Floyd is P4P #2 ever after SRR?

[fight_professor]

It was meant as a light-hearted joke but, going by my rep, it seems I've hit a nerve with someone on this thread

Wasnt me bro. I would never neg rep over a legit difference in opinion.

[Ray Corso]

I have him at number 6 1/4!!!!! .............but by the time the "picking" is over he could be #2!!!!! . HA!!!

[Bolo Punch]

Or fart_professor.

Wasnt me bro. I would never neg rep over a legit difference in opinion.

I know, I know. You took the joke well. Someone must've misinterpreted and thought I was hating - not at all, I just don't rank him that highly.

[JAB5239]

skillwise, the best ever, resume wise, he'll never get there. he'd have to do some superhuman feat like move up and beat the likes of martinez and ward and that will never happen.

I think Duran is better all around skillwise. Possibly Benny Leonard. Benitez is up there, Whitaker and a lot of others. Pretty tough to say Floyd is the best in my opinion. Definitely amongst the most skilled though.

[Barn]

I think Floyd is right up there with Duran and Whitaker and whoever.

He doesn't get appreciated enough by the real boxing fans in my opinion. We are watching one of the best there ever will be and some refuse to notice it.

Although resume wise he leaves a lot to be desired when compared with some, perhaps less skilled, greats.

[fight_professor]

He has faced all comers in his era.

[JAB5239]

He has faced all comers in his era.

He fights twice a year. Take the ATG's I named earlier and they fought better fighters and more often. Do you not factor that in?

[Capaedia]

****, you could say that depending on how you rank fighters. Most wont agree with you but its totally your call.

Its all speculation and subjective so you couldnt be outright wrong.

Marquez' facial hair < Robinsons. Thus i rank him higher.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[bravestone]

What the **** really?



Whitaker
Roy Jones
Hopkins


That's just this era. Then you have Canzoneri, Saddler, Williams, Gans, Langford, Leonard, Ross etc.

Ugh.

[bravestone]

He fights twice a year. Take the ATG's I named earlier and they fought better fighters and more often. Do you not factor that in?

Willie Joyce beat Ike Williams 3 times in 6 months. Beat Zivic, Jenkins, etc.