The current Boxrec top 10 P4P

[teddycanyon]

I think there is a computer ranking system over at boxrec that determines pound for pound lists, so it's pretty flawed.

[mathed]

If Bradley isn't on the list, then the list is trash. I'll pardon not having Martinez on there due to his inactivity but if he beats Cotto convincingly.....he must go back on there because the guy hasn't lost.

[mikinoki]

1-Manny
2-Ward
3-Rigo
4-Wlad
5-Román González
6-GGG
7-Sergio Martinez
8-Bradley
9-jmm
10-Adonis Stevenson

[Loque-san]

BoxRec's Top 10/100 P4P

[HonestBoxingFan]

1-Manny
2-Ward
3-Rigo
4-Wlad
5-Román González
6-GGG
7-Sergio Martinez
8-Bradley
9-jmm
10-Adonis Stevenson

That list is worse than the one on Boxrec. Sorry, mate, but it makes no sense. I certainly could see Pacquiao above Mayweather, Pacquiao's recent victory against Timothy Bradley is better than any victory on Mayweather's record. However, Mayweather is still undefeated and fought some okay opposition, why're you not even placing him on the list at all?

[mikinoki]

That list is worse than the one on Boxrec. Sorry, mate, but it makes no sense. I certainly could see Pacquiao above Mayweather, Pacquiao's recent victory against Timothy Bradley is better than any victory on Mayweather's record. However, Mayweather is still undefeated and fought some okay opposition, why're you not even placing him on the list at all?

Because he ducks.Any real sports ranking system(not me) would not rank him because he doesn't fight his mandatories like Many.Wlad,Ward,Rigo etc do...

[DannYankee]

Boxrec has a stupid weird automatic point system nobody pays attention to it as a serious p4p list.

[mikinoki]

Boxrec has a stupid weird automatic point system nobody pays attention to it as a serious p4p list.

p4p ranking is a fan fantasy ranking not a real ranking

[HanzGruber]

1-Manny
2-Ward
3-Rigo
4-Wlad
5-Román González
6-GGG
7-Sergio Martinez
8-Bradley
9-jmm
10-Adonis Stevenson

[Spray_resistant]

BoxRec vs Ring

1 Mayweather Mayweather
2 Pacquiao Ward
3 Klitschko Klitschko
4 Ward Pacquaio
5 Marquez Bradley
6 Alvarez Marquez
7 Froch Martinez
8 Stevenson Rigondeaux
9 Golovkin Alvarez
10 Maidana Froch

IMO Pacquaio should be above Ward, Froch above Alvarez, Rigon above Stevenson

They are both solid and defensible lists actually if you wanted to make some case for either.