Top 5 P4P Ranking

[CrowsNestWest]

All-Time:
SRR, Willie Pep, Larry Holmes, Ali, Julio Cesar Chavez Sr.
Current:
Mikey Garcia, Terrence Crawford, Lomachenko, Olek Usyk, Gennady Golovkin

[DuckAdonis]

Ray Robinson
Floyd Mayweather
Muhammad Ali
Roy Jones
Ray Leonard

[aAgger]

Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Robinson
Sugar Ray Leonard
Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather

[Zmerai Khan]

I suspect you're an alt and a troll.

And I believe you're exactly the kinda trick who licks stale peanut butter off my balls and tells me she loves me after she gets 2 black eyes.

[Zmerai Khan]

Top 5 ain’t bad, but ofc the loma comment is lulz.

Says a guy named "battlingnelson". You are not embarrassed by that?


Tell me, who've you seen that more impressive than lomachenko? Is it that his fights are recorded in color that you hold against him? Or maybe you're unsatisfied because he never had the chance to dodge packey MacFarland?

Forgive me for already laughing.

[Zmerai Khan]

Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Robinson
Sugar Ray Leonard
Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather

Bwahahaha ? Greatest at what? Getting arrested by StopandFrisk?


Ali got busted up by Frazier and outboxed by Norton. What about any of that screams GOAT!?!?!?

Mayweather looked lost against ODLH, struggled even more with maidana and castillo, and his wins against JMM and Canelo came under very suspect circumstances.

Leonard was blatantly outclassed against Duran - whom you fail to mention.

[Zmerai Khan]

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Harry Greb
4. Willie Pep
5. Roberto Duran

Honorable mentions: Benny Leonard, Sam Langford, Eder Jofre, Ezzard Charles, Muhammad Ali

Who did armstrong beat?

And which of history's great lightweights do you pick him to beat?

Greb and Robinson were the same size... Robinson a little bigger... who's resume is better? (Obvious hint: the guy from Pittsburgh).

[Zmerai Khan]

1. Roy Jones Jr
2. Sugar Ray Robinson
3. Mayweather Jr
4. Roberto Duran
5. Ali

The same roy Jones that got starched every time he was backed up to the ropes?

You know this is a GOAT list, right?

[JAB5239]

And I believe you're exactly the kinda trick who licks stale peanut butter off my balls and tells me she loves me after she gets 2 black eyes.

Says a guy named "battlingnelson". You couldn't think of anything more pathetic? How shameless do you have to be to pick that username?


Tell me, who've you seen that more impressive than lomachenko?

Forgive me for already laughing.

Bwahahaha ? Greatest at what? Getting arrested by StopandFrisk?


Ali got busted up by Frazier and outboxed by Norton. What about any of that screams GOAT!?!?!?

Mayweather looked lost against ODLH, struggled even more with maidana and castillo, and his wins against JMM and Canelo came under very suspect circumstances.

Leonard was blatantly outclassed against Duran - whom you fail to mention.

Who did armstrong beat?

And which of history's great lightweights do you pick him to beat?

Greb and Robinson were the same size... Robinson a little bigger... who's resume is better? (Obvious hint: the guy from Pittsburgh).

The same roy Jones that got starched every time he was backed up to the ropes?

You know this is a GOAT list, right?

Definitely an alt and a troll.

[Zmerai Khan]

Definitely an alt and a troll.

Yeah, or just, yeah know, somebody who actually bases his opinion on fact. Endless hours of footage exist. Most of it is available for free. You too can have an educated opinion substantiated by evidence, if you only try.


I saw you're list. Maybe I was too critical. But easy too many people on these boards come across as arrogant based on their ability to regurgitate the opinions of others, rather than form their own. Lomachenko is damn near perfect.