who ranks higher judah or hatton?

[-Lowkey-]

Hatton doesn't have what it takes to make Judah collapse mentally.

He has more than what it takes Judah has proved time and time again he is a mental midget. Hatton in his prime at 140 was relentless Judah wouldn't have time to breath he would be getting smothered and pounded to the body eventually getting stopped.

[D-MiZe]

People really have a skewed vision of Ricky Hatton now.

[FeFist]

He has more than what it takes Judah has proved time and time again he is a mental midget. Hatton in his prime at 140 was relentless Judah wouldn't have time to breath he would be getting smothered and pounded to the body eventually getting stopped.

Hatton in his 'prime' was unproven. It doesn't matter how relentless you are if you are unskilled. Judah has the power to hurt him, he has the tools to stop him and his earlier days footwork and movement to dance around Hatton.

Compare them ability wise and compare them resume wise Judah beats him on both accounts. You claim that Judah is a mental midget but what fighters broke him down Mayweather ( Who broke down Hatton) and Cotto. Hardly a great shame.

[D-MiZe]

It doesn't matter how relentless you are if you are unskilled.

Moron.

[FeFist]

Moron.

Is Hatton skilled? No. He cannot keep his composure when punching either lunging in or dropping his hands, he does those things because he doesn't have the technique to throw a meaningful punch without loading up. It led to him getting a checkhook from Mayweather, it led to him getting flattened by Pacquiao, it makes him predictable.

His defense is poor which is why when he fought fighters with the capability of hurting him he looked like a fish out of water. It is why he was finished soon after getting hurt, he lacks the ability to tie up and go on the evasive when he needs time to recover.

His offense consist of clinching and punching, effective in his backyard not on the big stage which is why clowns are still crying about Cortez screwing him over for forcing him to box ( How dare he).

He can't adapt even when he has a month to do so ''Right 'ook roll under..... same move every fookin time''.

But if you want to think I am moron for slating his abilities go right ahead.

[-Lowkey-]

Hatton in his 'prime' was unproven. It doesn't matter how relentless you are if you are unskilled. Judah has the power to hurt him, he has the tools to stop him and his earlier days footwork and movement to dance around Hatton.

Compare them ability wise and compare them resume wise Judah beats him on both accounts. You claim that Judah is a mental midget but what fighters broke him down Mayweather ( Who broke down Hatton) and Cotto. Hardly a great shame.

Judah in his prime on the other hand was proven....A proven failure who lost nearly all of his big fights.

Judah crumbles under pressure even Carlos Baldomir had enough to take prime Zab away from his game plan with pressure and aggression Zab looked uncomfortable throughout.

Zab would stand a punchers chance early vs Hatton after that he fades gets beat up and stopped there is no doubt in my mind about that at all.

[D-MiZe]

If you don't think Hatton is skilled, you've obviously not watched him fight. I'm not going to dispute the fact his defense was poor most of time but his foot work, ability to cut off the ring, throwing from angles etc are all underrated aspects of Hatton's game.

Hatton never looked like a fish out of water against opponents that could hurt him. He took their best shots and continued to pressure. His lifestyle played a big part in his downfall.

[hhs661]

I was a big Judah fan as he was coming up in the ranks but I'm going with Hatton on this one

[-Lowkey-]

Is Hatton skilled? No. He cannot keep his composure when punching either lunging in or dropping his hands, he does those things because he doesn't have the technique to throw a meaningful punch without loading up. It led to him getting a checkhook from Mayweather, it led to him getting flattened by Pacquiao, it makes him predictable.

His defense is poor which is why when he fought fighters with the capability of hurting him he looked like a fish out of water. It is why he was finished soon after getting hurt, he lacks the ability to tie up and go on the evasive when he needs time to recover.

His offense consist of clinching and punching, effective in his backyard not on the big stage which is why clowns are still crying about Cortez screwing him over for forcing him to box ( How dare he).

He can't adapt even when he has a month to do so ''Right 'ook roll under..... same move every fookin time''.

But if you want to think I am moron for slating his abilities go right ahead.

Hatton was never the most skilled fighter no ones saying he was but neither was Judah and since when do you have to be a master boxer to beat the likes of Zab Judah? that wouldn't be a factor Baldomir wasn't a skilled fighter he still had enough to beat Zab.

[RichCCFC]

the one who beat Tszyu