the feared kosta tzu

              Shane mosely had just beat the breaks of margarito one fight prior to Mayweather.

              Cottos only losses were PAC and margarito at the time

              Guerrero only had one loss and back then people on this forum thought he was the second coming. Had no recent losses.

              Victor Ortiz had beat berto and Nate cambell prior to the fight

              Canelo. Was undefeated. Had beaten cintron and mosely

              *** never fought TZU who was done after Hatton in 2005. Two years after Floyd entered the jr Welters
              *** never fought margarito at 147 who was proven to be a cheater later
              *** never fought Vernon Forrest, Quintana, Paul Williams
              *** mosely, Trinidad, and Vargas were in the welterweights when Floyd fought corralles at featherweight/lightweight

              The only the knock on Floyd is that he didn't fight PAC at the time when PAC destroyed Cotto. People just wanted Floyd to loose. He faced most of his biggest opponents within 2 fights of people calling them out for him. With the exception of Judah and PAC the handpicking myth is a lie. The real issue is that Floyd had a 13 year prime while most fighters primes only last 5 years.
              Don't need to read all that to know what you wrote is BS. Now sit didnt and stfu fanboy.

              Comment


              • #8
                He could have fought Margarito, that's the only one he legit missed. And even that fight he went ahead and fought the champ in Baldonir instead who was on a long won streak. He didn't want to do business with Arum.

                He made a fight with Cotto within weeks after Cotto left Arum. Arum wasn't going to let Cotto fight Mayweather.

                He fought more champions than just about anyone and almost always when they were on impressive runs and/or coming off big wins. It is a myth he hand picked people. He fought too many dangerous guys to nake that claim.

                Comment


                • #9
                  A for trying

                  but argument is just dumb, waste of time, garbage..sorry it is what it is

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Soda_Popinski View Post
                    As a Floyd fan, I would say there are a few guys he danced around for a bit...and a couple guys he just didn't fight...one of the big ones being Margarito...but his reputation and accomplishments are gone because he was a complete cheat...

                    He probably could have fought Cotto or Pacquiao earlier...he still probably would have beaten them regardless, but it is what it is....he fought just about everyone he could have...

                    His resume is nearly unmatched...I'd be interested if someone could put together a list of 5 guys he DIDNT fight, that would have had an honest to goodness shot at beating him...and not asinine matchups like someone that was fighting at 154 while Floyd was at 130
                    Only names that might of beat him... Forrest 147 in 2002, Winky 154 2005 ish, Paul Williams and the concrete version of Margarito in 2007. Hell throw in Bernard @ Middleweigt.

                    Originally posted by boxinghead530 View Post
                    Don't need to read all that to know what you wrote is BS. Now sit didnt and stfu fanboy.
                    I wrote the thread for people who can read and articulate a point of view. Not for a lifeless troll-fan who's so unbusy that he would leave a comment in a thread they didn't bother to read.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP