Greatest P4P All-Time: Pac, PBF, B-Hop, R-Jones, Pernell, or Chavez Sr

[icha]

Rank the following against each other in the all-time greatest P4P list:

Bernard Hopkins, Manny Pacquiao, Julio Caesar Chavez, Roy Jones, Floyd Mayweather, Pernell Whitaker

I have all six of these guys somewhere between number 16 and number 25 all time. And here is how I rank them against each other within that list.

Roy

Pac

B-Hop

Floyd

Pernell

Chavez

What's your ranking?

no love for duran??

[The Big Dunn]

Ranked against each other (assuming they'd fight in their primes, who would I pick)

Floyd
Roy
Pernell
Pac
Bhop
Chavez Sr.

You can easily switch Roy and Floyd as prime Roy was virtually unbeatable.

[IMDAZED]

Roy, Pernell and Mayweather are really really close as top three.

[LetOutTheCage]

Hopkins
Mayweather
Pac
Jones
Pernell
Chavez

[jypehob]

Aside from making Chavez sr "Look dumb" can someone please tell me what Whitakers signature wins are?

[Dr Rumack]

Roy is #1

Floyd and Pac are #2 and #3 however you prefer.

B-Hop, Chavez, and Sweet Pea next.

With the possible exception Roy the rest fall between the 20 and 35 mark. But who can be precise about that stuff.

[DARKSEID]

From that list I would have to go with Bernard Hopkins.

I might pick Floyd but we was never really tested in his career. He never fought the best at their best.

[Zaroku]

This guy is something else.

What a hilarious analogy. You really live in a fantasy world.

He does! He dreams of PAC !

[Santa_]

1. Roy Jones Jr

2. Manny Pacquiao

3. Floyd Mayweather

4. Julio Cesar Chavez

5. Pernell Whitaker

6. Bernard Hopkins

[eco1]

Duran!!!!!