who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[Brandish]

larry i agree with you. pernell is not better then floyd resume or skill wise. he had defense but his offense was no were near floyds.

when pernell fought oscar people make excuses for him but he was only 33 no one told him to take cocaine on a regular.

pernell ruined his own career by taking drugs and not taking care of his body. floyd is the exacy opposite thats why he is better all-time

[COACH WEBB]

Like I said twice before, this is still going on?

[bojangles1987]

Like I said twice before, this is still going on?

Duran is a flat footed carbon copy of baldomir

With posts like this, how would this thread not keep going. This is great.

[SkillspayBills]

Floyd's career isn't over yet. Still has at least 3 fights left. Skill wise I go with Floyd. Top 5 most skilled fighter of all time, Resume wise I go with Pernell for the moment.

[-PBP-]

The statement that Floyd beat more champions is incorrect. I even gave Floyd the benefit of the doubt and inclufrd NABF and NABO champions.

Champions defeated by Mayweather:

Hernandez
Jukko
Vargas
Corrales
Hernandez
Chavez
Castillo x 2
Corley
Bruseles
Judah
Baldo
Gatti
Mitchell
De La Hoya
Hatton
Marquez
Mosley
Ortiz
Cotto

Total: 20

Whitaker:

Mayweather
Ramirez x 2
Haugen
Pendleton
Nelson
Nazario
Chavez
Rivera x2
Hurtado
McGirt x 2
Cardona
Vazquez
Rodriguez
Jones
Pineda
Paez
Brazier

Total: 20

I'm going to check these othet statements too

[Larry the boss]

Like I said twice before, this is still going on?

yea we going all night

[SkillspayBills]

What's with some of the users in this thread. People disagree and all of a sudden someone is a nuthugge, a hater or know nothing about boxing. SMFH it's an OPINION.

[DiegoFuego]

I wouldn't be surprised if 50 of the people who voted for Pernell Whitaker have never seen any of his fights. That's how hated Mayweather is.

[Roman Moreno]

What's with some of the users in this thread. People disagree and all of a sudden someone is a nuthugge, a hater or know nothing about boxing. SMFH it's an OPINION.

It's not just about disagreeing, is how you disagree. For example, Mosley LW resume>>>>Nelson career resume.

Or Whitaker win over Azumah Nelson is just as good as Floyd win over Zab Judah.

If you have no idea who Whitaker or his opponents are or accomplished and pick Floyd. That's fine, it's ignorance is not knowing, it's cool.

However, to pretend and act like you know, and still say the crap that has been said on here like Duran is a carbon copy of Baldomir. And, Mosley is a top 20 ATG. Then yes nuthugger, hater, not knowing about boxing comes into play and it's well deserved.

[-PBP-]

Here's p4 p victories. Only includes guys that were on the list when they faced them:

Floyd:
Marquez #3
Hatton #8
Corrales #5
Mosley #3

Whitaker:
Chavez #1
McGirt#5
Nelson #7

Take that how you want it