Who has created better songs

[led]

Paul McCartney or Billy Joel?

[ßringer]

If we're talking strictly solo stuff here, Billy wins by way of landslide.

If you factor in the **** Paul did with John then that's a different story.

[led]

If we're talking strictly solo stuff here, Billy wins by way of landslide.

If you factor in the **** Paul did with John then that's a different story.

As solo artist.

I don't see the landslide. Paul had Live and Let die, My Love, Let em in, Pipes of peace etc, to counter Billy's.

[ßringer]

Billy has 'Piano Man', 'Goodnight, Saigon', 'Only The Good Die Young', 'Vienna' 'New York State of Mind', 'Summer Highland Falls', 'Just The Way You Are', 'Captain Jack', 'Scenes From An Italian Restaurant', and about a dozen others that were equally fantastic.

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

Terrible comparison, I mean Paul McCartney is on another level as far as song writing is concerned. I'm not even a huge fan of the Beatles and Wings but he's a beast in the song writing game.

[led]

Terrible comparison, I mean Paul McCartney is on another level as far as song writing is concerned. I'm not even a huge fan of the Beatles and Wings but he's a beast in the song writing game.

I hope when you said that it's a terrible comparison, it's just a personal opinion because...

It's like you just said that Bringer's taste on music is shit.